I just returned from giving a Commonweal Lecture at the University of Wyoming to discover that George Weigel reads dotCommonweal. Good for him!So . . . the Newsweek column. Doug Kmiec, Nick Cafardi and I will be responding in Newsweek in a more substantive fashion. Here, a few quick comments just for the dotCommonweal crowd.1. "Obamapologetics"? George, George. You can do better than that. It's awkward. And obvious. No one likes a good neologism better than I do. But this is simply beyond the Palin.2. Political Dedication Is No Excuse for Bad Proofreading. In paragraph five, Weigel writes:"Her argument, in sum: the constitutional and legal arguments that have raged since Roe vs. Wade are over, and Catholics have lost; there are many other "intrinsic evils" that Catholics are morally bound to oppose, and Republicans tend to ignore those evils; liberalized social-welfare policies will drive down the absolute numbers of abortions and Senator Obama is an unabashed liberal on these matters. Therefore, a vote for Obama is the 'real' pro-life vote."The argument he's just summarized is Nick Cafardi's argument, not my argument (although it's a powerful one). Weigel must have meant "His argument," not "Her argument. " In fact, he doesn't actually mention any of my arguments at all. Maybe he meant to suggest that my spirit was somehow poured out over all the arguments --but I would guess that this pneumatology would be a little too close to feminist theology for his taste.It must have been a typo.3. But Seriously Folks . . . And abortion is a serious issue. As a lawyer and a moralist, I've been thinking about it, both in political season and out of it, for twenty years now. If you want to know what I think, as opposed to what others say I think, here is an article I published in Origins a few years ago.Its M. Cathleen Kaveny, How Views of Law Influence the Pro-Life Movement, Origins 34:35 at 560ff (February 17, 2005).

Cathleen Kaveny is the Darald and Juliet Libby Professor in the Theology Department and Law School at Boston College.

Also by this author

Please email comments to [email protected] and join the conversation on our Facebook page.

© 2024 Commonweal Magazine. All rights reserved. Design by Point Five. Site by Deck Fifty.