Consistent Ethic of Life, Thirty Years Later

Rereading Joseph Bernardin

"The church is in a position to make a significant defense of life in a comprehensive and consistent manner." These were words spoken thirty years ago this week by Cardinal Joseph Bernardin at Fordham University, where he lectured on the U.S. bishops' pastoral letter The Challenge of Peace and formulated the framework for what would come to be known as the consistent ethic of life. We've asked four contributors to reflect on the lecture in light of current debates in the church and in politics, and to offer their thoughts on the legacy of Bernardin today.

Commonweal Roundtable: The Bernardin Lecture

This special symposium has been funded by a grant from the Henry Luce Foundation. You can read Joseph Bernardin's 1983 Fordham lecture in its entirety here [.pdf].

Ambivalent After All These Years

In his Fordham lecture Bernardin mentions abortion ten times. The word “fetus” appears twice, but the words “woman” and “women” do not appear at all.

Consistent, Comprehensive, Christ-inspired

Thirty years later one wonders how many recall the debates the lecture engendered. It bears re-reading; the challenges it poses may be even more pressing now.

The Original Culture Warrior?

Bernardin grasped the idea that the Church’s most important contribution to public life is in shaping a cultural consensus on attitude.

An Ethic of ‘Life,’ Not ‘Purity’

To say that Bernardin's consistent ethic of life did not catch on with the American hierarchy would be an understatement.
1 comment

1 comment

Commenting Guidelines

  • All

My goodness.  If may be nothing more than luck but perhaps not.  The posts by both women show depth, breadth and compassion.  Those by the males come off very much like lawyer "speak".  Clever enough but not so clever as to hide the erudition and the "I really am a caring lawyer, you now!".  Come on guys, we can do better.

Bernardin was from my home town.  My mother was not raised Catholic but she married one.  Bernardin she adored.  I am convinved easy accessiblity is a reliable trait of a genuine priest.  He had that in spades. 

Like so many I do so hope Pope Francis will continue to move his folk's attention toward a genuine, persistent conviction a "seamless garmet" is a great more than a pleasant metaphor for a gifted writer, however well intended.


Add new comment

You may login with your assigned e-mail address.
The password field is case sensitive.

Or log in with...

Add new comment