A blog by the magazine's editors and contributors


Band of Sisters: NYC Premiere

Band of Sisters, a new documentary film now showing at New York City's Cinema Village until January 30th, features sisters from eleven different congregations who all share the unique story of being American Catholic nuns who entered convents before Vatican II, and whose vocations were radically transformed by the council's documents.

American women religious are portrayed as themselves -- obedient risk-takers whose elevation from selfess servants to community leaders is natural and justified. The sisters narrate their story against a backdrop of juxtaposed images and stories: black-and-white footage of thousands of habits bending to pick lillies on convent grounds; today's sisters in overalls showcasing their organic farms; hundreds of pews full of heads bowed in prayer; nuns well into their eighties lobbying for access to immigrant detention centers; the letter from Pius XII urging U.S. congregations to create "a network" that would become the LCWR; Rome's investigation of the LCWR's "faithfulness to mission" under Benedict XVI; collared schoolmarms keeping order in classrooms; grey-haired women getting arrested at the School of the America's protest; and much more.

Nancy Sylvester, IHM, says her original motives for entering the convent were to love God and to be perfect. She did not anticipate enacting these goals beside laypeople as a lobbyist in Washington. “That idea that nuns and priests are better than the rest of the church really changed with Vatican II. We took seriously the Universal Call to Holiness.” But as the spirit of Vatican II was dimmed subsequent years of contradicting leadership in Rome, questions were raised on which rules to follow – theological questions, doctrinal rules.

Since it's sold-out 2012 premiere in Chicago, Band of Sisters has visited over 60 cities without a paid marketing campaign. It's director Mary Fishman’s first film -- she left her job as an architect and urban planner and began the project in 2004 after taking a few film courses. Thinking back to "all those nuns" who taught at her elementary and high school, she wondered what happened to them, and she was amazed at what she learned. The more she read about the real women and their great accomplishments, the angrier she became about the stereotypes. In making this film, she not only debunks stereotypes about nuns, but puts them in the applauding public light they deserve.


About the Author

Kaitlin Campbell is Commonweal's Assistant Digital Editor.

1 comment

1 comment

Commenting Guidelines

  • All

Looks great. I watched the trailer. One sister said, apparently in retort to the Vatican visitation, "I have been a sister for 50 years and now you are going to tell me I am unfaithful...I don't think so". POW...BANG

The sisters have the last word....yet again.... i can almost here the visitation documents being shelved and somebody must be saying "I told you so". From the Beguines in the medieval period right up to today, whenever Rome has tried to interfere with the sisters, it always backfires....big time (H/T to Cheney)

Add new comment

You may login with your assigned e-mail address.
The password field is case sensitive.

Or log in with...

Add new comment