In Defense of Indie Music

A little over a week agHelplessness Blueso, I read Paul ODonnells post on Wilco with eagerness. I love the band, and I was excited to see a Commonweal writer engaging with popular music so enthusiastically. (The post reminded me of Eric Bugyiss interesting thoughts on the Hold Steady.)Then, however, I got to the comments. There I found an awful lot of doom and gloom being proclaimed. Young people and their music are embittered and whiny, I heard; they express no hope in humanity; all popular music (or at least all somewhat popular indie rock) is just so much rhythmic moping.Of course, this isnt a true assessment of young people or their cultural expressions. Speaking from my own area of expertise, I can tell you that the defining characteristic of fiction in the last fifteen or so years has been an increase in sincerity and hopefulness. People like Dave Eggers and David Foster Wallace have argued again and again that an ironic, embittered attitude towards the world isnt enough, and that any art that reflexively resigns itself to this kind of attitude is necessarily impoverished. One of the major projects of post-post-modernism (or whatever you want to call our current moment) is the reclaiming of huge swathes of human experiencelove, joy, commitment, sacrificeas viable subjects for literary representation.But, looking back to music, I want to point out one band that should disprove any sweeping claims about the self-indulgent despair of my generation: Fleet Foxes. The band hails from Seattle, and it shows in their predilection for flannel shirts, unkempt beards, and long hair. Their sound, however, is anything but grungy. The bands 2008 self-entitled debut album was filled with sweet-sounding harmonizing and pleasing melodies. (And the band appeared unembarrassed to write and perform sweet, pleasing songs.) Displaying a variety of influences from Neil Young to gospel and sacred harp music, Fleet Foxes was really more a tone poem than anything else: singer/songwriter Robin Pecknold seemed less interested in telling a story than in creating a particular mood or feel. The title of the albums most popular song, White Winter Hymnal, hints at this mood: light, mysterious, haunting, angelic. (Here is a lyrical sample: I was following the pack, / All swallowed in their coats / With scarves of red tied round their throats / To keep their little heads / From fallin in the snow. Lest this sound overly precious, listen to the song, through Spotify.) Fleet Foxes was a tremendous debut. The songs were lush and moving, with Pecknolds lyrics often beautifully blending into a kind of choral chanting.

The bands most recent album, the 2011 Helplessness Blues, is even stronger. Pecknolds lyrics have become clearer without losing their poetic suggestiveness. This time, Fleet Foxes has a particular, compelling story to tell: the story of a young man reaching adulthood and trying to figure out what kind of life he wants to lead. (Pecknold was born two years after me, so I share many of his concerns.) The albums first song, Montezuma, introduces the albums major theme: So now I am older, / Than my mother and father / When they had their daughter. / Now what does that say about me? Much has been made of my generations delayed adolescencethe NY Times seems to run a story every other week about college graduates moving back in with their parentsand Pecknold here and throughout grapples with the need to grow up, to move beyond childish selfishness to a more mature selflessness. At one point he wonders, How could I dream of / Such a selfless and true love? Could I wash my hands of / Just lookin out for me? This is the albums main concern: how to give of oneself so as to become more truly oneself.The albums title track, Helplessness Blues, opens with a description of our cultures obsession with uniqueness: I was raised up believin / I was somehow unique / Like a snowflake, distinct among snowflakes / Unique in each way you can see. This attitude, however, has left Pecknold unmoved: Now, after some thinkin / Id say Id rather be / A functionin' cog in some great machinery / Servin somethin beyond me. He doesnt yet know what this greater cause will beit could be social, political, artistic, maybe even romantic but the desire and hope for what Iris Murdoch calls unselfing is palpable. Again, the bands lack of embarrassment is refreshing. They are unafraid to ask the largest of questionswhat is a good life?and they are unafraid to admit that they dont yet know the answer.Despite its title, the album is precisely an argument against helplessness and unthinking despair. By the end of the title track, Pecknold still hasnt figured things out: maybe he should open an orchard, he thinks, and find happiness in working the land. (This pastoral dream is a recurring one for the band: in both Bedouin Dress and The Shrine / An Argument, there are allusions to Innisfree, the ideal pastoral landscape of W. B. Yeats.) For now, all he can do is marvel at, and hope to do justice to, the beauty that surrounds him:

If I know only one thingIts that everything that I seeOf the world outside is so inconceivableOften I barely can speak.Yeah, Im tongue-tied and dizzyAnd I cant keep it to myself.What good is it to sing helplessness blues?Why should I wait for anyone else?

Turning wonder into song, and sharing this song with others: its a traditional move for folk music, and its something that Fleet Foxes does extremely well. And in pulling it off, they show that, in both popular music and in my generation broadly speaking, there is reason for hope.

Anthony Domestico is an assistant professor of literature at Purchase College, SUNY, and the author of Poetry and Theology in the Modernist Period (Johns Hopkins University Press, 2017). He writes Commonweal's "Bookmarks" column.

Also by this author
Back to Campus

Please email comments to [email protected]ne.org and join the conversation on our Facebook page.

Must Reads

Politics
Religion
Books
Collections