A blog by the magazine's editors and contributors


How Can A Poor Man Stand Such Times And Live?

For many musicians, New Orleans is as close to sacred ground as you can get in these United States.New Orleans holds Congo Square, the only place in the antebellum South where slaves could and did regularly gather to drum and to dance.New Orleans produced Louis Armstong, whose use of the backbeat revolutionized popular music worldwide and is the basis for his claim to the title of "Most Influential Musician Of The 20th Century".Jazz was born in New Orleans. (The word "jazz" itself is likely derived from Gaelic.) As was "The Queen of Gospel", Mahalia Jackson.

At the birth of rock and roll, before there was Elvis Presley (upriver in Memphis), there was the Creole-speaking, piano-playing, New Orleans native, Fats Domino (whose own birth was midwifed by his ex-slave grandmother).It is partly because of that history that there was such a tremendous musical outpouring in the wake of Hurricane Katrina. Hundreds of musicians from across the full spectrum of American popular music wrote and recorded scores of songs for and about New Orleans and the "criminal ineptitude" (to quote one of them) of our government that led to the drowning of a great American city.Now, on the 7th anniversary of Katrina's landfall, New Orleans is again being deluged, this time by Hurricane Isaac. Simultaneously, the Republican Party, gathered in convention across the Gulf, is making clear---by the platform it has adopted and the candidates it has chosen----that its major criticism of the previous Republican administration is that it was too compassionate and not "conservative" enough.Bruce Springsteen's updating of Blind Alfred Reed's 1929 song, "How Can A Poor Man Stand Such Times And Live?", may not be the best song to emerge from what happened to New Orleans after the levees broke. It does, however, capture something of the enduring shame, guilt and anger many Americans feel about what happened and, perhaps, something of their determination not to let it happen again. (Here's a performance from earlier this year at Jazz Fest.)

About the Author

Luke Hill is a writer and community organizer in Boston. He blogs at dotCommonweal and MassCommons. 



Commenting Guidelines

  • All

Ann Olivier, please check in!

Hi, Jean,Here I am, in New Orleans. I'm doing well, thank you, except there's no power, except for this trusty iPnone's. I can recharge it in my car. Best invention yet, I tell you :-)

Glad to hear you're well. I hope Jeff Landry and any/all other readers/commenters in the area are also alive, well, and not too flooded out.

Ann, you take care!

Add new comment

You may login with your assigned e-mail address.
The password field is case sensitive.

Or log in with...

Add new comment