A Senate vote is expected this week on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA), a bill that aims to streamline permitting for major infrastructure projects. Technical and focused on procedure, BAAJA might not be an obvious lightning rod for disagreement. Leaders from diverse industries, areas of expertise, and political commitments agree that permitting reform is needed to make necessary upgrades to our energy grid—especially, some advocates insist, growing renewable-energy capacity. But the effects of BAAJA’s provisions are contested, and the intense, complicated disagreements about process and legal rights reflect interesting philosophical differences within the Democratic Party and the environmental movement over the risks worth taking.
The almost-five-hundred-page bill contains many highly specific proposals better left to experts to explain. But three broad measures stand out. First, BAAJA would simplify the rules for building or upgrading transmission infrastructure and equipment that move power from its generation source to local substations. It would allow the federal government to override state-level inaction and require artificial-intelligence companies to pay for data-center transmission. (Steve Vladeck provides a helpful breakdown of the entire bill, including this change.) Transmission reforms are widely supported, and advocates of renewable energy argue that they would allow for more renewables to be added to the grid.
Second, BAAJA would streamline the permitting process by limiting the ability of affected parties to use existing environmental laws to challenge new projects. This includes shortening the National Environmental Policy Act’s challenge-filing window and weakening the right of states and tribes to cite Clean Water Act provisions in seeking conditions on projects affecting their waterways. It also gives “substantial deference” to the agency approving a project in cases of judicial review of NEPA violations. It would, in Vladeck’s words, “reshape the remedies available across a major category of federal litigation.”
Third, the bill would institute “project certainty”—meaning that once a project has passed the permitting process, it can be canceled only under a limited set of conditions, such as a court order. This is to prevent future administrations from canceling projects for political or ideological reasons.
Major energy companies overwhelmingly support BAAJA. The bill is “technology neutral”—fossil-fuel and renewable-energy providers will both benefit. Because the majority of projects in permitting limbo are for renewables, climate proponents believe that carbon emissions will ultimately decrease even if new fossil-fuel infrastructure is brought online in the short term, since over the longer term green energy will win out as costs keep coming down. As Senator Martin Heinrich (D-NM), one of BAAJA’s sponsors, put it, “If we can create an open, competitive level playing field, clean is cheap, and cheap wins in the marketplace.” Proponents of the bill also argue that the project-certainty provision means that the Trump administration won’t be able to continue canceling or buying out renewable-energy leases approved in previous administrations.
But, as opponents of BAAJA point out, that sword cuts two ways: it would be impossible for future administrations to halt the build-out of fossil-fuel infrastructure that the Trump administration, deeply hostile to renewable energy, would likely implement given a streamlined permitting process. Perhaps this is why the American Petroleum Institute and Big Oil executives have thrown the full weight of their lobbying might to push for BAAJA’s passage—something that “should give any climate advocate pause,” as environmental journalist Dana Drugmand writes. Big Tech also backs it because it will speed the construction of data centers.
Tribal organizations argue that the bill impinges on their sovereignty. The NAACP says that it “directly threatens the health, safety, and future of Black and frontline communities.” More than two dozen health organizations have cosigned a letter to senators stating, “We cannot in good conscience support any proposal that endangers communities or impedes them from taking actions to protect themselves from health and environmental harm.”
The fault line between climate-concerned supporters and climate-concerned critics of BAAJA seems to be whether market solutions—or “leveling the playing field,” as Heinrich said—are really going to bring a renewable-energy future. Today, some call this the “Abundance” agenda: regulations have become burdensome and clunky, so let’s deregulate to get back to building things again. (We might also go back to calling it neoliberalism.) Ezra Klein, one of the popularizers of the Abundance agenda, writes approvingly that BAAJA “represents Democrats and Republicans deciding that the fight over what gets built should play out in elections and markets rather than in the bowels of administrative agencies and courts.”
But does BAAJA really “level the playing field” for the market to choose renewables? Political power will be just as important in determining what gets built. Trump is all-in for BAAJA because, as he said on social media, it will “codify our America First Energy Agenda and ensure that we can build Pipelines, Mines, and Power Plants faster than ever before.” Presumably, he does not mean wind-power plants: he told reporters, “I will not approve wind turbines because wind turbines are a major loser.” As Rebecca Crosby and Noel Sims at Popular Information point out, this is at odds with what Senator Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI), one of the bill’s cosponsors, claimed: that BAAJA’s passage relies on the Trump administration’s support for wind energy. (Whitehouse said we can “chalk [Trump’s comments] up to him being eighty.”) As Al Gore argues, “The president of the United States is in charge of implementing whatever legislation is passed and he doesn’t play by the rules, he doesn’t respect the law and it’s not a mystery how he would try to implement this legislation…. It would lock in a lot of new pipelines and fossil fuel facilities.”
What’s perhaps most concerning is that what Trump, many Republicans, and the fossil-fuel industry plan to get from the bill is in contradiction to what its Democratic supporters claim it can achieve. Perhaps there’s something to be said for the bipartisan support a “technology-neutral” bill has garnered. But if the transmission provisions of the bill are so popular, why not pass just those, without all of the measures that would weaken environmental protections and legal recourse?
And with a new Democratic-controlled Congress, why not go further? Introduce a bill that isn’t “technology neutral” but that actually favors renewable energy. It’s true that Democrats won’t have a veto-proof majority. But that means doing the work of politics: convince people to support the transition from fossil fuels to renewables. The affordability argument is there for the making.
It would be a mistake to give more power to the Trump administration and its oil-industry and Big Tech allies. They have made abundantly clear what they intend to use BAAJA for. Even if more renewable energy does come online, the trade-off—more fossil fuels, more emissions, more data centers, and still more environmental destruction—simply isn’t worth it.
We welcome your comments about this article. Please send your response to [email protected].