'Don't hang around this area.'

At a Romney event in New Hampshire on Monday, a Harvard Kennedy and Divinity School student named Matt Bieber was asked by two police officers to leave the premises because, as he writes on his blog, the police said that "the campaign has identified you as someone who was at a protest at Romneys office in Manchester. Bieber told the police that he didn't even know there had been protests at Romney's New Hampshire HQ. He asked to speak to someone from the campaign, but the police refused. He asked to speak to the owner of the venue. No. Not that it would have mattered: "The company had delegated authority to the campaign, and the campaign had authorized the police to remove anyone the campaign didnt want present," Bieber writes. After he asked the officers a few more questions, they had had enough. "You're under arrest," one of them said. They cuffed him, put him in the back of their police cruiser, took him to the police station, booked him, and put him in a cage.

An officer named Manni and another officer processed my paperwork. As they did so, they told me not to go back to that area when I was released. I indicated that I understood I wasnt permitted to be on the companys land or facilities, but surely I could go back to the street if I so chose its public property, after all. Dont go back to that area, they said. If you go back, you might cause a disturbance or a riot, and you could be arrested for disorderly conduct.I tried to keep calm and ask even-keeled questions. Were they telling me I wasnt even permitted in the street near the facility? And if so, on what grounds? I thought: Im not planning on starting any trouble, but if I wanted to go and express myself by talking to the media about what had happened, wasnt that my right?And then the following exchange took place. I began to ask, If I express my First Amendment freedoms And Officer Manni interjected, Youll probably be arrested.(...)It was clear to me that the two officers had no interest in discussing what the law actually said, or what my rights actually entailed. I was paperwork, and they wanted to get it over with. I kept asking questions, and at one point, one of them opened up the New Hampshire legal code and read me the definition of disorderly conduct. He read the words dully, as if they were just syllables, with no interest at all in what they meant.I asked the officer if he could help me connect what hed just read with my situation and understand why it would be a problem to return to the street outside the event. He told me that I might return and say things that arent what others think.

Live free or die.Read the rest here. And more here.

Grant Gallicho joined Commonweal as an intern and was an associate editor for the magazine until 2015. 

Please email comments to [email protected] and join the conversation on our Facebook page.

Must Reads

Politics
Books
Books