A blog by the magazine's editors and contributors


Faith, Artifacts Of Character & Electing A President

As part of the lead-up to Frontline's new documentary, The Choice 2012, they've asked several close observers and biographers of Barack Obama and Mitt Romney to engage in what amounts to an online version of a roundtable discussion about the two men and the formative experiences of their lives.I found it to be a fascinating exchange. Take, for example, this entry from Obama biographer David Maraniss responding to an earlier observation by Jodi Kantor:That's right, Jodi, and it goes back even a decade before that speech, even before he became a community organizer in Chicago. In 1982 he wrote a letter to a girlfriend in which he described how his life was forcing him to an all-embracing philosophy. "Caught without a class, a structure, or tradition to support me, in a sense the choice to take a different path is made for me," he wrote. "The only way to assuage my feelings of isolation are to absorb all the traditions and all the classes; make them mine, mine theirs."

The entire conversation is filled with similarly close and perceptive observations about both men, structured in response to four "artifacts of character" presented by Frontline.I think we get a contemporary glimpse of this aspect of Pres. Obama in the latest campaign video produced to persuade "people of faith" to join and support his re-election. In both word and image, the video is broadly and---within the constraints of American civil religion---deeply inclusive. At a couple of points I hear (or think I hear) echoes of Catholic social teaching as transmuted through the Campaign for Human Development-funded community organizing work Obama did for a few years in the mid-1980s: the dignity of work, the inherent worth of all human beings.Given the powerful testimonies at the Republican National Convention from people who had encountered Mitt Romney in his role as a LDS stake president, I can't help but think that a similar fluency in speaking about faith, citizenship and politics from Gov. Romney would serve him (and his campaign) well.(I spent a bit of time searching YouTube and the Romney campaign website for a similar clip from and/or about Mitt Romney, but was unsuccessful. If anyone knows of one, please link to it in the comments.)

About the Author

Luke Hill is a writer and community organizer in Boston. He blogs at dotCommonweal and MassCommons. 



Commenting Guidelines

  • All

Ah, yes. This is the man that members of our hierarchy and clergy (even from the pulpit) have demonized from the very beginning of his presidency. (The nasty letters sent to Fr. Jenkins protesting the invitation of Obama to Notre Dames 2009 commencement and award were posted on the Cardinal Newman Society website.) At the U.S. bishops meeting last November Cardinal (then Archbishop) Dolan announced the foundation of a new Ad Hoc Committee on Religious Liberty chaired by Bishop Lori, who then gave a presentation followed by the bishops overwhelmingly approval of a 3% increase of their diocesan funding to the USCCB. It may not amount to much money from the individuals in the pews but how many U.S. Catholics are aware that part of their collection money is going to subsidize a group that has what I am coming to think a hidden agenda to prevent Obamas second term. Note: advisory board members, Carl Anderson, member of Reagans administration and Mary Ann Glendon, who did radio spots for Romney during the Republican primary, calling him the most pro-life candidate.

Ah, the hagiographies of true believers. It must be nice to be able to find your saints where you look for them.

A cynic is a man who, when he smells flowers, looks around for a coffin. H.L. Mencken

Good post, Luke Hill.

I will look forward to this video-- especailly post first debagte!I know there are reasonable critics, but is there anything that approached "Frontline" for incisive reporting that approaches fairness as much as possible? This isa traesure of PBS that we muct support!

Add new comment

You may login with your assigned e-mail address.
The password field is case sensitive.

Or log in with...

Add new comment