A blog by the magazine's editors and contributors


Liberty shut down

"Who's affected by the government shutdown?" "What does it mean for you?"

Those are the stories media outlets have ready to go today. There will be lots of worthy accounts. Already I got a text message from my best friend -- an Iraq veteran and cancer researcher in both the Public Health Service and the National Institutes of Health. "Not bad traffic today. LOL." Sometimes one has to laugh in the face of idiocy.

The NIH already suffered under sequestration, as Francis Collins tried valiantly to continue the world's leading medical research facilities despite across-the-board cuts. Also affected today will be the Center for Disease Control, the Environmental Protection Agency, and several other "common good" entities, the kind of organizations disrespected by the roughly 30 Republicans who shutdown the government last night.

As GOP insider Byron York noted yesterday, the Republicans overall did not want this.

"Analysts say the Congressional GOP doesn't understand strategy," the Republican said. "I'm like, 'Congressional GOP' my ass! It's 30 idiots who can't get us to 217."

This morning I'm wondering whom those 30 Republicans have in mind, when they think about the effects of a shutdown.

Do they ponder the Republican business-owner in Arizona, the one who has been trying to expand her workforce and do right by her employees, trying not to hire undocumented immigrants but also not to racially profile potential hires? Do they think of her, when she finds out that "E-verify" is not going to work this week?

Do they think of the Republican family of four from the midwest, they who saved up their money to give their oldest son what he asked for -- to visit the Statue of Liberty? Do they know that their mother went online months ago to reserve a prized set of tickets to go up into her crown? Do they know that boy is crumpled over in sobs right now at the ferry terminal because his family's 9:00 AM tickets are meaningless in the face of the red-letter signs: "IMPORTANT. GOVERNMENT SHUTDOWN"? Did they stop to ponder how much money they -- or any of the other 10,000 visitors per day to Lady Liberty -- spent on this once-in-a-lifetime trip to honor America?

Maybe the 30 radicals have forgotten the Republican business-owners in Estes Park, Colorado -- those whose town was ravaged by once-in-a-century floods, and whose federal aid is now at risk of drying up. As if that were not enough, Estes Park is one of many medium-sized towns in Republican territories that depend almost entirely on tourism to National Parks for their economy. Can Estes Park survive the floods and then the callous and unnecessary closing of Rocky Mountain National Park -- and that during fall foliage time?

Try giving a fear-mongering lecture on liberty vs. insurance marketplaces to the 700,000 daily visitors to our National Parks. The vast majority of citizens would shout it down. One of our 30 radicals could pick any one of the hysterical children at the gate of Yellowstone, Yosemite, or Glacier today. It's no big deal. They've only been saving and planning for this for years -- and been in the car for three straight days.

The other headlines we will see this week will talk about "gridlock" and "partisanship." That's journalistic malfeasance. It was estimated yesterday that over 175 Republicans in the House did not want this. Less than 10% of one chamber of Congress chose to do this.

Or we might consider the ridiculousness in a different way: the 2008 GOP presidential nominee has openly mocked them, and the 2012 GOP presidential nominee was the pioneer of the public policy over which they have shut down the government. The basic model of health insurance exchanges -- the insurance "marketplace" -- was a few years ago a signature move for their last presidential nominee!

But me, all I'm thinking about this morning are the kids crying at a barricaded gate, whether at a National Park or Battery Park -- kids merely wanting to see Old Faithful or Lady Liberty. I want those kids to feel the surge of patriotism that comes with America's open skies and open arms.

But they won't feel that love of country -- at least not today.


About the Author

Michael Peppard is associate professor of theology at Fordham University, author of The World's Oldest Church and The Son of God in the Roman World, and on Twitter @MichaelPeppard.



Commenting Guidelines

  • All

The 150 GOP reps are very afraid they may be 'primaried'. Yet they are not afraid to send  a 20 year old US soldier  to patrol an ally in any Muslim city they think needs to be invaded.and then slow up his paycheck.   

NPR accounts today state the obvious -- we are a divided country in whihc 48% think the government should help people and 48% do not (hope I've got that question right -verify!)

"Obamacare" is the symbol. Not sure there really is a middle ground here -- even for us Libra ENFPs.


I hope the folks who shut down our govt over Obamacare realize that Obamacare is still going forward even though other parts of the govt have come to a halt. Huge volume on the enrollent sites today..

Statue of Liberty closed. Yosemite closed. Flood victims stiffed. ACA open for business.

A caucus of turnips would be smarter than House Republicans.

The House GOP plan is to fund parts of the Government.... first.. the city of  Washington DC.

Obama promised to veto this. GOP thinks they have a gotcha if he does .. so maybe the turnips  think Ted Cruz will carry DC against Hillary. for pres.?????  .

Peace Corps shut down as well. (Though the volunteers are still serving overseas). 

And then there is this:

From "more educated" idiocy, may the Good Lord preserve us.

Add new comment

You may login with your assigned e-mail address.
The password field is case sensitive.

Or log in with...

Add new comment