Just when you thought things couldn't get worse for the Obama administration, Dr. Donohue drops another bombshell:
The problems with the IRS extend beyond playing politics with conservative groups seeking a tax-exempt status. I have never made this public before, but given the heightened interest
MORE
Today Attorney General Eric Holder enjoyed a relaxing day on Capitol Hill, where he engaged in mutually enriching dialog with the House Judiciary Committee at a hearing on “Oversight of the United States Department of Justice.” During a particularly warm exchange with Rep. Louie Gohmert (R-Tex
MORE
This morning the Vatican released a curt statement announcing that Cardinal Keith O'Brien, who recently resigned as Archbishop of St. Andrews and Edinburgh -- before the mandatory retirement age of seventy-five -- after admitting improper sexual conduct, will be leaving Scotland for a while to
MORE
Remember how in January, after nearly a decade of legal filibustering, the Archdiocese of Los Angeles finally made public the priest-personnel files it agreed to release as part of a 2007 settlement with abuse victims, except the files were heavily redacted, and remember how those files contained
MORE
Over the past few days, several limbs of conservative media have been vibrating with the fear that the Department of Defense was about to hatch a dark plot to persecute military personnel -- including chaplains -- for "sharing their faith." Some critics found those claims unpersuasive.
MORE
Today the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops announced that it has hired Kim Daniels to be a spokeswoman for Cardinal Timothy Dolan, whose term as USCCB president ends in November. (This is a new position, and Sr. Mary Ann Walsh remains director of media relations.) "Daniels brings to the
MORE
One of the Boston marathon suspects is dead and the other is on the run. (Graphic: NTN
MORE
Let's stipulate at the outset that the trial of Kermit Gosnell -- who is charged with murdering seven babies and one patient in his nightmarish, unmonitored Philadelphia abortion mill -- which began on March 18, should have received more coverage from national media outlets. (You can catch up with
MORE
What happens when well-wishers ask Pope Francis if he can try on the new zucchetto they brought him, and a cardinal says he can't? You get one guess
MORE
In today's L'Osservatore Romano, Cardinal Walter Kasper argues that by emphasizing social justice -- and nods toward collegiality -- Pope Francis has inaugurated a new phase of Vatican II. John Thavis reports:
“In this sense, Pope Francis from the first day of his pontificate has given what I
MORE
From Commonweal's April 26, 1963, editorial:
If the past is any guide in these matters, the Catholic response to Pope John's magnificent encyclical Pacem in Terris will be slow and tentative. This is not to say that there will not be initial praise and publicity; that much at least is traditional
MORE
Deirdre McQuade, spokeswoman for the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops Secretariat for Prolife Activities, comments on a federal judge's decision to allow the emergency-contraception drug known as Plan B to be sold over the counter to women of any age:
Plan B does not prevent or treat any
MORE
In a meeting today with Archbishop Gerhard Ludwig Muller, prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the faith, Pope Francis urged him to "act decisively" against sexual abuse, "continuing along the lines set by Benedict XVI," according to a Vatican news release. How?
MORE
From Commonweal's April 19, 1968, editorial:
White America has had another chance thrust before it, the chance provided by the violent death of a just man. The Kerner report, acknowledged and then quickly brushed aside a few weeks ago, is still there with its plethora of useful recommendations
MORE
As I moved through St. Peter's Square pestering every American I could find, I noticed a trend. Young Catholics kept bringing up the same concerns about their faith: how the church treats abuse victims, gays and lesbians, people of other religions -- and women. (I wrote up some of that in the
MORE
From our editorial on the election of Pope Francis:
Anyone who followed media coverage of the papal conclave that elected the Argentine Jorge Mario Bergoglio, now Pope Francis, couldn’t help noticing that the same breathless questions were raised again and again by commentators assessing the
MORE
ROME -- Pope Francis's low-key style has been amply demonstrated ever since he emerged on the balcony of St. Peter's. But since that time a lot of us have been wondering: Are his liturgical preferences simple too? At this morning's Vatican press conference, we started getting answers. Here's what
MORE
ROME -- St. Peter's Square today looked about as packed for Pope Francis's first Angelus as it was Wednesday night for white smoke. The crowds spilled over into surrounding streets, and well up the Via della Conciliazione. (It didn't help matters that Rome has a marathon today.) They sang. They
MORE
ROME -- At his first meeting with the media, Pope Francis continued to impress, charming the five-thousand-plus journalists in attendance with gestures of humility, his sense of humor, and suggestive comments about the direction he wants to lead the church.
He was introduced by Archbishop
MORE
ROME -- As the multitudes gathered to wait for smoke last night, the mood on St. Peter's Square -- at least in the parts I occupied (and was pushed to) -- was somewhere between political rally and victory parade. Some offered prayers, although, given the cold, wet weather, it wasn't always easy to
MORE
ROME -- If the real work of the cardinal electors takes place over plates of pasta and bottles of wine, the same might be said of the hordes of journalists who have descended on Rome to cover the conclave. One can only glean so much from Vatican press briefings -- now suspended until the cardinal
MORE
With the conclave just two days away, a quiet has settled over Rome. Todays main events: the cardinals fanned out across the area to say morning Mass at their various titular churches. Reports on the newsmaking cardinals are starting to trickle in. Journalists swarmed Cardinal Timothy Dolan's
MORE
Last weekend, Winter Storm Franck dislodged an avalanche of verbiage onto the sleepy hamlet of First Thoughts. Over the past few days, residents have been laboring to uncover the contours of an argument that engages the moral tradition many of them hold dear. Better fire up the snowblower.
Matthew
MORE
Last week, in a tour de force of intellectual humility, Matthew J. Franck treated First Things readers to a catalogue of my confusions. He didn't take kindly to my analysis of Cardinal Timothy Dolan's response to HHS's new proposals for the contraception mandate. First, Franck claims that I am &
MORE
Just posted, Massimo Faggioli on the pope's decision to resign (yes, by the way, canon law calls it resignation, not abdication):
Many Catholics are temped to “spiritualize” Benedict’s decision, but doing so avoids grappling with the unique features of the modern papacy. Catholicism has had
MORE
From Frederico Lombardi, SJ, Vatican spokesman:
Pope Benedict XVI has given his resignation freely, in accordance with Canon 332 §2 of the Code of Canon Law.
Pope Benedict XVI will not take part in the Conclave for the election of his successor.
Pope Benedict XVI will move to the Papal
MORE
Yesterday, Bishop Robert Lynch of St. Petersburg, Florida, posted his initial -- and positive -- impressions of the latest revision of the contraception mandate. This is significant not only because Lynch is a member of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops -- and its former general secretary --
MORE
Today, Cardinal Timothy Dolan released a statement outlining the USCCB's objections to the Obama administration's revision of the revision of the contraception mandate. The new rule scotches the previous iteration's much-maligned four-part definition of "religious employer," and proposes
MORE
Watch the his confirmation hearing here:
Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the
MORE
Given the initial response of critics of the Obama administration's contraception-coverage mandate (except for one lone welcoming voice), it's not terribly surprising that Cardinal Timothy Dolan, president of the USCCB, has announced his displeasure with last Friday's proposed revision. Here's his
MORE
Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, speaking at a conference in Spain in 2002:
In the church, priests are also sinners. But I am personally convinced that the constant presence in the press of the sins of Catholic priests, especially in the United
MORE
Following the release of decades-old memos detailing Archdiocese of Los Angeles officials' efforts to conceal sexual-abuse cases, the new archbishop of L.A., Jose Gomez, has relieved Cardinal Roger Mahony of public duties and relieved auxiliary bishop Thomas Curry of his episcopal duties (.pdf).
MORE
First, read our editorial on the nomination of Chuck Hagel for secretary of defense. Then watch the confirmation hearing here:
Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the
MORE
Two weeks ago, a retired University of Illinois professor discovered a previously unknown poem by Carl Sandberg. You may recall reading a thing or two about its subject.
Full text after the jump.
A REVOLVER
Here is a revolver.
It has an amazing language all its own.
It delivers
MORE
President Obama has announced twenty-three executive actions he'll take to reduce gun violence:
1. Issue a Presidential Memorandum to require federal agencies to make relevant data available to the federal background check system.
2. Address unnecessary legal barriers, particularly relating to the
MORE
As I've noted before, Catholic News Service has a distinctive approach to covering the Affordable Care Act: it freely presents worst-case interpretation as fact. Last February, CNS published a piece of agitprop dressed up as a news story on the alleged threats of "government-run health care.&
MORE
Last Friday, Mollie did a superb job cataloging Bill Donohue's shortcomings both as a crusader against anti-Catholicism (which obviously includes using the occasion of World AIDS Day to call people with HIV promiscuous) and as a surrogate for the conservative movement (giving Dick Morris a run for
MORE
Sad news today: Jazz legend Dave Brubeck died today at the age of ninety-one.
Brubeck, born Dec. 6, 1920, in Concord, Calif., was the son of a cattle rancher. His mother was a classically trained pianist. Although he studied zoology at the College of the Pacific in Stockton, he came to love the
MORE
The cover of the November 5 edition of the Weekly Standard:
And the November 19 edition
MORE
Matt Buchanan of Buzzfeed has noticed something unusual about the Israeli Defense Forces Twitter feed. This morning it announced a major assault on Gaza and has been regularly updating followers on the operation.
That came at 9:29 a.m. Two minutes later, the IDF tweeted:
That link takes you
MORE
Nearly one hundred University of San Diego faculty members have declared they have no confidence in university president Mary Lyons because she rescinded a fellowship invitation to British theologian Tina Beattie. (She last wrote for us in January: "A Modus Vivendi? Sex, Marriage, and the
MORE
As I was saying:
How did we get to the point where a meeting of the USCCB could entertain a conversation in which several bishops openly downplayed or denigrated one of the most important documents the conference ever issued? Has Economic Justice for All become so embarrassing that in order to get
MORE
After a long discussion, which I'll write up later, the document failed to receive the two-thirds majority support required for its passage. If fourteen more bishops had voted yes, the statement would have passed. More later
MORE
Tuesday morning the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops will discuss and vote on the following draft of their "pastoral message on work, poverty, and the economy." For ease of reading, I've incorporated footnotes into the main body of the text, between brackets.
THE HOPE OF THE GOSPEL IN
MORE
The editors on President Obama's reelection:
Some important questions have been answered. Because Obama was re-elected, the Affordable Care Act—vociferously and mistakenly opposed by the U.S. bishops—will not be repealed. Forty million uninsured Americans will now have access to health care.
MORE
According to CNN exit polling, 50 percent of Catholic voters went for Obama, and 48 percent for Romney. This is down from 2008, when Catholics supported Obama over McCain 54-45, but up from '04, when 52 percent of Catholics voted against their co-religionist John Kerry (47 percent supported him).
MORE
At the USCCB:
Dear President Obama,
In my capacity as President of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, I write to express my congratulations on your re-election as President of the United States.The people of our country have again entrusted you with a great responsibility.The
MORE
...you may live in Ohio. Last night, in place of ABC World News and Nightline, at least one Ohio ABC affiliate broadcast an "election special" that looked like a news program, but was actually a partisan critique of the Obama administration. It was even hosted by the station's news
MORE
Then tell us about your experience. Your Election Day open thread begins now
MORE
Just posted: Eugene McCarraher's piece on new books by Cardinal Timothy Dolan, Bill Donohue, and Carl Anderson. In begins:
On April 14, 2012, Bishop Daniel R. Jenky of Peoria, Illinois, speaking from a pulpit surrounded by flowers, a cross, and the American flag, issued a “Call to Catholic Men
MORE
Over at Mirror of Justice, Robert P. George declares that Michael Sean Winters and I have engaged in "aggressively partisan efforts to smear Paul Ryan as a Randian enemy of Catholic social thought." Evidently he's referring to my critique of his response to "On All of Our Shoulders.&
MORE
Did you like Cathleen Kaveny's article "The Single-issue Trap: What the Bishops' Voting Guide Overlooks"? Then you might want to check out the book from which it was adapted: Law's Virtues: Fostering Autonomy and Solidarity in American Society
MORE
Quick question: Who was the genius who scheduled a presidential debate for a Monday during football season (go Bears)? Anyway, have at it. Don't forget to refresh the page to update the comment thread
MORE
Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the
MORE
Robert P. George, McCormick Professor of Jurisprudence at Princeton, has published another missive on Mirror of Justice, in which he, holder of a Harvard JD, a Harvard Divinity MTS, and an Oxford DPhil, writes, "some of our friends at Commonweal seem to have figured out that I mean to
MORE
In its entirety [links added by me]:
Oh my. I'm in big trouble. My friend George Weigel tells me that Michael Winters at the National Catholic Reporter has declared (ex cathedra, I assume) that Grant Gallicho at Commonweal has "exposed" me for . . . sanctimony! (It was in my post
MORE
Have at it. Don't forget to keep refreshing the page to update the thread.Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the
MORE
Well, that was quick. Forty-eight hours after the release of "On All of Our Shoulders" -- a critique of Paul Ryan's libertarian tendencies signed by about one hundred fifty Catholic scholars and ministers -- Robert P. George took to the First Things website to denounce it as a partisan &
MORE
You can watch a livestream of the debate below. If you want to follow along with the comment thread, I suggest opening this page in another tab, and reloading it regularly to keep up with the conversation
MORE
Or maybe during, depending on how boring it is. Yesterday, more than one hundred Catholic theologians, scholars, and ministers released a statement called "On All of Our Shoulders: A Catholic Call to Protect the Endangered Common Good." (Kind of a mouthful, right? I'm calling it "
MORE
You know it's election season when you start losing track of Catholic conservative organizations. Thanks to the National Review Online, I've learned of another one -- the Catholic Association, whose senior fellow, Ashley McGuire, just enjoyed a relaxing game of slow-pitch with NRO's editor-at-large
MORE
Have at it. You will have to reload the page to see new comments
MORE
On Thursday night, about three hundred Commonwealers descended on Chelsea Piers in Manhattan to celebrate the magazine and to honor Georgetown president John DeGioia, recipient of the third Catholic in the Public Square Award. Most guests traveled from nearby places, but some came from far-off
MORE
Over the weekend, the New York Times published a piece on a newly discovered 1941 manuscript of a novel by Claude McKay, a major figure of the Harlem Renaissance.
The manuscript, “Amiable With Big Teeth: A Novel of the Love Affair Between the Communists and the Poor Black Sheep of Harlem,”
MORE
Entering is easy. Just like our Facebook page between now and 12 p.m. on Friday. If you win, here's what you and your guest will be getting into. (N.B. Travel arrangements and accommodations are on you.) Legalese after the jump.
Contest Rules
NO PURCHASE IS NECESSARY TO ENTER OR WIN. A
MORE
It has never seemed the best hill to die on, but apparently Catholic League president Bill Donohue doesn't know how to quit defending Bishop Robert Finn, who was found guilty this week of one misdemeanor count of failing to report suspected child abuse. (Be sure to read David Gibson's post on the
MORE
A judge has convicted Bishop Robert Finn of Kansas City-St. Joseph on one misdemeanor count of failing to report suspicion of child endangerment, making him the highest-ranking U.S. church official -- and the first U.S. bishop -- to be convicted in the sexual-abuse crisis. More from the Kansas City
MORE
Earlier this week the National Catholic Register posted an interview with Fr. Benedict Groeschel, in which he reflected on the twenty-fifth anniversary of the Franciscan Friars of Renewal. The interview attracted a good deal of attention for comments Groeschel made alleging that many abusive
MORE
Surprise.
Here's the full statement from spokesman Joseph Zwilling (not yet available on the archdiocese's website):
Timothy Cardinal Dolan, Archbishop of New York, has accepted an invitation to deliver the closing prayer at next week’s Democratic National Convention. As was previously
MORE
On August 16, after a two-year struggle with cancer, the theologian Margaret O'Gara died at the age of sixty-five. You can read a brief obituary in the Catholic Register of Canada here. From that piece:
The characteristic aim of Margaret's 37 years of work as a theologian was to foster dialogue
MORE
Don't get lost in her eyes
MORE
On Saturday, the Wall Street Journal ran an op-ed defending Rep. Paul Ryan against critics of his budget plan -- including the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. The authors -- Antony Davies, identified as an economist, and his wife Kristina Antolin, identified as a theologian -- lead with their
MORE
Last week Wheaton College, an evangelical school in the great state of Illinois, let it be known that they were joining the Catholic University of America in a lawsuit against the Obama administration over the contraception mandate. Why would an evangelical college sue over the contraception
MORE
Religion-journalism critic Terry Mattingly has a bone to pick with lamestream media reporting on the Chick-fil-A flap. Exhibit A: CNN's 125-word blog post on Chick-fil-A president Dan Cathy's remarks about the nature of marriage. Here's the sentence that ruffled Mattingly's plumage: "But the
MORE
When did the last week in July become National Cheap Moral Posturing Week? First the NCAA made a show of its disciplinary actions against Penn State's football program -- steps taken outside its normal review process, and possibly its jurisdiction. And now a first-term Chicago alderman and the
MORE
Run by a group founded by -- wait for it -- Saul Alinsky. For a grand total of $196. Twenty-six years ago.
I hope you were sitting down, because Catholic Culture, via The Blaze, is about to blow your mind. Apparently, when Obama was working with the Catholic Campaign for Human Development -- the
MORE
I hope you weren't looking at Twitter just now. If so, you would have learned that the Supreme Court both struck down and upheld the Affordable Care Act. What actually happened is this: Chief Justice John Roberts read the majority decision, which, by a 5-4 vote, upholds the Affordable Care Act --
MORE
On Saturday the New York Times published Mark Oppenheimer's writeup of the controversy surrounding Duquesne University's refusal to allow teachers it pays no more than ten grand a year -- without health coverage -- to form a union. (Paul Moses covered it here.) Oppenheimer nicely summarizes the
MORE
Every last bit of it:
Commonweal June 15, 2012 Issue: The Bishops and Religious
MORE
It begins:
Read the statement by some parishioners of Blessed Sacrament Parish (mentioned in the NPR story) right here
MORE
Today the Catholic Health Association released its comment (.pdf) on the Department of Health and Human Services proposal to accommodate religious employers' objections to the contraception mandate. From the beginning, CHA has objected to the structure of the mandate's exemption, which defines a
MORE
The Colbert ReportMon - Thurs 11:30pm / 10:30cRadical Feminist Nuns - Simone Campbellwww.colbertnation.comColbert Report Full EpisodesPolitical Humor & Satire BlogVideo Archive
(Having trouble seeing the video? Go here to watch it on the Colbert Report's site
MORE
At the Catholic Theological Society of America business meeting today, the membership considered a resolution urging "federal and state government to exempt employers from funding or providing contraception and sterilization when such funding or provision directly violates the moral tenets of
MORE
UPDATE: Moments ago (Friday evening), at the business meeting of the Catholic Theological Society of America, the assembly voted by an overwhelming majority to adopt the statement of the CTSA board on the case of Sr. Margaret Farley as its own. (A few members opposed the motion, and a few more
MORE
Just added to our religious-freedom symposium: Cathleen Kaveny's response to the bishops' latest statement on religious liberty:
"Our First, Most Cherished Liberty” reflects the bishops’ deep ambivalence about whether they prefer the protection afforded a religious minority in the United
MORE
Don't miss the second part of our series on the U.S. Catholic bishops' most recent statement on religious liberty. From Mark Silk:
Given the dubious argumentation and the high rhetorical gloss of “Our First, Most Cherished Liberty,” I confess some uncertainty as to whether it is a statement of
MORE
Our June 15 issue will feature a symposium on the U.S. Catholic bishops' recent statement on religious freedom, "Our First, Most Cherished Liberty." We're going to post one part of the package every day until Monday (when the full issue will be published online). First up is Peter
MORE
Last Thursday, Cardinal Donald Wuerl of Washington, D.C., and Archbishop William Lori of Baltimore appeared on EWTN's The World Over to discuss the twelve lawsuits filed by Catholic organizations against the Obama administration over the contraception mandate. (I've embedded the video at the bottom
MORE
Apparently seventy-two hours of incomplete univocity was just too much to bear. On Tuesday, Bishop Stephen Blaire, gave an interview to America magazine in which he expressed concern that there wasn't wider consultation among bishops about the USCCB's anti-contraception-mandate strategy. "I
MORE
Just posted to the homepage:
There is a healthy struggle brewing among the nation's Roman Catholic bishops. A previously silent group, upset over conservative colleagues defining the church's public posture and eagerly picking fights with President Barack Obama, has had enough.
The headlines
MORE
As Bryan Cones notes, Cardinal Timothy Dolan appeared on CBS This Morning yesterday to discuss the dozen lawsuits filed by Catholic agencies against the Obama administration over the contraception mandate. During the interview, Cardinal Dolan repeated the bishops' objection to the structure of the
MORE
There are 195 Catholic dioceses and eparchies in the United States. Why didn't more sign on? Where's Chicago? Boston? Atlanta? Why haven't any California dioceses joined the suits? Kevin Clarke of America has an interview with Bishop Stephen Blaire of Stockton, California -- chairman of the USCCB
MORE
Apparently university president Fr. John Jenkins is done studying the proposed contraception-coverage accommodation, because Notre Dame has filed suit against HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius, Labor Secretary Hilda Solis, and Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, claiming the mandate violates the
MORE
On Tuesday the Franciscan University of Steubenville announced that it would stop offering students health coverage at the end of the summer. Why? Contraception coverage and cost:
The Obama Administration has mandated that all health insurance plans must cover “women’s health services”
MORE
As soon as Georgetown announced that its roster of commencement-weekend speakers would include Secretary of Health and Human Services Kathleen Sebelius, the orthodoxy cops at the Cardinal Newman Society were all over it. The move "can only be interpreted as a direct challenge to America’s
MORE
From Dionne's latest column, just posted to our homepage:
Recently, a group called the Freedom from Religion Foundation ran a full-page ad in the Washington Post cast as an "open letter to 'liberal' and 'nominal' Catholics." Its headline commanded: "It's Time to Quit the Catholic
MORE
This morning, Thomas Reese, SJ, delivered a keynote address at the conference Clergy Abuse: Ten Years Later, sponsored by Santa Clara University. In his talk, Reese described the "unfinished work in responding to the sexual-abuse crisis." Some highlights (you can read the whole talk at
MORE
What's free:
* Our editorial "Rome & Women Religious"
* E. J. Dionne's column "Mommy Wars & Money Worries"
* As previously noted, Jerry Ryan's article on the life and death of René Page
* Kaya Oakes's "A Crush on God: How a Young Priest Helped Me Hear
MORE
Robert Mickens of the Tablet and Sandro Magister of Chiesa are reporting the names of the men behind the investigation of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious. You're going to recognize a few. First, Magister:
The inspection [of LCWR] had been urged above all by some cardinals of the United
MORE
.@NewtGingrich has brought creativity and intellectual vitality to American political life. Proud to call him a friend.— Mitt Romney (@MittRomney) May 2, 2012
Four months earlier
MORE
From the Editors:
The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith’s recent censure of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious for “serious doctrinal problems” raises a number of familiar, if troubling, questions. The LCWR, which represents most American nuns, exists to provide support
MORE
The Colbert Report Get More: Colbert Report Full Episodes,Political Humor & Satire Blog,Video Archive
For the record, the Gospel of Thomas covers Pell Grants in great detail
MORE
What's free:
* Peter Steinfels's review of Ross Douthat's new book Bad Religion.
* Our editorial on the bishops' latest statement on religious freedom.
* Timothy Jost's piece on abortion funding and the Affordable Care Act.
* Margaret O'Brien Steinfels's column on the bishops' campaign against
MORE
Were you surprised by the news that the Vatican planned to install a delegate with sweeping authority over more than 80 percent of American women religious? Non-nun, non-Catholic Get Religion blogger Mollie Ziegler certainly wasn't. She saw this thing coming a mile away. What did surprise her,
MORE
My favorite thing about the group's website is that the "other teachings" link, which is buried way down in the lower right-hand corner of the site, goes to a blank page
MORE
"These are mature Christian women, and to be placed in a kind of pen as if they were schoolchildren is humiliating and inappropriate."
"Why have they done this? I dont' know."
Watch here
MORE
1. After a long investigation, the Vatican has announced a major restructuring of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious. (From the archives, our 2009 article by a nun responding to that investigation.)
2. Apparently Rome and the ultra-traditionalist Society of St. Pius the X (yes, those
MORE
On April 14, Bishop Daniel Jenky, CSC, of Peoria, Illinois, delivered a homily to about five-hundred men on the theme of heroic Catholicism. After speaking quite movingly on the Resurrection, on evangelization in the face of impossible odds, persecution, Jenky pivoted to discuss contemporary
MORE
It comes as no surprise that the ultra-traditionalist Society of St. Pius X is less than elated by the U.S. Catholic bishops' latest salvo in the religious-freedom wars, "Our First, Most Cherished Liberty." The U.S. District of SSPX has issued a stern rebuttal to the bishops' statement,
MORE
Just posted to the homepage:
Rick Santorum's departure from the presidential race could not come soon enough for Mitt Romney. In proving himself more tenacious than anyone predicted, Santorum dramatized one of Romney's major problems, created another, and forced the now inevitable Republican
MORE
What's free?
* Our editorial on the Supreme Court and the Affordable Care Act
* Jo McGowan's column on what some priests don't understand about contraception
* Nathan Pippenger's piece on the foolishness of third-party enthusiasts
* A poem by Elizabeth Poreba
What's not?
* Dan Barry's
MORE
We just posted two articles on the Affordable Care Act: One by health-care-law expert Timothy Jost, who debunks the renewed claim that the health-care law will mean that “tens of millions of Americans will be getting federal subsidies to pay for abortions,” and another by the Editors on the
MORE
Looks like it's RNS day at dotCommonweal. David Gibson reports: "A small Catholic college in Massachusetts has been pressured by the local bishop into cancelling an invitation to Sen. Ted Kennedy's widow to deliver the school's commencement address because of her support of abortion rights
MORE
Last night's O'Reilly Factor featured an interview with Cardinal Timothy Dolan about -- what else? -- the contraception mandate. The exchange was fairly unsurprising: Dolan doesn't want to seem like he's judging the president, or anyone else (but he is judging their policy positions and motives).
MORE
On March 2, Cardinal Timothy Dolan, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, released a letter suggesting that the negotiations between the White House and the USCCB over the conteception mandate had stalled because of the administration's intransigence -- especially on the issues of
MORE
Probably, argues Joseph D. Becker.
Churches that preach the immorality of contraception are excused from federally imposed obligations to promote the practice. But federal law will soon require that the employees of hospitals and other charitable institutions run by such churches—notably, the
MORE
Herbert and Zelmyra Fisher will celebrate their eighty-sixth wedding anniversary in May. He's 104; she's 101. They recently answered questions about their marriage via Twitter. A few of my favorites:
6. What are the most important attributes of a good spouse?
Zelmyra: A hard worker &
MORE
I'll post some initial thoughts on this later; in the meantime, you can read the USCCB Administrative Committee's statement here (.pdf). Shorter version: Accommodation? What accommodation
MORE
The Catholic Diocese of Sacramento recently announced that it will no longer provide grants to a local nonprofit that serves the homeless. Why? Was it financial scandal? No. Egregious incompetence? No. The diocese decided to defund the group, which it had been working with for over two decades,
MORE
Just posted to the main page, Brett Salkeld's conversation with Alison:
Salkeld: Your writing reminds me of Joseph Ratzinger’s, because both of you manage to say very traditional things in fresh ways. But on the question of homosexual acts, you disagree with the teaching of the church. Can you
MORE
From the Could Have Seen This Coming a Mile Away Department: Bishop Lori of Bridgeport -- chairman of the USCCB Ad Hoc Committee on Religious Freedom -- has sent a strongly worded letter to America magazine in response to their strong editorial on the contraception-coverage mandate, "Policy,
MORE
In case you missed the show, here's video of what aired, along with the extended web-only clip after the jump. Nice work, Cathy!
The Daily Show with Jon StewartGet More: Daily Show Full Episodes,Political Humor & Satire Blog,The Daily Show on Facebook
The Daily Show with Jon StewartGet More
MORE
Because Commonweal columnist M. Cathleen Kaveny (we understand she also works for a little-known Catholic university in the Middle West) will be the guest on tonight's Daily Show with Jon Stewart. In the meantime, enjoy this amazing rant from Lewis Black.The Daily Show with Jon StewartGet More:
MORE
Last week, 47 of John Carroll University's roughly 215 faculty members signed a letter to school president Robert L. Niehoff, SJ, asking him to accept the contraception "accommodation" and include such coverage in employee health plans. The faculty members express their concern that "
MORE
What's happening at Catholic News Service? A few weeks ago, I took note of a CNS article that looked like a news story but smelled like an opinion piece. On Wednesday CNS published a piece that purports to bust myths about the contraception-coverage mandate but reads more like a USCCB press
MORE
First Tim Jost [.pdf], health-care law scholar:
Accommodation of religious belief and “neutral laws of general applicability” is not an easy task. I am a religious conscientious objector and object to the requirement that I must pay taxes to support war. Yet I do not consider the federal
MORE
E. J. Dionne Jr. has some advice for Cardinal-designate Dolan: Apologize to Sr. Carol Keehan, president of the Catholic Health Association. Why? Because earlier this week Dolan suggested that she endorsed President Obama's proposed revision to the contraception mandate because, as Dionne puts it, &
MORE
Cardinal-designate Dolan on the revised contraception regulations proposed by President Obama on Friday:
Today’s decision to revise how individuals obtain services that are morally objectionable to religious entities and people of faith is a first step in the right direction.
Fr. John Jenkins,
MORE
Show of hands -- who was surprised that conservatives, conservative Catholics, and Catholic conservatives didn't do a happy dance in response to President Obama's revision of the contraception-coverage mandate?
First, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops complained that the religious
MORE
President Obama has announced a major revision of the mandate requiring employers to provide contraception coverage in employee health plans. Under the new rule, senior administration officials confirmed, no religious institution will have to pay for health-insurance plans that include
MORE
Don't miss her excellent piece at the Atlantic:
The list of Catholics who have lobbied the administration to consider a broader definition of "religious employer" than now exists -- one that would cover institutions like Catholic universities and hospitals -- includes politically
MORE
Yesterday, the Obama administration signaled that it's willing to try to address the concerns of religious institutions that object to the HHS ruling requiring them to cover contraception in their employee health plans. When Press Secretary Jay Carney first began fielding questions about the
MORE
On Friday, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops issued a sharp response to Thursday's White House blog post purporting to clear up any confusion about how the contraception-coverage mandate will affect religious institutions. The USCCB's press release goes through the White House blog post
MORE
There's been a lot of it this week. A couple of selections:
First, Bryan Cones tries to suss out which Catholic institutions will have to include contraception coverage in their employee health plans. You'll recall that not-for-profit religious institutions that employ and serve primarily co-
MORE
The topic came up twice during today's White House press briefing -- first at minute 14:37 and again at minute 25:45 (transcript below):
Q Second topic -- the Catholic Church. It was a pretty extraordinary situation on Sunday in parishes all across the country, individual priests were
MORE
We just posted E. J. Dionne's latest column, in which he takes issue with Obama's decision to force certain religious institutions to pay for employee health plans that include contraception coverage:
One of Barack Obama's great attractions as a presidential candidate was his sensitivity to the
MORE
In a letter to the Catholics of the Diocese of Phoenix, Bishop Thomas Olmsted promises not to obey the "unjust law" requiring certain Catholic institutions to include contraception coverage in their employee health-care plans. "Unless the rule is overturned," Olmsted writes, &
MORE
"I will recover and return."
MORE
In our January 13 editorial, we criticized a ruling from the Department of Health and Human Services that would require all employers to include "contraception and sterilization coverage in their health-insurance plans, including those provided to employees of religious institutions."
MORE
Just posted: Ronald Osborn's "Leaving Iraq: Immunity, Impunity & the End of the War." It begins:
It was not supposed to end this way. Although President Barack Obama deserves credit for bringing an end to the war in Iraq that he inherited, if he had had his wishes, thousands of U
MORE
R. R. Reno and Fr. Robert Barron have had it with these songs of praise for Elizabeth A. Johnson, CSJ, who was recently named "person of the year" by the National Catholic Reporter. Why all the fuss? After all, Reno wonders, why should anyone be surprised that that "trade union for
MORE
At a Romney event in New Hampshire on Monday, a Harvard Kennedy and Divinity School student named Matt Bieber was asked by two police officers to leave the premises because, as he writes on his blog, the police said that "the campaign has identified you as someone who was at a protest at
MORE
Recently discovered in the desk of a (badly missed) colleague: the 1962 pamphlet How to Settle Your Conscience, by Hugh J. O'Connell, C.SS.R. It contains some illuminating passages:
In danger of harm to our own or another's soul or body, we must ordinarily take the safe side. For example, John has
MORE
Just before Christmas, Cardinal Francis George of Chicago decided to eat one of his feet on local television. When a Fox News Chicago reporter asked George for his thoughts about the new route and schedule of the city's gay-pride parade, which will run past a Catholic church not long before a
MORE
Official word came this morning at the bottom of the Vatican Information Service bulletin, under "Other Pontifical Acts": "Accepted the resignation from the office of auxiliary of Los Angeles, U.S.A., presented by Bishop Gabino Zavala, in accordance with canons 411 and 401 para. 2 of
MORE
During Commonweal's gift exchange yesterday, the following recipe was humbly received by our publisher, Tom Baker
MORE
From William Pfaff's latest column:
The great economic crisis has given birth to a smaller and tighter monetary union in Europe, under the influence of a Germany that is undergoing a certain estrangement from its European partners. This amounts to a possibly dangerous wager on what the European
MORE
We just had-slash-are-having our Christmas party. Here's what that looks like
MORE
How many GOP presidential candidates know how the U.S. health-care system works? Or what the Affordable Care Act does?
In October, one-time Republican candidate Herman Cain declared that if he had been diagnosed with stage-four cancer under "Obamacare" he'd be dead -- because
MORE
Yesterday the December 2 issue went live on our website. Free for all: Margaret O'Brien Steinfels on student debt, Daniel Finn's "When Is Self-interest Moral? A Gap in Catholic Social Teaching," and our editorial, which asks whether the president of the United States should "be able
MORE
The Catholic League president's latest defense of Bishop Finn outlandishly claims that "in an ideal world, there would have been no charges whatsoever: there was no complainant and no violation of law." Of course, as Mark Silk points out, whether there is a complainant is irrelevant
MORE
The Kansas City Star reports:
Bishop Robert Finn on Tuesday avoided a possible criminal misdemeanor indictment in his handling of a priest facing child pornography charges by agreeing to enter into a diversion program with the Clay County prosecutor.
Authorities have pledged not to prosecute
MORE
From Telecare (And we're live again):
In case you missed yesterday's coverage, check out David Gibson's RNS story, the Catholic News Service report, and Laurie Goodstein's New York Times account. You can read Bishop Lori's address on religious freedom here. And Archbishop Dolan's presidential
MORE
How do you know when you're eating good pizza? Readers of This Is Herman Cain! by Herman Cain know: "The way I test a good pizza is to order the 'all meat' one. If it tastes too salty, I know the meat is not top quality. But if you get top-quality ingredients and put them all together, you'll
MORE
E. J. Dionne's latest column runs through the rout delivered to Republicans by voters in several states yesterday:
This week's elections around the country were brought to you by the word "overreach," specifically conservative overreach. Given an opportunity in 2010 to build a long-term
MORE
In the October 29 issue of the newspaper of the Archdiocese of Boston, Daniel Avila argued:
Catholics do not have the luxury of being materialists. We look for ultimate explanations that transcend the strictly physical world and that stretch beyond our limited ability to mold and reshape reality
MORE
"Nun Has Refused to Meet with Doctrine Committee, Cardinal Wuerl Reveals." That's the headline of a Catholic Culture story reporting on a press release put out on Friday by Cardinal Donald Wuerl, chairman of the USCCB Committee on Doctrine. There's one problem with that headline. None of
MORE
In June, Fordham theologian Elizabeth A. Johnson, CSJ, responded [.pdf] to the USCCB Committee on Doctrine's critique [.pdf] of her book Quest for the Living God. (Read our coverage of the controversy here.) Today the committee has released its reply [.pdf] to Johnson. It follows a familiar tune
MORE
Some readers have suggested that I have it out for Herman Cain. Not so. I find him winning in many ways. Of course, I have some reservations. But after seeing his latest ad, maybe I should say I had reservations. How can you not vote for someone whose campaign produced the following?
You have to
MORE
If there's one thing CEO-of-Self Herman Cain is sure of -- well, right after regressive tax policy -- it's his position on abortion. While some have accused him of oversimplifying difficult policy questions, the Hermanator's views on abortion are not susceptible to such criticism. Three months ago
MORE
In a move that will doubtless warm the heart of Fr. Robert Sirico and his comrades, the Vatican has just published a long-expected statement calling for major reforms to the global economic and financial system -- including an international political authority to address the “inequalities and
MORE
You've probably seen the headline: "Dangerous exotic animals deliberately freed in Ohio."
The proprietor of an exotic-animal farm in Ohio apparently freed the animals before taking his own life. You don't want to laugh at a story involving suicide and enormous dangerous irrational
MORE
Sweet Marie, there's another GOP debate tonight. With Ceo-of-Self Herman Cain still leading the field, he's sure to receive lots of attention from the moderators--and his competitors. They're going to want to know why, for example, he doesn't think foreign-policy experience--or knowledge, really--
MORE
Making the rounds this morning is a video of CEO-of-Self Herman Cain singing a pizzafied version of "Imagine." It answers the question everyone's been asking: Can he croon? Oh can he. Of course, if you'd read This Is Herman Cain! by Herman Cain, you'd already be well aware of Cain's
MORE
Because if you're going to be in New York City, why don't you swing by Fordham Lincoln Center at 6 p.m.? That's when the Fordham Center on Religion and Culture will host the panel discussion "Faithful Citizenship II: Keeping Faith in a Season of Spin," featuring John DiIulio, head of
MORE
Today Bishop Robert Finn of Kansas City-St. Joseph pleaded not guilty to a misdemeanor charge of failing to report suspected child abuse. "The fact that this is a misdemeanor 'should not diminish the seriousness of the charge,'" according to the prosecutor. This is the first time a U.S.
MORE
As Herman Cain prepares for tonight's eleventy-seventh GOP debate, he's doubtless relishing the news that, according to a new poll, he's become Iowa Republicans' favorite candidate. Yet, with the Hermanator's surge comes increased scrutiny. Take, for example, this piece, which digs into his work
MORE
According to a new CBS News poll, CEO of Self Herman Cain is tied with Mitt Romney for the lead in the race for the GOP nomination. Republicans think Romney has the best shot at beating Obama, but, considering Cain was polling at 5 percent two weeks ago, he must be profoundly self-inspired by the
MORE
During the September 22 GOP debate, Godfather Pizza president Herman Cain repeated the claim that he would have succumbed to cancer had the Affordable Care Act been law when he was diagnosed. "I said I would be dead under Obamacare because...[after I was diagnosed] I was able to get the
MORE
Today is the feast of St. Francis of Assisi. So have a look at Paul Moses's "A Suffering Saint: Francis of Assisi's Shadow Side," just posted to the homepage. It begins:
The fact that Francis of Assisi hated to be put on a pedestal does not stop us from doing so when his annual feast
MORE
Hey, thanks, Supreme Court:
The Colbert Report Get More: Colbert Report Full Episodes,Political Humor & Satire Blog,Video
MORE
Jesus Colina, founder and editorial director of a news agency sponsored by the Legion of Christ, has been asked to step down. According to a letter Colina sent to Zenit employees, the Legion of Christ asked him to step down after he resisted efforts to more closely identify Zenit with the Legion.
MORE
Yesterday our Theology Issue (October 7) went live on our site. Here's what's free:
* Our editorial on Israel and the question of Palestinian statehood.
* Michael W. Higgins's piece on Marshall McLuhan's "post-curial Catholicism."
* Thomas Baker's review of Fr. Robert Barron's
MORE
More than 150 Catholic theologians, scholars, and social-justice advocates have signed a letter calling for the abolition of the death penalty in the United States. It begins:
There were two state-sanctioned executions in the United States on September 21, 2011. In Georgia, Troy Anthony Davis, an
MORE
At 4 p.m. on Saturday, November 12, join us at NYU (map) for a panel discussion about faith and the writing life, featuring Commonweal contributors Paul Elie, Alice McDermott, Valerie Sayers, and Rand Richards Cooper. The event is free and open to the public, and will be followed by a reception
MORE
Last week I posted a clip of a GOP debate audience cheering state-imposed death. During Monday night's Tea Party-sponsored debate, audience members applauded the idea of allowing a sick person without health insurance to die. Ron Paul was asked how an uninsured thirty-year-old who has a serious
MORE
Political applause lines are a dime a dozen. We hear what seems like thousands of them during State of the Union addresses. And in recent years they've been creeping into presidential debates. Usually they're little more than safe affirmations of America's superiority, or assurances of coming
MORE
If a bishops conference releases a document intended to help Catholics with their voting choices but hardly anyone reads it, does it make a difference?
That's the question U.S. Catholic bishops are asking themselves as they learn the results of a new survey commissioned by Fordham's Center on
MORE
This one goes out to the type nerds. Or nerd.
New Study Explains Why Comic Sans Font So Hilarious (Season 1: Ep 8 on IFC
MORE
Yes, a few minutes ago a 5.9 magnitude earthquake began in Charlottesville, Virginia, and rumbled all the way up to Boston--and down to North Carolina. Everyone at Commonweal is safe and sound. We barely noticed. Because this is our building:
It was a little like this:
But nothing like this (
MORE
The Catholic Herald was kind enough to give us permission to reprint John Wilkins's "Zapping Your Enemy," published in the February 11, 2011, edition of the paper (it's not available on the Herald's Web site). The full article appears below.
‘I wanted to suggest that you insert a
MORE
Commonweal is now available on the Amazon Kindle (and its mobile apps) for the low low price of $2.99 a month. Click here to subscribe. Do it for the trees
MORE
Ben Smith of Politico got a hold of records relating to Mitt Romney's 2004 attempt to convince Standard and Poor's to raise the credit rating of Massachusetts. Here's how Romney tells it:
“When I was governor, S&P rewarded Massachusetts with a credit rating upgrade for our sound fiscal
MORE
The Colbert ReportGet More: Colbert Report Full Episodes,Political Humor & Satire Blog,Video
MORE
Last week, I posted about the reactions and overreactions to Irish Prime Minister Enda Kenny's speech criticizing the Vatican's handling of the sexual-abuse crisis in Ireland. In that piece, I briefly mentioned the flouncery of George Weigel's response -- published by the National Review -- in
MORE
Last week, in an impassioned speech delivered from the floor of the Irish parliament, Prime Minister Enda Kenny offered some hard sayings about the Vatican's handling of clergy sexual abuse in Ireland. Kenny said that the recent report on the scandal in Cloyne "excavates the dysfunction,
MORE
When was the last time you heard product placement in a prayer? This actually happened:
This did not
MORE
Did you catch the second part of David Gibson's interview with Cardinal Francis George? What about the first part? And William L. Portier's review of George's new book? And what about Verdicts, our new books and culture blog? Did you read Anthony Domestico's post on Chris Adrian's novel The
MORE
I know this doesn't quite rise to the level of the country's or the church's most serious issue, but...
Yes, CNA has fixed the error
MORE
-- Scott D. Moringiello writes from Venice on the sinking city's modern art festival Biennale.
-- Anthony Domestico reviews Allegra Goodman’s novel The Cookbook Collector.
-- Paul Lakeland looks at The Crisis of Authority in Catholic Modernity and Governance, Accountability and the Future
MORE
If not, then you missed two great posts--one by Frank Oveis on Marian Ronan's book Tracing the Sign of the Cross: Sexuality, Mourning, and the Future of American Catholicism, and another by Paul Lakeland on Colm Toíbín and Henry James. What are you waiting for? Bookmark Verdicts. (And why not
MORE
Don't miss Anthony Domestico's Verdicts post "The Past Is a Foreign Country":
Reading Wolf Hall and thinking about Paul Lakeland’s post on Ron Hansen’s latest novel has got me wondering: why does it seem as if every “literary” novelist—I hate to use that term, but it will have
MORE
Head over to Verdicts for Scott D. Moringiello's post on David Foster Wallace's view of the sacred.
In an interview, Wallace said that he went through RCIA twice. Unfortunately, the interviewer did not pursue the line of questioning. In 2008, after a long battle with clinical depression and
MORE
As you may have noticed, our Web site looks a little different today. That's because we've added a new blog and expanded our books and culture pages. Be sure to visit Verdicts, a blog about books and culture, featuring Frank Oveis, Lauretta O'Connor, Paul Lakeland, Mollie Wilson O'Reilly, and
MORE
And then there's this, which is one of the funniest papal videos I've seen since the gymnasts...performed
MORE
TV reporters greeted the archbishop after Mass yesterday (of course), and the archbishop did his best to seem positive--even conciliatory--while admitting that he's been "down a little recently, as you might imagine":
H/T Rocco
MORE
The June 16 episode of The World Over starring Raymond Arroyo featured an interview with Robert Bennett, one of the original members of the USCCB National Review Board (2002-04). The two discussed the bishops' revisions to the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People. The whole
MORE
As Tom Fox reports, last night the membership of the Catholic Theological Society of America voted on a resoultion expressing regret over the procedures of the Committee on Doctrine, which claimed Elizabeth Johnson's book Quest for the Living God "completely undermines the gospel." The
MORE
NCR has obtained a copy of Johnson's 38-page reply to the USCCB Committee on Doctrine, whose statement [.pdf] on her Quest for the Living God claimed the book “contaminates the traditional Catholic understanding of God” and “completely undermines the gospel.” (We have a copy too [.pdf].
MORE
Stephen Schneck of the Catholic University of America offers a good post on the much-abused term:
"Subsidiarity refers to the appropriate balancing of responsibilities and functions among the parts of a social order. It has its origin in the Catholic understanding of community, which
MORE
Just posted, our editorial on the John Jay study of the "causes and context" of the sexual-abuse crisis. It begins:
From the beginning, armchair social-scientists have floated any number of explanations for the Catholic Church’s sexual-abuse crisis. Conservatives blamed gay men.
MORE
Sad news from NCR:
Joseph Feuerherd, NCR editor in chief and publisher, died this morning after an 18-month battle with cancer. He was 48. Funeral arrangements are pending.
Feuerherd died at 8:41 a.m. Eastern time at the Montgomery Hospice's Casey House in Rockville., Md. His family was at his
MORE
You can find the full text right here [PDF]. Archbishop Dolan's statement here
MORE
Just published by RNS--David's piece on the "Causes and Contexts" study, which the USCCB will release tomorrow
MORE
Today the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith issued a "circular letter" to bishops conferences worldwide asking them to develop guidelines for responding to abuse allegations. The letter is intended to help bishops formulate these guidelines--the letter itself doesn't contain new
MORE
Today the Associated Press ran a story on Ana Maria Catanzaro's Commonweal article, "The Fog of Scandal." If you've read the piece, you won't learn much, but the story does contain a couple of interesting items.
First, Nicholas Cafardi--former chair of the National Review Board and
MORE
Just posted, an important article by Ana Maria Catanzaro, chair of the Archdiocese of Philadelphia's review board.
Eight years ago, Cardinal Anthony Bevilacqua asked me to join the Archdiocese of Philadelphia’s sexual-abuse review board, which he was putting together to help him determine the
MORE
Are you seeing a scary warning when trying to access our Web site in Google Chrome? Or are our ads being blocked by Firefox? Not to worry--our site has not been compromised. We're not sneaking viruses onto your machine. Google has erroneously placed our ad server on its blacklist. This happened
MORE
Kids react to the killing of Osama bin Laden:
H/T
MORE
When a bishop pleads guilty to possessing child pornography, as did the former bishop of Antigonish in Nova Scotia, the Vatican promises to follow canonical procedures and punish him accordingly. But what happens when the pope removes bishops for less illegal offenses, such as poor management or
MORE
Last weekend, the Associated Church Press announced the winners of the Best of the Christian Press Awards. We took home a few:
First place in the general-interest-magazine category
Third place in the blog category
First place in the long-feature-article category (Peter Steinfels's "
MORE
Subway preachers are a dime a dozen in New York. They seem especially numerous on the 7th Ave. line--the one most Commonweal staffers take to work. There's the elderly Israeli man with the wild beard who promises a path to the pearly gates. The middle-aged Jamaican woman who preaches the peace of
MORE
Links worth reading:
Chait's take: Bin Laden's death may make Al Qaeda sympathizers think twice about opposing the United States. The operation raises American confidence in its military. And this won't move the needle for Obama come November.
Steve Kornacki agrees.
TPM: how it happened
MORE
In a thirteen-page letter [PDF], Cardinal Donald Wuerl, chairman of the USCCB Committee on Doctrine, explains his committee's rationale for taking on Elizabeth A. Johnson's Quest for the Living God (blogged about here, here, and here). The wide-ranging letter--while acknowledging the theologian'
MORE
Today working-class hero Gov. Scott Walker visited Capitol Hill to testify before the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee in a hearing titled "State and Municipal Debt: Tough Choices Ahead." Now that those pesky public employees have been stripped of their right to bargain
MORE
Just posted to the home page, "A President, Not a Ref":
President Barack Obama has finally decided to take his own side in the philosophical struggle that is the true engine of this nation's budget debate.
After months of mixed signals about what he was willing to fight for, Obama
MORE
The CTSA board of directors has issued a response to the USCCB Committee on Doctrine's critique [PDF] of Elizabeth Johnson's Quest for the Living God (blogged about here, here, and here).
Our intent here is to voice our serious concerns regarding three issues: 1) the fact that, in this matter, the
MORE
As I mentioned last week, I’ve been working through Elizabeth A. Johnson’s Quest for the Living God, recently criticized [PDF] by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ Committee on Doctrine. In a terrific follow-up post, Mollie expanded on a question I raised about the degree to which
MORE
Featuring our own David Gibson:
(function(){var s=function(){__flash__removeCallback=function(i,n){if(i)i[n]=null;};window.setTimeout(s,10);};s
MORE
The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops Committee on Doctrine has released a statement criticizing [PDF] Sr. Elizabeth A. Johnson's Quest for the Living God (Continuum) for failing "to accord with authentic Catholic teaching on essential points." The twenty-one-page document claims the
MORE
A couple of weeks ago, Editorial Assistant Christine Neulieb and I traveled to Anaheim to staff the Commonweal booth in the giant exhibit hall at the Los Angeles Religious Education Congress. I've written about the event before, after Terry Mattingly expressed puzzlement at the diverse offerings at
MORE
I've removed Peggy's post on President Obama's remarks on Libya (couldn't figure out what the fonts meant). She called the speech well wrought, well argued, and worth a careful read by all. I agree. So here's another thread on the subject, complete with video
MORE
Late yesterday afternoon, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops put out a statement on the sexual-abuse scandal from its president, Archbishop Timothy Dolan of New York. (You may have seen him on 60 Minutes this week, where he also discussed the continuing scandal.) The purpose of the statement,
MORE
Everything you need to know about the latest O'Keefe video sting was explained during the sixth season of The Simpsons
MORE
Just posted to the homepage: Nicholas P. Cafardi's article on scandal in Philadelphia. (Also check out our editorial on unrest in the Middle East, and Dionne's latest column on Wisconsin
MORE
"This terrible history recorded here today is history." --Archbishop Wilton Gregory, then president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, in his remarks accompanying the release of the John Jay College of Criminal Justice Study on "The Nature and Scope of Sexual Abuse of Minors
MORE
Yesterday, at his indispensable blog Spiritual Politics, Mark Silk pointed out that Justice League President Bill Donohue, PhD, managed to be not wrong about something important. Last week victims attorney Jeff Anderson released a 2003 letter from Archbishop Timothy Dolan (now of New York, then
MORE
The comment of the weekend was brought to you by dotCommonweal contributor unagidon, who helpfully outlined the evolution of the Right's recent antiunion memes. Be sure to read the whole thing, and the thread where it was posted.
The creation of memes in our current politics is an interesting one
MORE
Just posted, our March 11 issue.
What's free:
* Our editorial on Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker's proposed...adjustments to the state's public unions. (Also check out E. J. Dionne's latest column, "Power Play: Why the Wisconsin Fight Matters.")
* David Cortright's Short Take on
MORE
According to Wisconsin state senator Tim Carpenter (D), Governor Scott Walker "will not talk, will not communicate, will not return phone calls." That gave one liberal blogger an idea: "Who could get through to Gov. Walker? Well, what do we know about Walker and his proposed union-
MORE
The filmmaker Newt Gingrich runs an impressive fundraising operation. Today's Washington Post reports:
His main advocacy group, American Solutions, ranks as the largest money-making machine of its kind in the country, collecting more than $52 million in its first four years--though nearly two-
MORE
Allow me to name an awareness I just had. The Fordham Center on Religion and Culture has just posted the videos from their two-day conference on twenty-something Catholics. Don't miss our own Matthew Boudway--and his panel's Q&A session
MORE
While we're waiting for Mubarak, read the editors and William Pfaff on Egypt
MORE
Just posted: "Walking Softly," by E. J. Dionne Jr., and "The Battle for Egypt," by William Pfaff
MORE
Earlier today, Harvard law professor Charles Fried, who served as Ronald Reagan's solictor general from 1985 to '89, told the Senate Judiciary Committee that he was certain the health-care mandate was perfectly constitutional. "I come here not as a partison for this act. I think there are lots
MORE
Says one eyewitness interviewed on Al Jazeera English. Another: "The role of the military from the beginning was...to protect, but they have made it very clear that they are not getting involved anymore."
Things are getting worse. Watch here
MORE
The New York Times reports that earlier this month, Mayor Michael Bloomberg sent undercover agents to Phoenix to investigate selling practices at a gun show. Such venues serve as the planet-sized loophole through which people who shouldn't have guns are able to buy them without a background check.
MORE
Just posted to the homepage: Nicholas P. Cafardi's "Loose Canons: Ratzinger, Church Law & the Sexual-abuse Crisis."
In 1988, the CDF was fielding lots of laicization requests—many from accused American priests—and being pressured by U.S. bishops to grant them quickly. But
MORE
From E. J. Dionne's latest column, just posted to our home page:
It's remembered as a day chilled by "a Siberian wind knifing down Pennsylvania Avenue" and illuminated by "the dazzling combination of bright sunshine and deep snow."
On January 20, 1961, John F. Kennedy began
MORE
From the New York Times obituary:
R. Sargent Shriver, the Kennedy in-law who became the founding director of the Peace Corps, the architect of President Lyndon B. Johnson’s war on poverty, the United States ambassador to France and the Democratic candidate for vice president in 1972, died on
MORE
Before you settle in for a long day of giant men smashing each other while chasing an oblong ball, be sure to read Barry Gault's "Lay That Pistol Down: It Wasn't Our Mental-health Laws that Enabled Loughner. It Was Our Gun Laws." Gault takes issue with William Galston's argument for
MORE
This afternoon, Paul Baumann appeared at my desk bearing a quizzical look--and a gift. "This has been sitting in my office for a week or so. I don't know the name on the return address." I didn't recognize it either. Paul handed me a small box wrapped in red paper--tagged "Grant G.&
MORE
Over the past several years, and for a variety of reasons--some of them rather bizarre--Commonweal disappeared from newsstands. From time to time we'd hear from someone who wanted to know where he might purchase a copy of the magazine, and we'd have to say, sorry, not possible. Well, we don't have
MORE
Remarks of President Barack Obama – As Prepared for Delivery
At a Memorial Service for the Victims of the Shooting in Tucson, Arizona
University of Arizona, McKale Memorial Center
Tucson, Arizona
January 12, 2011
To the families of those we’ve lost; to all who called them friends; to the
MORE
MoJo political reporter (and one-time Commonweal editorial assistant) Nick Baumann has just filed a must-read interview with a close friend of Jared Lee Loughner. It begins:
At 2:00 a.m. on Saturday—about eight hours before he allegedly killed six people and wounded 14, including Rep. Gabrielle
MORE
Did you know that the Susan G. Komen for the Cure Foundation has spent $1 million suing other cancer charities for infringing on their trademarked phrase "for the cure"?
"It happened to my family," said Roxanne Donovan, whose sister runs Kites for a Cure, a family kite-flying
MORE
Last summer, Bishop Olmsted of Phoenix asked Catholic Healthcare West to provide a moral analysis of the case that started this controversy. So CHW secured the services of the moral theologian M. Therese Lysaught. Her analysis, sent to the bishop in October, was rejected by Olmsted last month. We
MORE
Bishop Olmsted has stripped St. Joseph's Hospital of its Catholic status. The Arizona Republic reports (the following is taken from an earlier version of that story):
The Catholic Diocese of Phoenix has removed St. Joseph's Hospital and Medical Center's status as a Catholic hospital for failing to
MORE
Cathleen Kaveny's column "The Long Goodbye: Why Some Devout Catholics Are Leaving the Church" caught the attention of several writers, making it one of the most-read columns on our Web site. One commentator even made a video about it.
Fr. Robert Barron teaches theology at the
MORE
At Fordham's event on Cardinal Dulles last night, his research assistant, Anne-Marie Kirmse, OP, offered the following:
Cardinal Dulles thought this was a subject that needed to be handled more with education and pastoral sensitivity than with authoritative pronouncements, especially in the public
MORE
Recently posted to our home page: a preview of the December 17 editorial, "The Human Dimension." Here's how it starts:
In 2003, Cardinal Alfonso López Trujillo of the Pontifical Council for the Family made headlines by claiming that condoms are unsafe because HIV “can easily pass
MORE
If there is one U.S. senator who, time and again, has stood for justice and against nonsensicalness and moral corruptness, it's Mary Landrieu of Louisiana. She identified rampant nonsensicalness in the 2007 immigration-reform bill, so, along with just seven other Democrats, she voted to kill it.
MORE
Last week, Fr. James Connell, vice chancellor of the Archdiocese of Milwaukee, stood on the steps of the Cathedral of St. John the Baptist and called on his bishop to release documents related to the local sexual-abuse crisis: “I am absolutely convinced that we need the truth. Justice requires
MORE
The plot thickens. John Thavis has the story:
The letter, written by then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger when he was head of the Vatican's doctrinal congregation, expressed concern that the normal process for dealing with such priests -- which typically involved a request for dispensation from priestly
MORE
Not everyone who wanted to attend last month's Commonweal Conversations could make the pilgrimage to NYU for the event. And not everyone who did make it had an unobstructed view. Not to worry. We taped the whole thing. Stay tuned for the one-liners of the night (at about 1:14:30):
Commonweal
MORE
Thirty years ago today, Salvadoran National Guardsmen abducted, raped, and murdered four American churchwomen: lay missionary Jean Donovan (top left), Maryknoll sisters Ita Ford (top right) and Maura Clarke (bottom left), and Ursuline sister Dorothy Kazel (bottom right). Over the years, Commonweal
MORE
Blast from the recent past, to honor Woody Allen, who turns 75 today: Fr. Robert Lauder's April interview with the director.
RL: When Ingmar Bergman died, you said even if you made a film as great as one of his, what would it matter? It doesn’t gain you salvation. So you had to ask yourself why
MORE
If it's Thanksgiving, it's Meet the Les.
You can watch the whole episode at Hulu
MORE
In case you missed it, yesterday we posted "Boycotting the Poor Box," our editorial for the December 3 issue. Here's how it starts:
In mid-November, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops discussed a report detailing an extensive “review and renewal” of its domestic-poverty program
MORE
It's good to know the newly minted president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops isn't boycotting a newspaper whose coverage he finds wanting. In today's New York Times, Laurie Goodstein has an interesting interview with Archbishop Dolan.
Of course, Goodstein had to ask about the condom
MORE
The comment of the day comes from our own unagidon, who offers the following tutorial in answer to the vexing question, "Why do hospitals charge so much for an aspirin?"
The reason that hospitals charge so much for an aspirin is a rather simple one, and if I tell you why they do it
MORE
This doesn't happen very often. The USCCB just elected as president someone other than the sitting VP. The race went to three ballots, with Dolan finally winning 128 to 111. The first vote had Bishop Kicanas with 104, Dolan with 84, and Archbishop Chaput with 20. In the second ballot, required
MORE
Join us for a 4 p.m. panel discussion on faith, politics, and the midterm elections, featuring Jean Bethke Elshtain, Mark Shields, Peter Steinfels, and Paul Baumann. Reception for Commonweal Associates to follow. All the info you'll need is right here
MORE
Next week the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops will elect its next president. According to custom, the current vice president, Bishop Gerald Kicanas of Tucson--considered a Bernardin bishop and therefore more liberal--will likely win the presidency. That has some Catholic conservatives up in
MORE
MSNBC's motley crew delivered several amusing moments last night (like this one), but none so bizarre as Keith Olbermann's theory that the Tea Party is a political universal solvent. A what? (Skip to minute 1:45.)
KEITH OLBERMANN: My theory about the Tea Party, in all respects, has been the old
MORE
Just posted to the homepage: two new articles on the election results. First, "Cash Cowed: How Money Is Deforming Our Politics," by Margaret O'Brien Steinfels. It begins:
The 2010 midterms will go down as one of the most fiercely fought campaigns in our political history. Nasty campaigns
MORE
...that in the final hours of the race to represent Louisiana's 2nd District his Family Research Council needed to air an ad denouncing Republican Anh "Joseph" Cao--one of the more interesting and thoughtful representatives of any party--for having a "dismal record" on "
MORE
My apologies to dotCommonweal readers for posting this publicly, but I need to communicate these journalistic guidelines to our blog contributors and am unable to send e-mail at the moment. Feel free to skip to the next post.
Attention dotCommonweal writers: those who plan to cover Saturday's
MORE
In case you missed it, be sure to check out Cathleen Kaveny's article "Catholics as Citizens: Today's Ethical Challenges Call for New Moral Thinking" over at America, along with Lisa Fullam's response (other responses here
MORE
Updates throughout: Apparently the Minnesota Democratic-Farmer-Labor Party recently sent this [PDF] to prospective voters. On the front it features a priest person in a Roman collar wearing a button that reads "Ignore the Poor" (and holding some kind of holy-looking book, or possibly a
MORE
Just a quick PSA to remind you that if you're not able to spend all day on our Web site (although I highly recommend it), one of the best ways to keep up with Commonweal is to follow us on Facebook and Twitter. You don't have to call us. We'll call you. Unless you want to donate or subscribe
MORE
You've probably already heard the one about the Democratic candidate who questioned his Republican opponent's claims to Christian faith. Republicans are shocked, shocked that a Democrat would go after a member of Christ's party, as if everyone doesn't already know that Democrats would hate God if
MORE
And who can blame them?
The newspaper cited an analysis in the Oct. 16 issue of the Italian Jesuit magazine, La Civilita Cattolica.
In it, Father Francesco Occhetta examined a Catholic-themed episode from 2005, "The Father, the Son and the Holy Guest Star," in which Homer and his son
MORE
Patrick Madrid calls attention to a story claiming a Muslim man did the worst slow-mo breakdance ever on the altar of the Florence cathedral (Basilica di Santa Maria del Fiore), and poses a telling thought experiment:
Try to imagine what would happen if a Christian were to perform this same
MORE
The October 22 issue just went live, so be sure to look at its table of contents, but before you do, you're going to want to read "Further Adrift: The American Church's Crisis of Attrition," by Peter Steinfels. Here's how it starts:
It is not often that someone at a New York dinner party
MORE
You've probably seen this correction already (H/T everyone, but Chait has a great kicker). It's a doozy:
This blog post originally stated that one in three black men who have sex with me is HIV positive. In fact, the statistic applies to black men who have sex with men.
But have you heard about
MORE
Just posted: our editorial for the October 22 issue, which we just put to bed. Here's how it begins:
“I have no enemies and no hatred. None of the police who monitored, arrested, and interrogated me, none of the prosecutors who indicted me, and none of the judges who judged me are my enemies
MORE
Remember that unintentionally funny Sharron Angle ad I mentioned last week? In case you were wondering where you'd seen those menacing Latinos before, Think Progress is on the case: It turns out Louisiana Republican David Vitter managed to capture the same scary-looking Hispanics Angle's people
MORE
Last week we discussed the decision of the bishops of Minnesota to send anti-gay-marriage DVDs to the state's four hundred thousand Catholics. The mailing--funded by an anonymous donor--included a six-minute video of Archbishop Nienstedt of St. Paul and Minneapolis and a twelve-minute video
MORE
Just posted to the main site: "Bus to Birmingham: What I Saw at Newman's Beatification," by William D. Wood. Here's how it starts:
Way back in the twentieth century, when I decided to pursue doctoral work in theology, I never imagined that I would one day teach in an Oxford college.
MORE
As mentioned at Vox Nova, the Web site Catholic Vote Action, has endorsed Sharron Angle, who is running to represent Nevada in the U.S. Senate. Here's one of her SNL fake TV ads campaign commercials:
I can't decide which part is more hilarious: the stock footage of vaguely Hispanic-looking
MORE
Two days before California was going to execute Albert Greenwood Brown, a convicted rapist and murderer, the California Conference of Bishops issued a statement calling for an end to the death penalty and clemency for the state's death-row inmates. Today that execution was stayed by U.S. District
MORE
In which I abuse my position with Commonweal to promote a well-reviewed, attractively priced performance of T. S. Eliot's Murder in the Cathedral at my parish in Brooklyn.
Jason Zinoman praised the show in Saturday's New York Times, and I can't disagree with his judgment:
The director, Alec
MORE
Are the Democrats any good at politics? Jonathan Chait calls their fetal decision not to hold a vote on tax cuts a sellout. That's about the size of it.
Here's the really crazy thing. Moderate Democrats worry that passing a tax cut for income under $250,000 would be portrayed as a tax hike,
MORE
So asks our newest columnist, Margaret O'Brien Steinfels, in "Trivial Pursuits," just posted to the home page. Here's how it starts:
Republicans were few—you could count them on one hand—in our Chicago neighborhood. The one on our block, Bob O’Rourke, was the Republican counterpart
MORE
From the archives: our editorial "September 11, 2001," and "What Kind of 'War'?" by Peter Steinfels, Robert White, Jean Porter, and Bruce Russett
MORE
Just posted to the homepage:
By insisting Tuesday evening that "it's time to turn the page," President Barack Obama was talking about more than the Iraq War, and doing much more than reviving one of his most effective slogans from the 2008 campaign.
He was also trying to turn the page
MORE
Last night Michael Bloomberg spoke again, convincingly, on Park51. Bear with me as I quote at length from the superb address:
There are people of good will on both sides of the debate, and I would hope that everyone can carry on a dialogue in a civil and respectful way. In fact, I think most
MORE
The Daily Show With Jon StewartMon - Thurs 11p /
MORE
Don't forget, readers, we post content to the main site too. Today's offering: E. J. Dionne Jr. on the Democrats' chances in November: "The Power of Negative Thinking."
Democrats have come up with a loud "no" of their own, asking voters to reject the Republican past one more
MORE
Our own David Gibson offers his reflections on the mosque mess at the New York Times "Room for Debate" forum:
Obama could well invert Gingrich's rhetoric and perhaps stanch the political bleeding -- and help believers overseas -- if he laid out the argument that religious freedom at home
MORE
Let us count the ways.
Suppose the Catholic Church proposed to build a 13-story, 50,000 square-foot showpiece at Ground Zero? Or the 92nd St. Young Men’s Hebrew Association proposed to relocate its facility to the site of the attack on the Twin Towers? Or the Billy Graham Evangelical Association
MORE
John Thavis reports:
The norms on sexual abuse of minors by priests now stipulate:
-- The church law's statute of limitations on accusations of sexual abuse has been extended, from 10 years after the alleged victim's 18th birthday to 20 years. For several years, Vatican officials have been
MORE
Yesterday the National Right to Life Committee fired off a press release warning that the Department of Health and Human Services had approved the federal funding of elective abortions in Pennsylvania:
The Obama Administration will give Pennsylvania $160 million to set up a new “high-risk”
MORE
Recently discovered as the excavation of the editor's old office continues, a form letter to Commonweal's book reviewers:
Dear Reviewer,
We would like to enhance the book review section by printing brief, interesting and representative passages from the books being reviewed.
We would
MORE
Everybody relax. As widely expected, Rome is about to issue new rules for handling priests who sexually abuse minors, including those who view child pornography and abuse adults with mental disabilities, classifying such acts as grave canonical crimes. Oh, and the new document will include those
MORE
Careful readers of Laurie Goodstein and David Halbfinger's "Church Office Failed to Act on Abuse Scandal" (discussed here) will recall seeing Nicholas P. Cafardi quoted in the piece. Nick is a canon lawyer and a professor of civil law at Duquesne. He was also one of the first members of
MORE
Cardinal Christoph Schoenborn of Vienna surprised many of us when he called for an "unflinching examination" of mandatory clerical celibacy as a response to the sexual-abuse scandals. He stunned even more people when he went after former Vatican Secretary of State Angelo Cardinal Sodano
MORE
You'll recall the controversy surrounding Bishop Olmsted's announcement that Sr. McBride had excommunicated herself owing to her participation in a decision to approve an abortion to save the life of a mother. (We discussed it here and here last month.) If you've been struggling with the
MORE
So says Catholic jabberer-in-chief Bill Donohue, explaining how he travels to his frequent TV appearances. Who could doubt it? The man can talk. Donohue shared that tidbit in his fiesty reply to NCR editor Joe Feuerherd's takedown. In a follow-up post, Michael Sean Winters did most of the heavy
MORE
Just posted: "Episcopal Oversight: How the Bishops Get Health-care Legislation Wrong," by health-law expert Timothy S. Jost.
On May 20, 2010, the Secretariat of Pro-Life Activities of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops issued a statement supporting H.R. 5111, sponsored by
MORE
In which Congressman Bart Stupak briefly tells the story of "the most grueling period in my nearly twenty years on the hill." That may sound hyperbolic. It's not. Read the whole thing. He has body guards. His wife unplugs the phone because drunks harass the family at all hours and from
MORE
Congratulations to all the winners of the Associated Church Press Awards. You can check out Commonweal's awards right here
MORE
Pope Benedict to reporters on the flight to Lisbon:
Attacks on the pope and the church come not only from outside the church, but the suffering of the church comes from inside the church, from sins that exist inside the church. This we have always known but today we see it in a really terrifying
MORE
You'll recall the controversy over Archbishop Chaput's decision to bar the children of a lesbian couple from returning to their Catholic school next year. In the course of those conversations on dotCommonweal, several readers asked, "Why would gay parents want to send their kids to Catholic
MORE
Rachel Donadio reports on the pope's spontaneous remarks during his homily today:
“I have to say that we Christians, even in recent times, have often avoided the word ‘penance,’ which seems too harsh,” Benedict said at a Mass on Thursday morning, Vatican Radio reported.
“Now under the
MORE
Michael Sean Winters continues to call down shame on the secular press for its coverage of the latest phase of the sexual-abuse crisis. Winters doesn't see why anyone should be too troubled by how the CDF handled the case of Stephen Kiesle: "This, we are led to believe, is the smoking gun.
MORE
Vatican Secretary of State Tarcisio Bertone on celibacy, homosexuality, and pedophilia in the church's sexual-abuse crisis:
Many psychologists and psychiatrists have shown that there is no link between celibacy and pedophilia but many others have shown, I have recently been told, that there is a
MORE
At this moment, Commonweal's Facebook page has 666 fans. Please consider helping us move past the number of the beast by becoming a fan. And don't forget: you can follow us on Twitter too
MORE
Cardinal Sodano is at it again--this time he has a few wing men.
"But it's not Christ's fault if Judas betrayed" him, Sodano said. "It's not a bishop's fault if one of his priests is stained by grave wrongdoing. And certainly the pontiff is not responsible."
"Behind the
MORE
From our April 9 editorial, recently posted on our homepage:
In his last years as head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and from the beginning of his papacy, Pope Benedict has demonstrated a real understanding of the nature and scope of the clergy sexual-abuse crisis. He came to
MORE
Over at America's In All Things blog, Michael Sean Winters wonders how the Catholic Church can defend itself without being defensive. He begins by expressing gratitude for the work of the secular media in exposing the sexual-abuse scandal. Then the other hand comes out:
Nobody in the press, not
MORE
In her thread on the Legion of Christ's disavowal of Maciel, Mollie linked to an important piece by Sandro Magister, "Legionaries: The 'Nomenklatura' that Must Disappear." Next month, the five bishops who led investigations of the the Legion--Archbishop Chaput in the United States--will
MORE
Jon Ward of the Daily Caller has a stunning interview with Bart Stupak:
“The [National] Right to Life and the bishops, in 2007 when George Bush signed the executive order on embryonic stem cell research, they all applauded the executive order,” Stupak said in an interview with The Daily
MORE
Peter Nixon's comment on Matt Boudway's Jost post is worth highlighting here:
I worked in Washington DC for ten years and am familiar with... “worst case scenarioism,” where opponents of legislation come up with increasingly bizzare predictions of how a particular bill could lead to
MORE
NCR's Tom Fox has an exclusive interview with the lesbian couple whose children are no longer welcome in the Archdiocese of Denver's Catholic schools.
What happened? It all began two weeks ago:
“I went in to turn in our daughter’s kindergarten application and was called into the principal
MORE
"If that frightened, unemployed 19-year-old knows that she and her child will have access to medical care whenever it's needed, she's more likely to carry the baby to term. Isn't it obvious?" -- Cardinal Basil Hume to T. R. Reid, as reported in Reid's Washington Post column, "
MORE
From Sr. Carol Keehan, DC:
The insurance reforms will make the lives of millions more secure, and their coverage more affordable. The reforms will eventually make affordable health insurance available to 31 million of the 47 million Americans currently without coverage.
CHA has a major concern
MORE
As blogged by Paul Moses here, a Catholic school in Boulder, Colorado, has told a lesbian couple that their children cannot re-enroll next year. Yesterday, in a column posted to the Web site of the Archdiocese of Denver, Archbishop Charles Chaput tried to explain that decision.
First,
MORE
A new report by the Social Science Research Council (posted at the Immanent Frame and written by Nathan Schneider) names dotCommonweal as one of the hundred (or so) most influential religion blogs. So, what's the survey all about?
It places this religion blogosphere in the context of the
MORE
Did you miss Mollie's post on Scott Horton's doubters? Give that a read and come back. All set? OK.
Horton just posted a follow-up to his important piece on the three Gitmo prisoners who, as he puts it, died under mysterious circumstances in 2006. Horton describes those circumstances:
According
MORE
Check out the mesmerizing New York Times interactive graphic of Obama's 2011 budget (and compare it with 2010
MORE
Speaker Pelosi says the votes for the Senate bill just aren't there.
"I don't see the votes for it at this time. The members have been very clear in our caucus about the fact that they didn't like it before it had the Nebraska provision and some of the other provisions that are unpalatable to
MORE
A bound galley of Terry Eagleton's forthcoming book On Evil just arrived in our office. Flipping through the front matter, I scanned for the name of the publisher (Yale), the expected pub date (April), and--most interesting--the dedication page. Too often ignored, dedication pages can be telling.
MORE
Via the New York Times Lede blog, Pat Robertson explains why Haiti suffered such devastation yesterday.
[S]omething happened a long time ago in Haiti, and people might not want to talk about it. They were under the heel of the French. You know, Napoleon the third, or whatever. And they got
MORE
PrayTell is a joint venture of St. John's Collegeville and the Liturgical Press. The blog features an impressive roster of contributors, including dotCommonweal regular Rita Ferrone (we trust she won't abandon us). What can you expect? Take it away, newly knighted blogmaster Anthony Ruff , OSB:
MORE
As you can see, we've redecorated. With the move to a new site comes the inevitable unforeseeable glitches. Will you give us a hand ferreting them out? Already you'll notice that blog comments are displaying e-mail addresses instead of registered usernames. That's a major problem, and we're on it
MORE
Must-reads from the New York Times: Peter Baker's impressive piece "How Obama Came to Plan for 'Surge' in Afghanistan" and the reporting team's Q&A with readers
MORE
While most of us were gorging ourselves yesterday, Ireland was busy digesting a government report on their own clergy sexual-abuse scandal. Its verdict? Over a period of thirty years, diocesan authorities systematically covered up sexual-abuse allegations against clergy--in collusion with the
MORE
Is this two years in a row or three that I've posted this classic WKRP clip? What the hell?--it's tradition. Happy Thanksgiving, everybody. (You can watch the whole episode, and the rest of the first season, at Hulu
MORE
Big news from the AP:
A preliminary report commissioned by the nation's Roman Catholic bishops on the roots of the clergy sex-abuse scandal found no evidence that gay priests were more likely than heterosexual clergy to molest children, the study's lead authors said yesterday.
The full $2
MORE
As the USCCB continues to discuss the new liturgical translations, perhaps you'd be interested in reading a backgrounder on the controversy, courtesy of John Wilkins, former editor of the Tablet of London.
On December 4, 1963, at the end of the council’s second session, the [Constitution on
MORE
UPDATE: Show's over, folks, but feel free to continue the discussion below. The USCCB meeting page is here
MORE
The New York Times reports:
Top executives at Blackwater Worldwide authorized secret payments of about $1 million to Iraqi officials that were intended to silence their criticism and buy their support after a September 2007 episode in which Blackwater security guards fatally shot 17 Iraqi
MORE
In which he discusses health-care reform and the common good, which he wrote about for Commonweal last month (transcript here
MORE
One of the reasons the Vatican decided to launch an investigation of U.S. women religious? Feminism. Tablet Rome correspondent Robert Mickens reports:
The official that initiated the Vatican's investigation of women religious in the United States admitted this week that the enquiry was fueled by
MORE
In case you missed it, Robert Mickens's comment from Peggy's thread below deserves your attention:
A very helpful piece by John Allen to begin the discussion.
However, in absence of the actual Apostolic Constitution it is difficult and dangerous to draw too many conclusions. We are left only
MORE
Yesterday on the First Thoughts blog Mary Rose Rybak posted a video of First Things Associate Editor David Goldman's appearance on the Larry Kudlow program. Kudlow had convened a panel to discuss the value of the U.S. dollar. "Watch FT’s own David Goldman dominate the discussion on last
MORE
Too many sexual-abuse settlements, not enough money, says the bishop.
The Chapter 11 filing in U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware lists assets of as much as $100 million and liabilities of as much as $500 million for the nonprofit.
The diocese encompasses 58 parishes, 21
MORE
Rufus Phillips wonders whether President Obama really grasps the nature of our Afghanistan problem. Who's he? George Packer explains:
Rufus Phillips, raised in rural Virginia and educated at Yale, was a young C.I.A. officer in Saigon in the nineteen-fifties, a protege of the legendary Colonel
MORE
That's a term that appears in the Cardinal George interview mentioned by Cathy Kaveny. It also came up during a 1999 symposium sponsored by Commonweal and held at Loyola University Chicago, "The Crisis of Liberal Catholicism." Speakers included Cardinal George, Peter Steinfels, E. J.
MORE
After you're finished reading Sister X, be sure to check out Dan Callahan's important article "America's Blind Spot: Health Care & the Common Good."
The concept of the common good, ancient in origin, would seem on the face of it an ideal foundation for health-care reform. We
MORE
Maybe it's a bit early to decide, but with most of the nation bathed in sun, it could be a slow day for dotCommonweal. The comment comes from Commonweal contributor Jean Raber (most recent piece on the new Beguines here--subscribers only). Jean was responding to the following comment from Mark
MORE
Good get for Politics Daily:
We teach that health care is a basic human right, an essential safeguard of human life and dignity.... Health care reform especially needs to protect those at the beginning of life and at its end -- the most vulnerable and the voiceless. It is essential that reform
MORE
Are you planning to join us in New York to celebrate our eighty-fifth anniversary?
Date: 10.19.09.
Time: 6:30 p.m.
Place: Pier 60, Chelsea Piers.
Honoree: Tim Shriver, Chairman of the Special Olympics.
Presenter: Mark Shields, PBS commentator and columnist.
Dinner chair: Rev.
MORE
When it comes to "abortion neutral" health-care reform legislation, Peter writes in today's New York Times, the status quo is in the eye of the beholder.
Currently the federal government does not pay for abortions under Medicaid, except in cases of rape, incest or physical threat to
MORE
First up, the National Right to Life Committee:
"The claim that a federal agency would be spending private funds on abortion, not federal funds, is absurd on its face, a political hoax," [NRLC legislative director Douglas] Johnson said.
Next, Bill Donohue:
MORE
Karl Vick of the Washington Post reports on the pernicious practice of insurance-policy "recission"--when insurers decide to cancel a policy on the grounds that they've been misled:
"They said I never mentioned I had a back problem," said Marrari, 52, whose coverage with Blue
MORE
At Salon:
Let's get on with it, Mr. President. We're up the proverbial creek with spaghetti as our paddle. This healthcare thing could have been the crossing of the Delaware, the turning point in the next American Revolution -- the moment we put the mercenaries to rout, as Gen. Washington did
MORE
A Daily Dish reader reports on his school's absurd response to President Obama's planned nationally televised speech to students:
I teach in a midwestern, upper-middle class suburban school.
(...)
Today there were two more e-mails about the speech from my principal. The first re-affirmed
MORE
(After writing this I realized Dave Gibson already posted on the statement. But, because my post does something a bit different from his, I'm leaving it up.)
Via John Allen: Archbishop Naumann of Kansas City in Kansas and Bishop Joseph Finn of Kansas City-St. Joseph have released a "Joint
MORE
Good piece in today's New York Times.
As recently as July, the bishops’ conference had largely embraced the president’s goals, although with the caveat that any health care overhaul avoid new federal financing of abortions. But in the last two weeks some leaders of the conference, like
MORE
In what seems to be a rejoinder to America magazine's strong, persuasive editorial on the controversy surrounding President Obama and Notre Dame, Bishop John D'Arcy of Fort Wayne/South Bend restates his case against inviting the president to speak at commencement and awarding him an honorary doctor
MORE
Today's must-read: the first, jaw-dropping article in the Times' important two-part series "Interrogation, Inc." Bear with me as I quote at some length:
Jim Mitchell and Bruce Jessen were military retirees and psychologists, on the lookout for business opportunities. They found an
MORE
From the New York Times obituary:
Mrs. Shriver’s official efforts on behalf of people with developmental challenges began after she became the executive vice president of the Joseph P. Kennedy Jr. Foundation in 1957. The foundation was established in 1946 as a memorial to her oldest brother, who
MORE
Last week half-term governor of Alaska Sarah Palin delivered her unhinged description of Obamacare:
The America I know and love is not one in which my parents or my baby with Down Syndrome will have to stand in front of Obama's "death panel" so his bureaucrats can decide, based on a
MORE
From the Times obit:
Budd Schulberg, who wrote the award-winning screenplay for “On the Waterfront” and created a classic American archetype of naked ambition, Sammy Glick, in his novel “What Makes Sammy Run?,” died on Wednesday. He was 95 and lived in the Brookside section of Westhampton
MORE
...provided it stays off TV.
The Colbert ReportMon - Thurs 11:30pm / 10:30cThe Word - A Perfect Worldwww.colbertnation.comColbert Report Full EpisodesPolitical HumorMark Sanford
MORE
And now a brief PSA: For those of you plugged into these newfangled social networking sites, you may want to check out our fan page on Facebook and follow us on Twitter. The future is now
MORE
Peter Steinfels wants to know.
That is meant as a serious, honest question, not a snap way of dismissing a remarkable document, brimming with profound ideas and moral passion and issued at a time when it could hardly be more relevant. The matter is all the more confounding since Benedict has often
MORE
John Allen reports:
In what could be seen as another piece of fallout from Benedict XVI’s January decision to lift the excommunications of four traditionalist bishops, including one who is a Holocaust denier, the pope today restructured the Vatican office that handles relations with the
MORE
We're just about to put the July 17 issue to bed. But before we do, we thought you'd be interested in Editor Paul Baumann's account of last week's POTUS/Catholic press meeting--just posted to the homepage. It begins:
“Apologies for the short notice,” began the e-mail I received late in the
MORE
Via Melinda Henneberger at Politcs Daily, a disturbing report from Politico about the Washington Post's latest fundraising plan, apparently cooked up by CEO and publisher Katherine Weymouth:
For $25,000 to $250,000, The Washington Post has offered lobbyists and association executives off-the-
MORE
You know how to bank. In honor of Canada Day, we're de-firewalling our piece on the Canadian banking system, "Northern Light." Kick back, pour yourself a glass of maple syrup, and marvel at their sound financial management
MORE
(H/T Andrew Sullivan, who has more on the BBC report right here.)
For more on detainee abuse in the "war on terror," read Michael Peppard's article "Disgrace," now the lead story on our home page
MORE
What's going to happen tomorrow? Will Ahmadinejad lose to the reformer Hossein Mousavi? Will the Revolutionary Guard crack down on Mousavi's youth movement? Read all about it:
The all-night street rallies and the joyful campaign of Mousavi's supporters have rekindled the passions and hopes of
MORE
William Saletan has some good advice for participants in the president's abortion-reduction meetings.
Dear Ms. Barnes and other pro-choice participants in these meetings: Please give up this distinction [between "reducing the need for abortions" and "reducing abortions"]. No
MORE
Really, Christianity Today? A Q&A with Samuel Wurzelbacher? Really? "They know where I stand," W2 says, "and they know that I wouldn’t have them anywhere near my children. But at the same time, they’re people, and they’re going to do their thing." (HT TPM
MORE
Free for all to read:
Ananda Rose Robinson's piece on the new deportees: "Borderline: Stranded in Nogales"
Cathy Kaveny's column on conscience protections: "The Right to Refuse"
Mollie Wilson O'Reilly's review of the play Irena's Vow: "The Miracle Worker&
MORE
On last weekend's episode of Religion & Ethics Newsweekly. Be sure to watch the second clip, too (by clicking the "extended discussion" tab below the video box). Regrettably, there's no transcript for the online-only portion of the interview, but here is an excerpt from the
MORE
Over at the Vox Nova blog, Morning's Minion has posted a long, thoughtful reflection on l'affaire Notre Dame. In case you can't read the whole thing right now, here's the outtro:
The Catholic right may think they have won a major tactical victory with the “watershed moment” over Obama’s
MORE
The AP reports:
When President Barack Obama eased limits on taxpayer-funded embryonic stem cell research, the big question became how far scientists could go. Friday, the government answered: They must use cells culled from fertility clinic embryos that otherwise would be thrown away.
(...)
MORE
I hesitate to give this any space at all, but here goes. Another Obama-hates-Jesus meme is spreading around the conservative blogosphere. An outfit called CNSNews (no relation to Catholic News Service) published a piece claiming that, at the request of the White House, Georgetown covered the
MORE
Richard Armitage on his tenure with the Bush administration.
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3hEvvUBkYDk&eurl=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.huffingtonpost.com%2F2009%2F04%2F15%2Frichard-armitage-on-tortu_n_187391.html&feature=player_embedded[/youtube]
(H/T HuffPo
MORE
Randall Thompson: Alleluia - Voices of Ascension, Dennis Keene (conductor), Mark Kruczek (organ
MORE
Stainer: God so loved the world - The Chapel Choir of University College,
MORE
Been meaning to post a music-recommendation thread for months now. What's on your iPod--or your turntable? What are you playing, singing? This is the time of year when I spend my commute brushing up on choral pieces for the Triduum. I'll be back in the motherland this Easter--subject to the musical
MORE
Brilliant.
Prague's Franz Kafka International Named World's Most Alienating
MORE
Ken Woodward makes his case in today's Washington Post:
I am an alumnus of Notre Dame. I am adamantly pro-life, independent as a voter -- and greatly pleased that Obama has agreed to speak at my alma mater. He joins six other sitting presidents going back to Dwight D. Eisenhower -- including
MORE
Paul Lauritzen interviews the Nigerian Jesuit Uwem Akpan, whose critically acclaimed collection of short stories, Say You’re One of Them, won the 2009 Commonwealth Writers' Prize (Africa region
MORE
Housekeeping memo. From now on the E. J. Dionne Jr. columns that we aren't able to run in the print edition will appear on our Web site. The first one--"Fighting the Politics of Evasion"--is available right here. Be sure to check the home page regularly for updates
MORE
The Times recently reported that New York Gov. David Paterson has favored legislation that would suspend the statute of limitations in sex-abuse cases involving private institutions. (Their editorial page opined on the matter here.) Apparently he's had a change of heart.
"These types of cases
MORE
Darius Rejali looks at the history behind the CIA's torture techniques.
In the 20th century, there were two main traditions of clean torture—the kind that doesn't leave marks, as modern torturers prefer. The first is French modern, a combination of water- and electro-torture. The second is Anglo
MORE
The New York State Assembly Codes Committee approved a controversial bill that would suspend the statutes of limitations in cases of sexual abuse involving private institutions. Now the bill will go to the Assembly floor for a vote.
For those who would rather not read the whole piece, excerpts
MORE
It's true. Against the advice of Tim Geithner, AIG will pay out roughly half a billion in bonuses to the 370 people who bankrupted the company. In a letter to Secretary Geithner, AIG CEO Liddy claims that when it comes to these bonuses, "AIG's hands are tied." Liddy trots out the same
MORE
Must read: Mark Danner's harrowing review of the Red Cross report on the CIA's treatment of fourteen "high value" detainees.
And so, after a devastating and unprecedented attack, the gloves came off. Guided by the President and his closest advisers, the United States transformed itself
MORE
Stewart vs. Cramer (H/T everyone):
.cc_box a:hover .cc_home{background:url(\\'http://www.comedycentral.com/comedycentral/video/assets/syndicated-logo-over.png\\') !important;}.cc_links a{color:#b9b9b9;text-decoration:none;}.cc_show a{color:#707070;text-decoration:none;}.cc_title a{color:#868686;
MORE
Breaking details about Commonweal's eighty-fifth anniversary celebration, Commonweal Conversations:
Date: Monday, October 19, 2009 at 6:30 p.m.
Place: Pier 60, Chelsea Piers, New York City
Receiving the second Catholic in the Public Square Award: Tim Shriver, chairman of Special Olympics
MORE
On March 26, the National Pastoral Life Center will celebrate its twenty-fifth anniversary with a symposium on St. Paul--featuring Peggy Steinfels, Tom Beaudoin, Cardinal Maradiaga, and Fr. Robert Schreiter--followed by a banquet honoring Commonweal contributors E. J. Dionne Jr. and Msgr. Harry
MORE
So I neglected to mention that a few of us from Team Commonweal have invaded the Los Angeles Religious Education Congress. Any other Commonwealers among the throngs? Stop by booth 213 and say hello. Free issues for those who mention dotCommonweal! For every copy of America you turn in, get two
MORE
Just as the AP calls it, the Journal-Sentinel reports that Timothy Dolan will be New York's next archbishop.
It's official. Here's the press release from the Archdiocese of New York.
Even if they're mistaken, and I seriously doubt that, you'll be interested And be sure to read Archbishop
MORE
Ten years ago today, film critic Gene Siskel passed away. On the Sun-Times Web site, Roger Ebert has posted a moving remembrance of his long-time sparring partner, some-time nemesis, and dear friend. It's a long, rich piece, so I encourage you to read it all, but here's one of the more interesting
MORE
Facing more than 200 sexual-abuse lawsuits, the Oregon Province of the Society of Jesus has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. In the filing, the province claims about $5 million in assets with liabilities nearing $62 million. CNS has the story.
"Our decision to file Chapter 11 was
MORE
Finding it hard to keep things interesting with your spouse in these dire economic times? Fear not. ForYourMarriage.org, an initiative of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, is on it. The Web site recently published a list of "ten cheap dates."
Heart: right place. Execution...
MORE
Remember when Roland Burris swore up and down (and apparently under oath) that he had not been in contact with Blago or the disgraced guv's people about that vacant U.S. Senate seat--until he was appointed? Yeah, not so much.
In the latest in a series of shifting accounts of his conduct, Sen.
MORE
From the New York Times liveblog of the A-Rod presser :
2:13 p.m.
Freudian Slip of the Decade:
“I’m here to take my medicine.”
Alex Rodriguez, February 17,
MORE
For 25 years. (I've mentioned him before here, here, and here.) The Trib reports:
The white-haired McGuire, convicted by a federal jury last October of traveling to engage in sex acts with a teenage boy, showed little reaction to the testimony. When it finally came time for him to speak, McGuire,
MORE
Pranksters, take heed. As the AP reports, various state departments of transportation have had it with hackers who reprogram digital road-side signs to say things like...
And...
And...
Yes those are real. And if you're caught tampering with road-side signs in Indiana, where
MORE
The head of the Legion of Christ has written a letter to the group's lay movement in response to the revelations about Maciel. He doesn't allude to the news until the sixth paragraph.
As regards truth, the first thing we see in Christ’s presence is that he is the Truth, which leads us to look
MORE
.msnbcLinks {font-size:11px; font-family:Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif; color: #999; margin-top: 5px; background: transparent; text-align: center; width: 425px;} .msnbcLinks a {text-decoration:none !important; border-bottom: 1px dotted #999 !important; font-weight:normal !important; height: 13px;} .
MORE
I updated my post below, but just in case people aren't checking that thread, here's the latest development in the Williamson saga.
John Allen reports today that the Vatican has released a statement from SSPX superior Bishop Bernard Fellay, who apologizes for Williamson’s offenses. It reads,
MORE
Just posted by John Allen at NCR:
When the Vatican lifted the excommunication of four traditionalist Catholic bishops Jan. 21, it’s entirely possible Rome was unaware that one of those bishops, an Englishman named Richard Williamson, had just given an interview to Swedish television in which
MORE
One of the bishops recently welcomed back into the Catholic Church by Pope Benedict XVI
MORE
You remember Fr. Rodney Rodis. He's just been sentenced to thirteen years for embezzling nearly half a million dollars from his parish in Louisa County, Virginia. (Technically, the judge sentenced him to 200 years--the maximum--but suspended 187 of them.) AP story is here.
Authorities said Rodis
MORE
This brief reflection from First Things editor Joseph Bottum was just posted to the On the Square blog:
Fr. Richard John Neuhaus slipped away today, January 8, shortly before 10 o’clock, at the age of seventy-two. He never recovered from the weakness that sent him to the hospital the day
MORE
Slate's William Saletan has a few choice words for one section of Dignitas personae:
This document covers several interesting topics, which I hope to get to in the days ahead. But the one that calls for rebuttal right away is the section on "[n]ew forms of interception and contragestation.&
MORE
The Trib reports:
As legislators weigh impeaching Gov. Rod Blagojevich and federal prosecutors prepare to indict him on corruption charges, his acting chief of staff and a deputy governor will be keynote speakers Wednesday at an "Ethics in the Workplace" seminar for some 200 state
MORE
Today the Boston Globe published a curious op-ed by the head of the U.S. Catholic bishops' National Review Board, Judge Michael Merz. The occasion for the piece is the release of the film Doubt, adapted from John Patrick Shanley's Tony- and Pulitzer Prize-winning 2004 play about an accused
MORE
According to the feds, he tried to sell President-elect Obama's Senate seat. And that's not all. Brief summary at HuffPo. WaPo article here. Running Chicago Tribune updates here. Astonishing charges. Talking Points Memo is all over it
MORE
Our exclusive report on the USCCB's emergency meeting to address l'affaire Weis:
Chicago, Dec. 3 — The Administrative Committee of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) will convene an emergency meeting here today to discuss the University of Notre Dame’s decision to
MORE
Just posted: the cover story of the December 5 issue, Michael Peppard's "The Secret Weapon: Religious Abuse in the 'War on Terror.'"
“One time there was a long, tortured cry. I turned around. There was a second and then a third cry, but they sounded different from the cries of people
MORE
The classic WKRP turkey drop. Look out below. And happy Thanksgiving
MORE
According to the Sun-Times:
The Rev. Andrew Greeley, author and Sun-Times columnist, is now recovering at the Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago, weeks after he fell and suffered a head injury, a spokeswoman for the Catholic scholar said Tuesday.
Great news. Updates available here
MORE
As mentioned in a recent thread, George Weigel's latest column declares: "this year's election cycle clarified decisively...that the great public fissure in these United States is between the culture of life and the culture of death." How does he know? To wit:
Washingtonians
MORE
Maybe not. But, if you're interested, you can watch EWTN's live stream of the USCCB meeting here. They're discussing "Catholic Teaching in Political Life" right now. Start your air-poppers
MORE
Over the weekend, the New York Times ran a column on its coverage of the controversial Terrence McNally play Corpus Christi. Public Editor Clark Hoyt writes:
When Terrence McNally’s “Corpus Christi” was first produced in New York 10 years earlier, the Manhattan Theater Club said there were
MORE
The Diocese of Davenport, Iowa, which entered bankruptcy in 2006, announced yesterday that it has evidence that four clergymen sexually abused minors, including retired Bishop Lawrence Soens, whose case has been referred to the Vatican.
A five-member review board found Soens, who served as bishop
MORE
I've seen versions of this quote before. One of my favorites:
"Studs is a character," said Scott Craig, the producer of a 1989 WTTW-Ch. 11 documentary titled, simply, "Studs." "But that doesn't make him a caricature. He's been famous around here for so long that people
MORE
Then enroll at your nearest institution of higher learning. We're offering free subscriptions to undergraduates and grad students. All you have to do is e-mail your name, address, school, and expected year of graduation to Marketing Coordinator Nicole Benevenia: nicole-at-commonwealmagazine.org.
MORE
You think the presidential race has taken a nasty turn? Get a load of this brutal mailer sent out by Maricopa County Supervisor Fulton Brock, who accuses his opponent, Ed Hermes, of--are you sitting down?--living with his parents. It gets worse:
(View the full image here
MORE
I'm going to open up a thread during the debate tonight for those who'd like to mix it up in the comboxes. Think of it as a group liveblog. So come back when the grudge match starts. BYOB
MORE
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cP12aNzocSc[/youtube]
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2kjFn4s4sU[/youtube]
Watch CBS Videos
MORE
I can't find an image of the hilarious ad for Bill O'Reilly's new book that appeared in today's New York Times, so here's an approximation:
"William, you are a bold, fresh piece of humanity."--Sr. Mary Lurana, St. Brigid's School, 1957
Some things never change.
He's the host of
MORE
Obama calls McCain this morning to see if they can hammer out a joint statement on bailout principles. McCain returns call to accept the offer, then announces he will suspend his campaign tomorrow to focus on the crisis in Washington, urges Obama to do the same, and asks that Friday's debate be
MORE
We just posted our September 26 editorial on the home page. Here's the lede:
It is hard to know what is more exasperating, the ill-informed statements of Catholic prochoice politicians about the church’s teaching on abortion, or the response of certain bishops, whose criticism of politicians
MORE
A friend sent me the following reflection from one of his parishioners, who asked not to have his name attached. Well worth reading:
I am an alcoholic. I can say that now and know what it means- that was not always the case. When I first started coming to the rooms of AA I couldn’t say it. I
MORE
OBAMA AND JESUS: TWO “COMMUNITY ORGANIZERS”
September 10, 2008
On the floor of the House of Representatives today, Democratic Congressman Steve Cohen said that “Barack Obama was a community organizer like Jesus.”
Catholic League president Bill Donohue responded as follows:
“
MORE
For those who missed Bob Woodward's appearance on CBS last night
MORE
Anyone watching the speech and dotCom at the same time? Feel free to post your thoughts in this open thread
MORE
Google is great. Terrific search engine. Quick. Accurate. Free of clutter. Mettle-proving. Their e-mail client? Robust. Sure, there was a minor flap about "contextual ads" that appear on the basis of the words in your e-mails. But for limitless storage, who isn't willing to sacrifice a
MORE
From the Belleville News-Democrat:
A jury awarded $5 million to a former altar boy Wednesday, validating arguments by his attorneys that the Rev. Raymond Kownacki sexually abused him and other youths and that top officials of the Belleville Diocese covered it up for decades.
(...)
The jury
MORE
From Peter's column today--a Q&A with Doug Kmiec:
A. There is a widespread misconception that overturning Roe is the only way to be pro-life. In fact, overturning Roe simply returns the matter to the states, which in their individual legislative determinations could then be entirely pro-
MORE
We just posted a Web exclusive from Laura Sheahen of CRS--a journal from the first week of her deployment as an aid worker in Georgia.
Day Three: Friday, August 15
A CRS colleague waits in a tedious bank line to transfer $25,000—a first installment of several to come—so Caritas Georgia can
MORE
George Pawlaczyk of the Belleville News-Democrat reports:
While reports that the Rev. Raymond Kownacki was sexually molesting minors were piling up, Belleville Diocese bishops and other top church officials failed to investigate and routinely reassigned the priest six times to unsuspecting
MORE
For those who missed Andrew Bacevich on Bill Moyers tonight, check out the PBS Web site for the video and transcript. Commonweal readers will recognize Bacevich's arguments--he's offered versions of them here--but the whole interview is worth watching.
BILL MOYERS: You dedicate the book to your
MORE
Today the Chicago Tribune published its summary of Cardinal George's deposition in the $12-million settlement with abuse victims. It isn't pretty. Bear with me as I quote the piece at length.
In his deposition, George revealed under oath the steps, missteps and lies that led to McCormack's tenure
MORE
WBBM reports:
Cardinal Francis George announced the $12.675 million settlement himself, which involves ten Chicagoland priests and 16 abuse cases.
These abuse cases date back to the 1960s and extend through 2006. All of the priests have been removed from public ministry.
Its unclear how
MORE
Is anyone watching this? My rough transcription:
Costas: What are your impressions so far?
Bush: First of all, I think the Chinese are being great hosts. The venues are fantastic. And our team's fired up, and so am I. I'm excited to be here. It's such a thrill to watch our men and women compete
MORE
Just when you thought the HV anniversary rituals were over... For those who missed Peter Steinfels's excellent column in the New York Times yesterday, give it a read.
Often lost in these anniversary rituals is exactly what “Humanae Vitae” was about.
It was not, for example, an analysis and
MORE
I am a bit surprised that John Allen's Sunday Times op-ed has not yet occasioned comment at dotCom. I found it disappointing and, at points, quite strange--I'll try to say more about why later. In the meantime, pop over to Pontifications for David Gibson's astute analysis:
The principal comment on
MORE
What did you miss at the Museum of the City of New York last night? Sewell Chan reports at his Times blog, City Room:
Like the exhibition, the 90-minute discussion — moderated by Paul Baumann, editor of Commonweal magazine, a Catholic biweekly opinion journal — was heavy on history, but the
MORE
Find out tomorrow night tonight at the Museum of the City of New York:
Tuesday • July 22 • 6:30 PM
Is Anti-Catholicism Dead?
Paul Baumann, editor of Commonweal, will moderate a discussion about the history of anti-Catholicism and its resonance today. From the virulent nativist movements
MORE
Pat Lang wants to know why Bill Kristol was invited to a private meeting at Ft. Hood with Gen. Odierno, who is about to take over for Gen. Petraeus in Iraq:
Why was Kristol invited by the Defense department to Ft. Hood, Texas to talk to Odierno? Who were the other member of the "small group
MORE
Virginia Heffernan on the perils of quoting sources on the Interwebs:
I am stumped by how to excerpt the language on message boards and blogs.
Take a passage signed by zipthwung, an astute online commenter: “pornography if for the ruling classes and their violent vulgar all consuming
MORE
...to legitimate torture. Read Andrew Bacevich's review of Jane Mayer's The Dark Side.
In The Dark Side, Jane Mayer, a staff writer for the New Yorker, documents some of the ugliest allegations of wrongdoing charged against the Bush administration. Her achievement lies less in bringing new
MORE
We just updated the Web site with the July 8 issue. Be sure to read dotCommonweal regular Gene Palumbo's moving remembrance of Bill Ford, long-time friend of the magazine. Here's how it starts:
When William P. Ford died last month at the age of seventy-two, after a battle with esophageal cancer
MORE
Australia's ABC TV seems to have caught Cardinal George Pell of Sydney in a rather serious error. In a letter dated February 14, 2003, Pell wrote to abuse victim Anthony Jones to dismiss the allegation because, Pell claimed, he had received no other complaints against the accused priest, Fr.
MORE
It appears the pope has made them an offer--can they refuse
MORE
In his great column today, Peter Steinfels asks an important question about NRLC's decision to feature Karl Rove as a keynote speaker at its annual convention:
Is it politically naïve to be surprised that the nation’s leading anti-abortion organization, which describes itself as nonpartisan,
MORE
Just in from the National Pastoral Life Center:
Brian Williams, anchor and managing editor of NBC Nightly News will speak at the Philip J. Murnion Lecture for the Catholic Common Ground Initiative Friday, June 27 at 8 p.m. at the Pryzbyla Center of the Catholic University of America in
MORE
As noted by several blogs this week, Archbishop Edwin O'Brien of Baltimore has issued a letter to the Legionaries of Christ and its lay movement Regnum Christi requiring them to inform him of all their activities within the archdiocese--including names of priests, recruitment methods, the locations
MORE
Today the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that foreign terrorist suspects imprisoned at Gitmo have the right to challenge their detention in U.S. courts. The NY Times reports:
In a harsh rebuke of the Bush administration, the justices rejected the administration’s argument that the individual
MORE
On the off chance that any dotCommonweal readers were hankering for a break from the abortion debates, I thought I'd point out this great piece by Natalie Angier on the odobenus rosmarus, the only pinniped that walks with its teeth.
“The first thing the walruses will do when they come over is
MORE
Just posted as a Web exclusive: Don Wycliff's take on l'affaire Wright. A snippet:
Whatever may have been Wright’s motives for speaking out now, he stands to earn a dubious distinction in American history: the man who torpedoed the presidential chances of the first African American with a
MORE
Talking Points Memo reports on some very suspicious robocalls being made in North Carolina. In the calls, a man identifying himself as Lamont Williams delivers the following message:
In the next few days you will receive a voter registration packet in the mail. All you need to do is fill it out,
MORE
Something much more important than Rev. Wright's performances happened yesterday. Morris Davis, the DoD's former chief prosecutor for terrorism, took the stand at Gitmo in defense of a terrorism suspect and declared in so many words that the U.S. military tribunal system is a sham. The Washington
MORE
A view from the Tablet's Rome correspondent:
"Before he became Pope, Joseph Ratzinger was known as a very staunch Catholic," said one of New York's local TV personalities. The reporter said Benedict XVI had shown that "he really is a ‘people person', and that he is very open
MORE
The New Republic recently posted a Q&A with Philippe Sands, the author of an important new book on the role of lawyers in the Bush administration's so-called coercive interrogation techniques. A snippet:
One of the lawyers you focus on is Doug Feith--though he makes clear in his interview
MORE
Just as we learn that the Wall Street Journal's managing editor is expected resign after less than one year in the position, news comes that Rupert Murdoch has agreed to buy yet another New York-area paper, Newsday.
Selling the paper would be key to Tribune Chief Executive and Chicago real estate
MORE
Amid the overwhelmingly positive coverage of the pope's visit, Rocco Palmo's praise stood out especially fulsome. He described New York City as buzzing with energy over Benedict's visit. Perhaps Brooklyn doesn't count, but having spent some time this weekend in several neighborhoods in both the
MORE
Now this is genuinely surprising. John Allen reports that today Pope Benedict met privately with five victims at the Vatican embassy in Washington.
Prior to this afternoon, no pope had ever met with victims of sexual abuse by priests. That omission has been oft-cited by critics of the church’s
MORE
You know, I think he really meant it.
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i2bgmBqYDgA[/youtube
MORE
Posted to our Web site just moments ago
MORE
The New York Times is assembling an impressive amount of coverage for the papal visit, but its diagram of the Communion-distribution plan for Yankee Stadium contained an amusing gaffe. Can you find it
MORE
As noted below, Barack Obama just announced his National Catholic Advisory Council, which includes Commonweal columnist Cathleen Kaveny and me (and other Commonweal contributors, such as David O'Brien and Richard Gaillardetz). Diligent readers of dotCommonweal won't be terribly surprised by my
MORE
President Bush approved conversations detailing "enhanced interrogation" of detainees in the "war on terror." ABC News reports:
The most senior Bush administration officials repeatedly discussed and approved specific details of exactly how high-value al Qaeda suspects would be
MORE
A bit late to the party--which is just fine--Marquette theologian Fr. Bryan Massingale offers a thoughtful op-ed on the Jeremiah Wright controversy (from the Milwaukee Journal Sentinal):
The fact that many seem unable to move on is a signal that something more is fueling this ongoing discussion.
MORE
One of John Yoo's fateful 9/11-justifies-all memos was released this week, as a result of a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit filed several years ago. Lowlights from the Washington Post:
"If a government defendant were to harm an enemy combatant during an interrogation in a manner that might
MORE
Finally, a piece about John McCain's flirtations with the Democratic Party. This will be a serious problem for McCain once the Dems have their nominee
MORE
The New York Times has the prepared text. Update: essential reading. Those of you contributing to Robert Imbelli's thread should call a time-out and read the speech immediately. It's brilliant
MORE
In all the hoopla surrounding Rev. Wright, a very important news item has gone ignored.
Brooklyn's Sixpoint beer just released "Hop Obama" ale in New York and Massachusetts. From the press release:
In keeping with the Illinois senator's unifying theme, the "Hop Obama" is an
MORE
From the Dept. of Tit for Tat: "If Obama was a white man, he would not be in this position. And if he was a woman (of any color) he would not be in this position. He happens to be very lucky to be who he is. And the country is caught up in the concept." Last week, Geraldine Ferraro
MORE
Over at his blog Get Religion, Terry Mattingly--nom de Web "tmatt"--links to an L.A. Times story on the Los Angeles Religious Education Congress, which I returned from last week. Mattingly, a religion journo who apparently has never heard of the nearly forty-year-old event, finds the
MORE
I tried to get Leonard Nimoy to plug this, but turns out he's a busy man. So you're stuck with me. The big news for the Commonweal Web site this a.m. is that after many months of work spanning several continents (really), the complete Commonweal archive is now live. You can search everything we've
MORE
Republican Gov. Charlie Crist of Florida finds it "unconscionable" that Democratic delegates from his state and from Michigan will not be seated at the Democratic convention this summer (the GOP delegate counts in those states were only halved by the RNC), so he's calling for a re-vote.
MORE
TPM has put together a series of Hagee-related clips, including several moments of unhinged ranting (viewer discretion advised) and McCain's acceptance of his endorsement. What some of us Catholics are still waiting for is not simply an acknowledgment that McCain doesn't endorse everything Hagee
MORE
Just posted on the home page: Robert N. Bellah's case for Barack Obama, which will run in the March 14 issue, and Wilfrid Sheed's review of John Judis's 1998 book William F. Buckley, Jr.: Patron Saint of the Conservatives. Check them out
MORE
Completely forgot to mention this: fellow Commonweal staffer Marianne Tierney and I will be hosting the magazine's booth at the Los Angeles Religious Education Congress--starting tomorrow. (The Commonweal jet touched down just a few hours ago.) If you'll be among the horde of 30,000, swing by booth
MORE
I knew we couldn't trust those newfangled voting machines...
Diebold Accidentally Leaks Results Of 2008 Election Early
[Thanks, Joe
MORE
Speaking of Augustine...the Department of Justice has announced an investigation into waterboarding--sort of. Not a criminal investigation, of course--Attorney General Mukasey has already promised not to look into that (thank you, Chuck Schumer and Dianne Feinstein). Rather, DOJ's Office of
MORE
Hope I'm not stealing Peggy's thunder, but...
Here are CNN's Democratic exit polls, and here are their GOP exits.
Worth noting in the Democratic race: While Clinton and Obama nearly split the overall Catholic vote, 50 percent (Hillary) to 48 percent (Barack), Clinton won the weekly-Mass-
MORE
The latest issue of Commonweal went live yesterday--including our editorial, "Bridge Closed," on Bishop Edward K. Braxton's decision to refuse permission for Luke Timothy Johnson to speak in the Diocese of Belleville, Illinois.
Commonweal sponsors a speakers bureau that sends a handful
MORE
The Irish Times reports:
Former archbishop of Dublin Cardinal Desmond Connell, has withdrawn an attempt to stop documents handed over by his successor from being considered by the Government's inquiry into allegations of sexual abuse in the Dublin Archdiocese.
The withdrawal of the legal
MORE
After refusing to admit that waterboarding is torture, Attorney General Mukasey now says he won't bother to investigate whether the waterboarding inflicted by U.S. personnel--now admitted by the White House--was illegal. (He also won't investigate warrantless wiretapping.) Why? Because the Justice
MORE
As part of the Commonweal Speakers Program, Managing Editor Patrick Jordan recently gave a talk at St. John Student Parish at the Michigan State University. They run a very impressive operation--to wit, audio of Patrick's talk, titled "Dorothy Day: Her Message for Our Times," has already
MORE
What's happening to undersea cables delivering the Internet to the Middle East? Nobody seems to know
MORE
Check out the great NY Times feature "Voices from the Polls" for audio interviews with voters from polling places across the country today.
Update: And while we're at it, why not offer your own reports from your polling places? What did you see and hear
MORE
Item one: Fr. Tom Doyle recently penned an open letter to and about Voice of the Faithful--to which VOTF Board Chair Bill Casey responded. The exchange is not exactly a lovefest. I'd post Doyle's letter here, but it is long. You can read it at Voices in the Desert (scroll to the bottom of the post
MORE
Attorney General Michael Mukasey disappoints Sen. Charles Schumer--who voted to confirm Mukasey--by refusing to support a statute banning waterboarding, which is already illegal:
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iERRrY1m_Mo&eurl=http://www.tpmmuckraker.com/archives/005179.php[/
MORE
For those who missed 60 Minutes last night, check out the fascinating interview with FBI Agent George Piro, lead interrogator of Saddam Hussein.
"He told me that most of the WMD had been destroyed by the U.N. inspectors in the '90s. And those that hadn't been destroyed by the inspectors were
MORE
Not to pile on, but of all the commentary on the Clintons' attacks on Barack Obama, E. J. Dionne's is the best I've seen so far.Let's grant the Clintons their claims: The press is tougher on Hillary Clinton than it is on Barack Obama; the old, irrational Clinton hatred is alive and well in certain
MORE
No, not latest Hollywood adaptation of The Taming of the Shrew. Rather, the results of a study released by the Center for Public Integrity.
President George W. Bush and seven of his administration's top officials, including Vice President Dick Cheney, National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice,
MORE
As Eduardo mentioned here recently, the Nevada State Education Association (NSEA) along with six Nevada residents have filed a federal lawsuit to block caucus sites on the Vegas strip on the grounds that the process unfairly favors casino workers. Last year, the Nevada Democratic Party set up
MORE
On the latest Commonweal podcast, Paul Lauritzen interviews William B. Hurlbut, physician and consulting professor at Stanford's Neuroscience Institute. Hurlbut's main area of interest involves the ethical issues associated with advancing biomedical technology, the biological basis of moral
MORE
SNAP has released a 1983 letter from the late bishop Aloysius Wycislo of Green Bay to Fr. John Patrick Feeney, who was convicted of molestation in 2004 and laicized in 2005. The letter reads in part:
As I go through the total file of the hearings, your meetings with the personnel board, and your
MORE
So, what happened? A late break for Hillary that polls couldn't detect? Did the pollsters have the bad luck of stumbling on a group of liar-respondents? Theories abound: Her choke-up moment humanized her. Coupled with her debate performance, women were inspired to show their support. Bill's late
MORE
What did you see? What did you like? Dislike? Who succeeded? Who didn't? Who wants to adopt Bill Richardson
MORE
David Brooks's column on the Iowa results is well worth reading--and discussing, so have at it in the comboxes.Obama has achieved something remarkable. At first blush, his speeches are abstract, secular sermons of personal uplift — filled with disquisitions on the nature of hope and the
MORE
When I called the Kiriakou interview a Rorschach test I had in mind the probability that he wasn't being entirely above-board. First, while he was part of the team that captured Zubaydah, he wasn't present for the interrogations he describes. Second, his testimony gives aid and comfort to the Bush
MORE
Former JAG officer Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) put a hold on the bill in the Senate last week, claiming that "applying the Army Field Manual to the CIA would be ill-advised and would destroy a program that I think it lawful and helps the country." As Steve Benen points out, Graham's
MORE
Broken-record time again. Ohio Secretary of State Jennifer Brunner darkly summarizes her study of the state's five electronic voting systems like so: “It was worse than I anticipated. I had hoped that perhaps one system would test superior to the others.” Instead, the report found what we e-
MORE
Over at the First Things blog, Thomas Sieger Derr cites Pope Benedict as a supporter of his skepticism of the "climate-alarmism movement":
...in a message prepared for World Peace Day on January 1, but released today, [the pope is] warning us against the climate change prophets of doom.
MORE
Yesterday the House narrowly passed a bill that would outlaw a set of harsh interrogation methods. Predictably, President Bush threatened to veto it.
The administration particularly opposes restricting the CIA to interrogation methods approved by the military in 2006. That document prohibits
MORE
Now that the hot stove has cooled, it's time for Major League Baseball's steroid bombshell to drop: the Mitchel Report was released today (PDF). The four-hundred-page report implicates several top players, including Roger Clemens, Andy Pettitte, Jason Giambi, David Justice, Chuck Knoblauch (sensing
MORE
Brian Ross's long, fascinating interview with the former CIA agent John Kiriakou contains a wealth of information, including that all the "enhanced interrogation" techniques used by Kiriakou's team were approved by higher-ups--even waterboarding, which Kiriakou correctly calls torture. (
MORE
Over at Mirror of Justice, Rick Garnett isn't too taken with Eduardo's post on the Vatican and climate change.Eduardo writes, with respect to the news that the Holy See is sending a delegation to the climate-change conference in Bali:Let’s hope this signals the beginning of a shift away from the
MORE
All that flag says to me is Cardinal Rocky. (And the Liberty Bell?!) Other nominees
MORE
If anyone was wondering just how bad things have been at the CIA, the destroyed-interrogation-tapes controversy makes it clear: very. Today the New York Times reports that in 2003 officials in the White House and in the Department of Justice warned the CIA not to destroy the tapes, and at that time
MORE
This is been much blogged elsewhere, but in case you missed it, read the blockbuster New York Times story on the CIA's decision first to hide then to destroy two videotapes of detainee interrogations. Highlights:
The Central Intelligence Agency in 2005 destroyed at least two videotapes documenting
MORE
Quick round-up before lunch: In case you missed it, check out Ken Woodward's perceptive op-ed on Romney (published before the Big Speech). Commentary collection courtesy of Andrew Sullivan right here. Also have a look at Mathew Schmalz's Commonweal piece, "Meet the Mormons."
MORE
So, we made the big switch to dotCommonweal 1.5--apparently without a major hitch. We've already addressed a handful of minor problems, but if you encounter any more, please let us know in the comment boxes below. (If you find that the site is not displaying correctly in Safari or Firefox [Mac], as
MORE
Spencer Ackerman at TPM has been reading the recently leaked 2004 operations manual for military detentions at Gitmo.
Last month, Wikileaks published
the 2003 edition of the manual. Among other controversial provisions,
the manual instructed officials to hide certain detainees from the
MORE
Incoming: very early Thursday morning, dotCommonweal (but not the main site) will be down for about two hours while our Web developers install several upgrades, most of which are behind-the-scenes improvements. Here's how the user interface will change come Thursday: First--are you sitting down,
MORE
Today the New York Times published Linda Greenhouse's helpful preview of Wednesday's Supreme Court hearings, when detainee lawyer Seth Waxman will argue that--contra the Military Commissions Act of 2006 (MCA)--federal judges do have jurisdiction to hear the cases of Guantanamo Bay detainees. The
MORE
Welcome to the blogosphere, America! Be sure to check out their new blog, In All Things, which debuted this week
MORE
Andrew Sullivan links to Deal Hudson's post on Rudy Giuliani's paid consultant (and childhood friend) Msgr. Alan Placa, who was accused of sexual abuse in a 2003 grand-jury report and has been suspended from ministry for the past five years. Andrew asks the right question: Where's the press on this
MORE
Chicago Sun-Times writer Steve Patterson reports today on the disconcerting story of a parish business manager who warned the chancery about his pastor's questionable spending habits and was told to keep his yap shut--then fired.
Brockhagen was business manager at St. Margaret Mary -- the
MORE
"There's no chin behind Chuck Norris's beard. Only another fist." Classic. I don't know who thought up this spot, but he deserves a raise
MORE
The convicted sexual abuser Rev. Donald McGuire plans to fight the Jesuits' decision to dismiss him from the order. No surprise there. "They can't abandon me," he told the Chicago Sun-Times. Sure they can. The conviction isn't going to help his cause when the Congregation for the Doctrine
MORE
Jason Berry thinks not.
Cardinal Francis George, the archbishop of Chicago, is currently
preparing to assume the presidency of the Conference of Catholic
Bishops, whose annual meeting begins Monday in Baltimore. His new
position would make George highly visible when Pope Benedict XVI
arrives
MORE
Religion reporter Susan Hogan/Albach has a piece in today's Chicago Sun-Times that asks, "When and what did the archdiocese know?" She reports that in December 2002 a concerned father contacted the Archdiocese of Chicago to complain about Donald McGuire, SJ--convicted last year of
MORE
Those of you who have been following the depressing case of Donald McGuire, SJ, convicted last year of molesting two high-schoolers, will be interested to know that U.S. Magistrate Judge Arlander Keys just released Maguire on a $50K bond. McGuire was recently picked up by feds and charged with
MORE
Here's a sneak peek at our Nov. 9 issue, which will go up on the home page later this afternoon: "Torture's Enablers".
First you are strapped to a plank. Then the
plank is tilted so that your feet are above your head. Next a cloth is
pulled taut across your mouth, and finally water
MORE
Apparently Mukasey's unwillingness to call waterboarding torture along with his view that the president of the United States can operate outside the law weren't enough to persuade Senators Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) and Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.) that he's the wrong man for the job. Their endorsement
MORE
Yesterday President Bush invited reporters into the Oval Office for a preview of a speech he gave later that day at the Heritage Foundation. He's annoyed by how long the Mukasey confirmation is taking. Implying that the United States is at risk in the "war on terror" while operating
MORE
No, of course not. But you wouldn't know it from Diogenes' post on the magazine's recent editorial on British Prime Minister Gordon Brown. Here it is, in its entirety:
America ♥ Gordon
Posted by: Diogenes
- Oct. 29, 2007 1:51 PM ET USA
America Magazine is
MORE
Rudy says that whether waterboarding is torture "depends"--not only on what's being done but also, remarkably, who's doing it. John McCain disagrees.
“All I can say is that it was used in the Spanish Inquisition, it was used in Pol Pot’s
genocide in Cambodia, and there are reports
MORE
At an Iowa town-hall meeting, Linda Gustitus, president of the National Religious Campaign Against Torture, put a couple of questions to America's mayor. Noting that Attorney General-nominee Michael Mukasey had "fudged" when asked whether waterboarding is torture, Gustitus said:
“I
MORE
Congressional hearings on the absurdly unfair postal rate hike will be held on October 30 at 10 a.m. Victor Navasky of the Nation and Jeff Hollingsworth of Human Events are going to testify about the damage the rate increase is doing to political and cultural periodicals. Remember, the National
MORE
The Tribune's Mark Silva has a partial transcript.
RUSSERT: You know, if you look at the voting blocs that exist in
South Carolina and around the country, I'm quite surprised the way you
treat them in this book. Senior citizens -- this is what you call them
-- "old people." "
MORE
Several friends have sent this image to me. Supposedly, the direction in which you see the dancer spinning reflects which side of your brain is dominant. Apparently
most people see the dancer rotating in a counterclockwise direction. When I first looked, I
saw her spinning clockwise. But with
MORE
Bill Cork on John Allen on Pope Benedict's upcoming beatification of Fr. Gabino Olaso Zabala. First Allen:
According to written testimony from the victim, Olaso
participated in the 1896 torture of a Filipino priest named Fr. Mariano
Dacanay, who was suspected of sympathy for anti-Spanish
MORE
Courtesy of the preposterously unfair postal-rate hike, which will cost NCR an additional $95,000 annually. They're going to publish twenty-four times a year, and increase the page count of each issue. I can't find any announcements online yet, but below is a scan of the letter they sent to
MORE
For God Is Not Great, natch. Gene McCarraher, start your engines
MORE
Paul Lauritzen is back with his latest podcast: an interview with longtime friend of Commonweal, Sidney Callahan. You may recall that Sidney's new book Created for Joy was positively reviewed by dotCommonwealer Robert Imbelli. Give a listen below, download it directly, or subscribe via iTunes
MORE
Iraq was just the beginning:
Founded this summer by a dozen wealthy conservatives, the nonprofit
group [Freedom's Watch] is set apart from most advocacy groups by the immense wealth of
its core group of benefactors, its intention to far outspend its rivals
and its ambition to pursue a
MORE
America magazine has posted a slew of letters they received in response to Fr. Miscamble's article on Catholic identity at Notre Dame. Keep an eye out for a few Commonweal and dotCommonweal regulars. (Registration is required.)And don't forget:
John McGreevy's response to Miscamble in Commonweal
MORE
About those armed nuclear missiles that were transported by plane through U.S. airspace... The WaPost reports that it was the result of a "simple error." One Talking Points Memo writer isn't buying it:
So let’s see: not only did the munitions custodian officer lose track
of the
MORE
At the Fordham forum on Iraq last night, one of many astute audience members asked whether there can be a genuine moral accounting for the injustice of the war without a mea culpa from those responsible. In that vein, have a look at the trailer to the film No End in Sight, which Andrew Sullivan dug
MORE
A small housekeeping matter, dotCommonwealers: We've been hit with our first comment spam (took them long enough), so we've had to implement image verification with every comment. I know it's a pain in the neck, but spammers are a clever lot, and this is a relatively painless way to keep our blog
MORE
Georgetown University theologian--and Commonweal contributor--Rev. Peter Phan (a priest of Dallas) is being looked at, according to John Allen:
Both the Vatican and the U.S. bishops are
investigating a book by a prominent American Catholic theologian, Vietnam-born
Fr. Peter Phan of
MORE
Talking Points Memo has helpfully posted a slew of videos related to the general and his report. Here are a few worth watching.First up, a snippet from Petraeus's exclusive interview with that bastion of fairminded journalism, Fox News. Take it away, Brit...Did you catch that? Hume asked Petraeus
MORE
That's the title of our editorial in the new issue of Commonweal, which went live on the homepage today. Serendipitously, the new iteration of Crisis magazine also launched today: Inside Catholic is the umbrella Web site that hosts the now online-only Crisis, its parent organization the Morley
MORE
The New Republic has posted a useful primer on the myriad Iraq reports that have already been issued. It's worth reading before General Petraeus delivers his tomorrow.Also worth reading: today's New York Times editorial on the general's report.
As Congress waited anxiously for General Petraeus
MORE
Reuters reports:
The Roman Catholic Diocese of San Diego has settled lawsuits with
144 victims of sexual abuse by priests for $198 million, the diocese
and lawyers for the victims said on Friday.
The settlement was twice as much as the diocese offered five months
ago to resolve
MORE
As predicted, Virginia authorities have dropped their embezzlement charges against Fr. Rodney Rodis to make way for the feds, who arraigned Rodis today new charges of stealing half a million dollars from his two parishes, mail fraud, wire fraud, and money laundering. According to prosecutors, Fr
MORE
Bracing figures from the Census Bureau: 47 million Americans (15.8 percent of the population) lack health insurance, up from 44.8 million last year. And the number of uninsured children rose for the second consecutive year--after years of steady decline. The Los Angeles Times reports:
Most of the
MORE
I realize I'm beginning to sound like a broken record on this topic, but it's an important one. The cable channel HDNet recently aired a Dan Rather special on the myriad and very serious problems with computer touchscreen voting machines that is well worth watching. (Warning: it's about an hour
MORE
Big news in today's (or, technically, tomorrow's) the Age of Melbourne :
THE Catholic Church is still not serious about confronting
sexual abuse, only "managing" it, according to the Sydney bishop
who headed Australian efforts to tackle abuse.(...)
Bishop Robinson, 70, who was
MORE
Mark Lilla's New York Times Magazine article has garnered some attention on this blog and elsewhere. I recently received the following helpful response to the piece from Dean Brackley, SJ, of the Universidad Centroamericana in San Salvador. Have a look:
Mark Lilla's essay "The Politics of
MORE
Late last year, I blogged on the decision of the Priests of Holy Cross, Indiana Province, to close Notre Dame High School for Boys (my alma mater). A few months later, I wrote a piece for the National Catholic Reporter detailing how province came to that difficult decision, and how the school would
MORE
I recently bumped Peter Galbraith's New York Review of Books article, "Iraq: The Way To Go." The NYRB had the bright idea of fielding readers' questions about the piece and forwarding them to Galbraith for his response. You can read the exchange right here. From Galbraith's replies:
I
MORE
A few items I've been meaning to plug...
Cardinal George spoke to local Chicago news about the sentencing of admitted molester Fr. Daniel McCormack. He admitted his own mistakes in the case--which, along with the errors of several others, were very serious--but refused to say exactly what
MORE
Rejoice: the August 17 Commonweal was just posted on the homepage. Some highlights:
"$660 Million"--our editorial on the Los Angeles sexual-abuse settlement.
"The Face of God"--Peter Steinfels's take on Benedict XVI's Jesus of Nazareth.
"All Too Real"--
MORE
The most recent New York Review of Books contains the usual selection of excellent articles. (Regretably, they firewalled a review of Wilfrid Sheed's new book, so read Garrison Keillor's NY Times review instead.) But before you dip into the somewhat less depressing fare, be sure to read Peter
MORE
In the comment boxes of Peter Nixon's post on the feast of St. Ignatius of Loyola, Robert Imbelli mentioned the marvelous fresco La Madonna della Strada, which was recently--and rather dramatically--restored. Thanks to the cybersleuthing of dotCom reader Alan Andolsen, you can have a look at the
MORE
As if the they needed more exposure, in the latest Civilita Cattolica a Jesuit argues for the SJs to set up shop in the online virtual-world game Second Life--a game not exactly known for its spiritual depth.
Father Antonio Spadaro, the literary critic of "Civilta' Cattolica" and
an
MORE
Today's New York Times contains an Editorial Observer piece on the return of the old Mass. Writer Lawrence Downes recounts his experience at a Tridentine "low" Mass at a Chicago church:
I went up the steps of the Renaissance-baroque church, through a
stone doorway and back into my
MORE
The New York City Department of Buildings Web site shows that an undated demolition permit for the ill-fated parish is on file. A curious squib recently appeared in the Villager, a local paper covering Vilnius's neighborhood:
On a stroll through Hudson Square on Monday, we passed Our Lady of
MORE
There isn't a tremendous amount of attention being paid to the issue of computer voting machines, but there ought to be. It seems that every tech-head who's had a chance to hack the machines has been successful. They are not the solution to the hanging-chad problem. They are a disaster waiting to
MORE
In his second Commonweal podcast, Paul Lauritzen interviews Karen Long, book review editor for the Cleveland Plain Dealer, about the magazine's summer-reading feature, along with other notable books, such as Be Near Me and The Gravedigger's Daughter. You can listen to the show via the embedded
MORE
Katie Couric puts the former chairman of the National Review Board in the hot seat
MORE
On September 1, Crisis will go online-only under the new domain TheCatholicInsider.com, which will also host the Morley Institute. In the Morley Publishing Group's press release, Brian Saint-Paul, editor of Crisis, explained: "With this transition, we're actually able to expand our mission,
MORE
Some notable items in the L.A. abuse scandal story:
Reuters reports that Latinos in the Archdiocese of Los Angeles (half the city) continue to support Cardinal Mahony. Shocker.
The civil suits may have been settled, but there remains the possibility of criminal prosecution.
An L.A. Daily
MORE
The figure is astonishing--over half a billion dollars in abuse settlements involving 508 victims. And that is not including the $114 million the L.A. Archdiocese paid out earlier this year. No wonder Cardinal Mahony announced he was selling the chancery in May. But that building won't come close
MORE
Andrew Sullivan isn't optimistic about the president's press conference on Iraq (transcript):
He's arguing he didn't decide to go to war; Saddam did. He's saying he
agrees with his Republican critics. He's blaming the generals for all
the combat decisions that have made this war a failure. His
MORE
Be sure to jump over to the home page to read the just-released issue of Commonweal, including Jack Miles's review of the pope's book on Jesus, the editorial on dialogue among Catholic scholars, and Richard Alleva's latest film review. Anxious to get at some of the subscribers-only features (you'
MORE
From the Congressmen and -women's press release:
Fourteen Members of Congress including Congresswoman Rosa DeLauro (CT-03) and
Congressman Tim Ryan (OH-17) sent a letter to the U.S. Conference of Catholic
Bishops (USCCB) last Thursday, calling on the Bishops to increase their
involvement in
MORE
Today, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith released something called "Responses to some Questions
Regarding Certain Aspects of the Doctrine on the Church." I'm not sure who was asking, but here's the link to the Vatican Information Service story about the document, which
MORE
And--hard to believe, I know--much more pressing (not that I'm expecting motu-level comments here): Yesterday the New York Times editorial page called for the United States to withdraw from Iraq. Some highlights:
Continuing to sacrifice the lives and limbs of American soldiers is
wrong. The war
MORE
I meant to blog this sooner, but in case you missed it, take the time to read the Washington Post's much-talked-about four-part blockbuster on Dick Cheney. The articles provide plenty of context for today's news.And while you're at it, have a look at the hilarious, and at times frightening, piece
MORE
So, he did it. He really did it. The convicted purjurer Libby is guilty still, but the president found the prison sentence "excessive," so he commuted it (Scooter still has to pay the fine, though--see, crime doesn't pay). In making the decision, the president opted out of running it
MORE
Several months ago, I blogged on the painful case of Fr. Daniel McCormack, 38, whose alleged abuses made the holes in the Archdiocese of Chicago's abuse policy all too clear. Now it appears that he'll plead guilty to charges that he abused five boys at his West Side church. Allegedly, abuse took
MORE
A few weeks back, dotCommonweal contributor Paul Lauritzen generously offered to helm an experiment in podcasting for the site. His first effort is an interview with Fr. Donald Cozzens, author of Freeing Celibacy. The interview focuses on the sexual-abuse scandals--including due process for accused
MORE
Since this subject popped up in the iPope thread (God knows why), here's a place for dotCom readers to discuss--with exemplary civility--the looming motu propio. From Vatican Information Service:
VATICAN CITY, JUN 28, 2007 (VIS) - Given below is the text of a communique released today by the Holy
MORE
Commonweal contributor Andrew Bacevich in Monday's L.A. Times:
In fact, the great lesson of Iraq (further affirmed in Afghanistan) is that the umma
— the Arabic name for the entire Muslim community — is all but
impervious to change imposed from the outside. If anything, our
ham-handed
MORE
Seymour Hersch's infuriating piece on General Taguba and his hamstrung investigation of the Abu Ghraib atrocities.
If there was a redeeming aspect to the affair, it was in the
thoroughness and the passion of the Army’s initial investigation. The
inquiry had begun in January, and was led by
MORE
Andrew Sullivan posted this over the weekend--The Simpsons on heaven
MORE
Some of you nonsubscribers out there (for shame!) may have noticed that we had placed Eugene McCarraher's review of Christopher Hitchens's God Is Not Great behind the subscriber-only firewall. Well, we decided that it was far too good to hide under a bushel, so now the piece is free to the masses
MORE
I hate to interrupt the orgy of pop-culture commentary, but in case you weren't able to access our Web site yesterday, don't forget to check out the home page, which was updated on Monday--especially Luke Johnson's and Eve Tushnet's pieces on homosexuality and Scripture. Read, digest, discuss.P.S.
MORE
Or even good. So says Paul Baumann in his review of Christopher Hitchens's latest book, which appears in the June issue of the Washington Monthly. Regretably, it's not online. But maybe someone with better Intertube skills than I can crack their confusing Web site. In the meantime, here's a
MORE
Meant to bump this last week, but be sure to check out America's spiffy new Web site. Rebuilding a site from the ground up isn't easy; they've done a heck of a job
MORE
In today's edition, Emily Brady briefly updates New York Times readers on the situation of Our Lady of Vilnius. Readers of dotCommonweal won't learn much from the piece, although it does contain one surprise: Joseph Zwilling, director of communications for the Archdiocese of New York explains the
MORE
Let's see, where was I? Right. The failures of the Bush administration. Arriving a tad late to the party, Peggy Noonan has issued a call to conservatives, even Republicans, to dump the president.
The beginning of my own sense of
separation from the Bush administration came in January 2005, when
MORE
Coming in the May 21 issue of America: Bishop Donald Trautman's strong--and I mean strong--critique of the new Mass translations. He singles out, for example, an Advent prayer over the gifts:
Accept, O Lord, these gifts,and by your power change theminto the sacrament of salvation,in which the
MORE
Who got the better of the debate? The Empire Zone, a New York Times blog, has the goods
MORE
Dan Mangan of the New York Post has the scoop. You've seen the term "lay trustee" bandied about in stories about Our Lady of Vilnius. What does it mean? In New York, parishes are separately incorporated, and each is governed by a set of five trustees: the bishop, usually his secretary,
MORE
In an earlier post, I summarized the latest developments in the case of Our Lady of Vilnius, a Lithuanian parish in Manhattan whose closure was questionably carried out by Cardinal Egan. As photographs have shown, not only have the pews, stained glass, altar, and icon been removed--for
MORE
We're delighted to announce another new addition to our stable of illustrious dotCommonweal contributors: David Gibson, author of The Rule of Benedict and The Coming Catholic Church. You've seen David popping up in the comment boxes of various threads (even when they concern his own work). So we
MORE
As you know, Bill Donohue tirelessly beats back anti-Catholicism wherever it may rear its ugly head. Look at his latest press release:
If the same standard that was applied to President George W. Bush were to be applied to Senator Barack Obama, then Obama must be considered a theocrat who shows no
MORE
There have been a few interesting developments in the story of Cardinal Egan's conduct in closing Our Lady of Vilnius, a Lithuanian parish in Manhattan. (For background, read my post on the subject and my piece in the March 23 Commonweal. And it can't hurt to read Michael Powell's recent profile
MORE
David Pogue, guru of all things technological at the New York Times, wrote a great post on the issue of codes of conduct in the blogosphere, including those who leave anonymous, not entirely courteous, comments.
The quality of the discussion at nytimes.com/pogue is very, very high, as a
number
MORE
A housekeeping question for those of you who subscribe to Commonweal via snail mail: when did you receive the April 6 issue (the one with the Easter eggs on the cover), and in what part of the country do you live? Thanks for your help
MORE
NCR's Joe Feuerherd reports on the issue of due process for priests who are accused of sexual abuse.
Four years ago, an adult woman informed her local diocese that a
recently ordained priest had groped her. No criminal or civil charges
were filed, but the initial investigation showed that the
MORE
Check out David Gibson's op-ed in Monday's New York Times, "His Own Pope Yet?":
Above all, in his pronouncements and writings, he carefully accentuated the positive. His first encyclical was titled “God Is Love,” and charity has become the recurring byword of his apparently irenic
MORE
Who's behind the postal rate hike that will punish smaller periodicals to the tune of 30-percent in rate increases, and reward larger publications with hikes of less than 10 percent? Click here to find out. (Hint: it rhymes with Wime Torner.) I've signed the petition at that site, and urge you to
MORE
You may have noticed the lead story on the home page, Mark Sargent's "Vengeance Time: When Abuse Victims Squander Their Moral Authority." We're already getting...somewhat heated letters about it--not that anyone is surprised. Mark gives voice to the concerns of many observers of the
MORE
As promised, here's a link to the lead editorial in our April 20 issue, "Bishops & Their Critics," which was mentioned in Peter Steinfels's "Beliefs" column in Saturday's New York Times. A sample:
President George W. Bush’s decision
to go to war with Iraq was initially
MORE
Peter Steinfels's "Beliefs" column on Saturday offered a preview of Commonweal's April 20 editorial, which will be available on our Web site this afternoon (I'll bump it here):
For over four years, George Weigel, staunch supporter of President Bush and biographer of Pope John
MORE
Jonathan Glater and Karen Arenson report:
In a fierce contest to control the student loan market, the nation’s banks and lenders have for years waged a successful campaign to limit a federal program that was intended to make borrowing less costly by having the government provide loans directly
MORE
John Allen's "The Real Ratzinger Revealed" is free on the Tablet's Web site. Were you expecting a "fundamentalist" pope? If so, how are you coping with having the expectation confounded?
If the danger of the John XXIII and Paul VI era was throwing the baby
out with the
MORE
I'm pleased to announce that Paul Lauritzen, director of the Program in Applied Ethics at John Carroll University, has agreed to join our esteemed roster of dotCommonweal contributors. You may recall Paul's most recent Commonweal article, "Holy Alliance? The Danger of Mixing Politics &
MORE
Just wanted to bump Andrew Bacevich's op-ed in today's L.A. Times, along with his Commonweal piece, currently the lead story on our homepage. (Cliff May responds at the Corner
MORE
DotCommonweal contributor Joe Komonchak sent me two photos of the spectacular San Clemente mosaic discussed here earlier this week, and asked me to post them. Without further ado, and just in time for Easter, here they are. And the detail: 
MORE
Just in time for Good Friday:
In a bankruptcy reorganization plan filed March 28, the San Diego
Diocese proposed a $95 million pool to compensate 143 people who claim
childhood sexual abuse by priests.
Under the proposal 83 victims who say they were forced to have
sexual intercourse could
MORE
Bill Cork has a post on the rumored universal indult for the Tridentine Mass that put me in mind of Cathy Kaveny's phrase describing those who are eager for the "restoration" but don't know Latin, or--as Bill points out--don't want to learn Latin
MORE
The March 24 edition of the Tablet of London contains reader responses to Robert Mickens's article on Jon Sobrino's "notification" by the CDF. The full letters pages are available only to subscribers, but here's an excerpt from the best of the bunch.
We used to have a complex system of
MORE
It's been a long time since I left a movie theater believing I had seen a great American film, but that's exactly what was buzzing around my head as I walked out of Zodiac, David Fincher's brilliant, obsessive recreation of the hunt for the serial killer who terrorized northern California in the
MORE
The following e-mail went out to the Ave Maria University community this afternoon:
To the Ave Maria University community: I have been asked to resign my position as provost and leave the campus immediately.
I will miss Ave Maria and the many of you whom I hold dear.Fr. Joseph Fessio, S.J.
MORE
Fr. Daniel McCormack will have his day in court after all. From the AP:
A May first hearing is scheduled for a Roman Catholic priest accused of sexually abusing several children in Chicago. Daniel
McCormack appeared in a Cook County courtroom today. And Judge Thomas
Sumner agreed to a
MORE
If you're in the Philadelphia area, you may want to drop in on this event tomorrow night.Update: By the way, please feel free to share your ideas about the subject of tomorrow's panel discussion. What intrigues you about the blogosphere--Catholic and otherwise? What worries you?Post-event update:
MORE
More proof that Stephen Colbert is the best TV interviewer working today
MORE
The story hasn't made much of a splash Stateside, but Fr. Jon Sobrino, SJ, a well-known liberation theologian, is the subject of a "notification" by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which takes issue with several aspects of his Christology. The Spanish newspaper El Mundo
MORE
From the Revealer, an interview with the director of a remarkable-sounding new film (I haven't seen it yet):
Tiny bottle of Chartreuse in hand, I emerged in mid-town a few weeks ago from
watching Into Great
Silence, my promised dinner date long-gone. The two-hour
documentary about a
MORE
Be sure to visit the home page and check out the new issue, which went live today--especially Peter Quinn's article, "The Gentle Darwinians: What Darwin's Champions Won't Mention." Col. Blimp or Lt. Columbo
MORE
Live from exhibit hall of the Los Angeles Religious Education Congress:A sixty-something woman just approached a Scott Foresman representative in the booth next to Commonweal's, and asked, "You don't have any adult videos, do you?" Maybe those critics are right, after all
MORE
You'll recall my previous posts (two links there) on Bishop Bruskewitz's decision to excommunicate members of about a dozen groups, including Call to Action and SSPX, en masse. CTA apparently appealed to the Signatura, which declined to rule on the issue. News reports have tended to treat this non-
MORE
Try to ignore the overheated evaluations of the Los Angeles Religious Education Congress that issue annually from some corners of the Catholic blogosphere. It's an impressive event. And this year, again, Commonweal will be there. If you're going to attend, why don't you stop by our booth to say
MORE
Cardinal Egan does himself no favors with this move.
Edward Cardinal Egan pulled a fast one on a lower Manhattan parish
pastor yesterday, summoning the priest to meet with him - then
dispatching security guards to permanently lock the cleric's church
doors.
The priest returned to Our Lady of
MORE
John Allen's recent Web column has occasioned some teeth-gnashing among those who want bishops to refuse Communion to prochoice Catholic politicians (see here, here, and here).But I wonder what such critics make of the fact that the former mayor of Rome, well known as a prochoice Catholic
MORE
Some highlights from the current issue of Commonweal, now available on the home page:
Our editorial on the new series of church financial scandals, which threatens to further erode the laity's trust in their bishops.
Mathew Schmalz's fascinating article on Audrey Santo, and the devotion that
MORE
Accusations abound in the Diocese of Cleveland.
Former Cleveland Catholic Bishop Anthony Pilla received
$177,000 in money and furniture over a decade from an
off-the-books church account set up to hide the
transactions, a former diocesan official said.
The accusation came in a 40-page
MORE
A former staffer for Joe Lieberman's 2006 campaign takes the lefty netroots folks to task for their tactics in the flap surrounding John Edwards's now-resigned bloggers. He points out the obvious--though apparently not obvious enough to Edwards and the blogging Left: Catholic voters matter.
One
MORE
BustedHalo recently published a favorable take on the play by a young woman religious. And Bill Cork doesn't see why it shouldn't serve as a jumping-off point for a discussion of moral theology. 
MORE
On Sunday, about twenty parishioners of Our Lady Queen of Angels began their vigil to protest the decision of the Archdiocese of New York to close the parish. (Read the New York Times story here.) The Times reports on its conclusion:
Six women were led away in handcuffs from an East Harlem
MORE
Commonweal is establishing a new
internship program that will provide promising young Catholic scholars, writers,
journalists and critics with real-world experience in opinion journalism as well
as stimulating opportunities to meet and work with potential mentors and
teachers in academia,
MORE
Amanda Marcotte has resigned.Update: Bill Donohue remains unsatisfied.Update 2: McEwan has also resigned
MORE
A few new developments on the Donohue vs. Edwards front. First, Commonweal columnist Melinda Henneberger picked up Eduardo's post below over at the Huffington Post. Second, the New York Times published a follow-up story, which made no mention of the offended who are not on the Right. Third and
MORE
From Vatican Information Service:
VATICAN CITY, FEB 7, 2007 (VIS) - Made public today was a declaration of the
Holy See delivered during the course of a world congress on the death penalty,
held in Paris, France from February 1 to 3.
"The Paris congress," reads
MORE
Some of you may recall my Religion News Service (RNS) piece criticizing the clergy-abuse documentary Deliver Us from Evil. Apparently it had no effect on the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, because they have nominated the film for an Oscar. Later this month, Deliver Us will have its
MORE
Two items, briefly: One, check out this map of the imperial history of the Middle East (give it time to load)--from the folks at Maps of War, who also ginned up a map of the history of religion. (HT, I'm told, goes to Martin Marty.)Two: Cathy Kaveny's long-awaited article, "Salvation & '
MORE
Play it, Chicago Symphony Orchestra.(Thanks for the opening, Eduardo
MORE
The PBS ombudsman has looked into the controversy surrounding a local affiliate's decision not to air the clergy-abuse documentary Hand of God at its scheduled time, even though the vast majority of other PBS station did. He published his findings earlier this week. (More on this in my posts here
MORE
Here is the must-read statement delivered by Zbigniew Brzezinski in today's Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing. It's long, I realize, but stick with it. Take it all in.
Your hearings come at a critical juncture in the U.S. war of choice
in Iraq, and I commend you and Senator Lugar for
MORE
Media Matters has posted a useful timeline of the events following a nasty piece of yellow journalism published by InsightMag.com--a "news" outfit owned by Sun Myung Moon's Unification Church--that claimed the Clinton camp "has discovered" that Barack Obama attended a madrassa
MORE
I meant to blog this a few weeks ago, but never got around to it. On my flight to San Diego for the Catholic Campus Ministry Association conference earlier this month, I was treated to a rare flying pleasure: a good in-flight movie--The Queen, which is up for Best Picture. The PG-13-rated film
MORE
The latest issue of New York magazine contains David Gibson's revealing, well-reported article on the state of the Archdiocese of New York, its priests, and its archbishop. Those of you keeping tabs on ArchNY may recall the controversy surrounding an anonymous letter that was quite critical of
MORE
In case you missed it, worth your while (including the definitive revelation of the nature of his hair
MORE
Lots more happening in the dustup over the decision of a Catholic-diocese-owned PBS affiliate not to air the clergy abuse documentary Hand of God on January 16 at its scheduled time, as did most other PBS stations.* Published TV listings and the station's own Web site listed the program as
MORE
As Andrew Sullivan has noted, Senator Patrick Leahy (D.-Vermont) has had quite enough of Attorney General Gonzales's dismissive answers in Senate Judiciary Committee hearings on detainee policy. Here's the video from the CBC (CNN's account curiously edited some of the better moments). Andrew also
MORE
If you live in the Rio Grande Valley, that is. The local PBS affiliate there decided not to show the Hand of God episode of Frontline on Tuesday night, although it was broadcast on most other PBS stations around the country.* Instead, KMBH-TV ran last week's episode of Frontline, which focused on
MORE
Commonweal columnist and Huffington Post contributor Melinda Henneberger reports on former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright's testimony before the House Foreign Relations Committee.
One of the sharpest exchanges of the day was between Albright and a
fellow Democrat. Responding to her
MORE
If you missed Frontline last night, you can now watch the documentary Hand of God in its entirety on the robust Web site PBS set up for the film. It's helpfully broken up into ten segments, so if you aren't conditioned for 90-minute sessions in front of your computer, you can watch it in parts.&
MORE
Are you having trouble leaving comments on the blog? Experiencing other Web-site-related weirdness? If you can manage to leave a comment on this post, please explain in detail the technical difficulties you're having. It will be helpful to know what operating system you use (Windows 98, XP, or Mac
MORE
Tuesday night, PBS will air a Frontline documentary, Hand of God (9 p.m. Eastern, but check local listings, or watch online). I watched a screener on the flight home for the holidays--nothing says Christmas like a sexual-abuse documentary--and intended to blog on it much sooner, but the holiday
MORE
Commonweal contributor David Gibson has an op-ed in the Newark Star-Ledger on the Catholic topic du jour:
Throughout its history, Poland has been fiercely Roman Catholic, rallying to the faith even as the nation was regularly overrun by invaders, to the point that Poland was known in Rome as the
MORE
The New York Times has published the first in a long-awaited (at least by me), major series of articles by David Gonzalez on a Pentecostal church in Harlem, and "los aleluyas" who run it. (You should also check out the interactive feature
MORE
[Update: The good folks at America have decided to make Bishop Curry's article and the letters responding to it free. Christmas in January!]
Last month I noted an unwieldy and finally disappointing article by Bishop Thomas J. Curry in the November 20 edition of America, "The Best and Worst
MORE
Der Spiegel on the Polish question. Anne Applebaum on l'affaire Wielgus. (H/T to dotCom reader Jimmy Mac.) And Sandro Magister lays out the case. (H/T Amy Welborn.)And, of course, check out the Piotr Mazurkiewicz piece from the current issue of Commonweal, "The Polish Paradox," written
MORE
Lots of commentary on the address already. Are his premises wrong? Are the Iraqi government and military up to the task? Has Joe Lieberman decamped from the reality-based community? If the Democrats reject the "surge," can they stop it? What about the Republicans? What happens in '08?
MORE
It's come to our attention that many users are having a hard time moving their accounts over to the new system, and it isn't hard to see why. Here's the deal:If you are a print subscriber and want to receive full access to our archive online, you need to login and click the My Account link near
MORE
Effective this weekend, Commonweal is introducing some changes at its Web site. Probably the most significant change is that while stories from each current issue of the magazine remain available for free, almost all stories prior to the current issue, and our extensive searchable archive of past
MORE
What happened at Gitmo (WaPo, free registration req'd)?
FBI agents witnessed possible mistreatment of the Koran at the military
prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, including at least one instance in
which an interrogator squatted over Islam's holy text in an apparent
attempt to offend a captive
MORE
As I promised in an earlier post, I did some digging to find out the canonical significance of Bishop Bruskewitz's 1996 decision to excommunicate members of Call to Action (and several other groups) in his diocese, along with its recent affirmation by Cardinal Re, prefect of the Congregation for
MORE
For those of you who missed this important announcement before last night's broadcast of Monday Night Football
MORE
Quick, somebody give our lawmakers a crash course in computer technology. From the same part of the legislative brain that brought you computer voting machines comes a proposed law to have sex offenders register their e-mail addresses and instant-message screen names.
Here's how the plan would
MORE
From the University of Notre Dame newswire:
The Notre Dame Task Force on Catholic Education—a national group of Catholic educators, administrators, diocesan representatives, philanthropists, and investment specialists—has released a report on the challenges and opportunities confronting
MORE
On March 19, 1996, Bishop Fabian Bruskewitz of the Diocese of Lincoln, Nebraska, issued a warning to Catholic members of a dozen groups to sever ties with the organizations by April 15, 1996, or face excommunication within his diocese. One of the groups, Call to Action, appealed to the Vatican.
MORE
Lorne Michaels, I think you just found your next stars
MORE
From "The Best and Worst of Times," by Bishop Thomas J. Curry, an auxiliary of the Archdiocese of Los Angeles, in the November 20 issue of America:
In
parish life, I find little evidence of the supposedly polarized church.
The pastoral conflicts that occupy me center on personnel,
MORE
From the Chicago Tribune:
A Sister of Mercy who taught in Chicago-area Catholic schools for more
than three decades has been indicted in Wisconsin over allegations that
she abused pupils at a Milwaukee school nearly 40 years ago.
Sister Norma Giannini is accused of having sexual intercourse
MORE
When Bishop Michael Saltarelli of Wilmington, Delaware, released the names of twenty priests or former priests of his diocese who had been credibly accused of sexual abuse, I wonder if he imagined the following scenario as a possible consequence.
Members of two groups representing victims of
MORE
A dotCommonweal reader with great taste (redundant, I realize) recommended Sufjan Stevens's new collection, Songs for Christmas, in John McGreevy's Sufjan post a couple of weeks ago. (The article he links to in Books and Culture is, I think, way off the mark.)I was able to snag a promotional copy
MORE
Rocco Palmo, who writes the blog Whispers in the Loggia, noted two recent pieces in Commonweal on the subject of the future of the priesthood in the United States, our editorial and Paul Stanosz's Continuing the Conversation article. (The Stanosz is available to registered users only. If you haven'
MORE
There have been some developments in the sexual-abuse scandal in the Archdiocese of Los Angeles. Here are a few stories on the happy subject.First, a summary Q&A on the L.A. story.Second, the $60 million settlement. Third, what about criminal charges against the archdiocese
MORE
Richard Dawkins, Oxford professor of science and bestselling author of books of militant atheism, has not received the warmest of welcomes in the media for his latest effort to persuade you that religion is nonsensical, The God Delusion. The New York Times didn't recommend it. Neither did the
MORE
Ian Fisher and Sabrina Tavernise report:
Turkey’s prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, told reporters after a brief meeting with Benedict at the airport here that he had asked the pope to support Turkey in its attempt to become a member of the European Union.“He said, ‘You know we don’t
MORE
He'd been quiet for a while, but recently Ur-Diogenes over at Off the Record, the blog of Catholic World News, has gotten back on the horse. (We've discussed him before here and here.) Seemingly brought out of hibernation by the midterm elections (Ur-Diogenes is nothing if not deeply interested in
MORE
No, not Michael Richards's racist rant. I'm talking about the main hed on the front page of today's New York Post. No doubt the headline and sports writers at the Post are giving voice to the resentment Yankee fans feel after seeing their veteran shortstop Derek Jeter edged out of the MVP award by
MORE
P.R./Newswire reports:
Double Murder in Wisconsin Prompts Lawsuit Against All US Bishops
But Delaware's Top Church Official Will Be Removed As Defendant
Saltarelli's Disclosure of Names of Alleged Predator Priests is the ReasonA family whose relative was
murdered by a priest and who has filed
MORE
Commonweal editor Paul Baumann is on today's Brian Lehrer Show on WNYC, which is streaming live right here (links on the left side of the page) right now. As I understand it, they'll be discussing the bishops' meeting
MORE
Press releases and approved statements from the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops meeting are available here. 
MORE
You'll notice our roster of contributors just got longer. We'd like to welcome the latest additions to the dotCommonweal crowd: Lawrence S. Cunningham, James T. Fisher, Michael W. Higgins, Eduardo Peñalver, Jean Raber, and Barbara Dafoe Whitehead. Who are these people? Some are familar to
MORE
From TNR Online:
Americans who attend religious services on a weekly basis voted 51 percent for
Republican candidates and 48 percent for Democrats, a statistically meaningless
difference. Nationally, Democrats made modest gains among two important groups
of religious voters--they matched
MORE
How did it go yesterday? CIAFTCG has preliminary results. (H/T Daily Dish
MORE
And you should give it a look straightaway. (Don't worry, it's much cheaper than the print magazine: free.) 
MORE
Too many polling-place reports to keep track of, but here are a few worth reading.
To be a Latino voter in Arizona...
Or any kind of voter in Maryland...
Or in Virgina... (audio bonus)
Or an Ohio Congressman
MORE
My take on the new documentary on clergy sexual abuse.Update: Apparently, you need to login. You can use the following to gain access:
username: noone@kansascity.compassword:123456Update 2: I'm getting some reports that the link isn't working right. Here is it in full and live, if you have to copy
MORE
Ted Haggard gave the keynote at the Religion Newswriters Association conference in September. He opened the talk by discussing his early interest in journalism. (Audio can be found here. The following transcriptions are mine.)"I was excited about telling the truth, and helping people to be
MORE
Last week, Cardinal Francis George of Chicago delivered a homily at the Catholic Theological Union in which he candidly explained why he thinks the world casts a suspicious eye on the United States. Cathleen Falsani reports:
"The world distrusts us not because we are rich and free. Many of us
MORE
The New York Times reports.And from the BBC story:
As the judge began reading the death sentence Saddam
Hussein shouted out "Allahu Akbar!" (God is Great) and "Long live Iraq!
Long live the Iraqi people! Down with the traitors!"The former leader looked shocked and furious
MORE
Bill McGarvey, editor of BustedHalo, interviews blogger-in-chief Andrew Sullivan. Within moments of its posting, Catholic World "News" blogger Diogenes offered his (their?) predictable response
MORE
The San Diego Civic Theater is home to the Pulitzer Prize-winning, Tony-winning play by John Patrick Shanley for just four days, so act fast. Here's Welton Jones's review of the production, which includes two of the original cast members, the fantastic Cherry Jones and Adriane Lenox. And here's my
MORE
Citing the women-priests' planned eucharistic celebration at the Call to Action (CTA) conference this weekend, the officers of Voice of the Faithful (VOTF) have decided to withdraw the from the meeting. Here's the full text of the letter from VOTF President Mary Pat Fox explaining the withdrawal
MORE
We've been hacked! Sort of. The home page wasn't updated yesterday because someone or something dropped malicious code into our user database, which crippled our ability to post new content. After many unhappy hours of digging for the problem, I now support abrogating habeas corpus. Hackers, we're
MORE
Are you in Chicago or in the Chicagoland area? Free Tuesday night around, say, 7? Yes, I realize game three of the World Series is on. But unless you're a displaced Tigers fan, or encamped in some secret Redbird-fan enclave, you don't really have a dog in that fight. So, what do you say? Come on
MORE
According to plaintiffs' attorney Lynne Cadigan in Tuscon, yes.
“We were very skeptical and we initially thought the bankruptcy was
just one more way to scam the victims,” she said. “Financially and
emotionally it was a good tool to heal the (victims). I don’t like
admitting that, but
MORE
For those of you who missed the home-page update, be sure to read Commonweal columnist Melinda Henneberger's review of Damon Linker's controversial book. Turns out she wasn't too impressed. Here's the lede:
The Theocons, Damon Linker’s new book about his former boss, First Things editor Fr.
MORE
The Washington Post reports:
A team of American and Iraqi epidemiologists estimates that 655,000 more people have died in Iraq since coalition forces arrived in March 2003 than would have died if the invasion had not occurred.(snip)Of the total 655,000 estimated "excess deaths," 601,
MORE
And now for something completely different. Which is to say hugely geeky. I'm here to discuss the best television show not on HBO: the Sci-Fi Channel's Battlestar Galactica, whose third-season premiere aired Friday night. (The best show on TV including HBO is--sorry, Sopranos fans--Deadwood.) No
MORE
As usual, Catholic League President Bill Donohue has it all figured out. In his press release on disgraced Republican Rep. Mark Foley, he has some "tough questions" for the congressman. Such as, why did he let himself be molested by a member of the clergy when he was between 13 and 15
MORE
University of Chicago historian David Nirenberg dissects the pope's Regensburg lecture at the New Republic. A sample:
Benedict's plea for Hellenization draws on a German philosophical tradition--stretching from Hegel's The Spirit of Christianity
through Weber's sociology of religions to the post
MORE
In August, Bishop Thomas G. Doran of Rockford, Illinois, wrote a column in which he announced that the "seven 'sacraments' of [the Democrats'] secular culture are" -- in alphabetical order -- "abortion, buggery, contraception, divorce, euthanasia, feminism of the radical type, and
MORE
If you haven't yet, check out our Web-only interview with Daniel Madigan, SJ, president of the Institute for the Study of Religions and Cultures at the Pontifical Gregorian University in Rome, on Benedict XVI's controversial address at Regensburg
MORE
I've heard of The Tao of Pooh and The Te of Piglet, but "The 9/11 of Pope Benedict XVI"? I'll let Deal Hudson, of the Morley Institute for Chuch and Culture, explain:
Ever since he emerged smiling through the doors of St. Peter’s, as the Cardinals’ choice to lead the Church,
MORE
Yes, they've reached an accord on the interrogation bill, they say (the president's 90-second commentary is viewable in this story). But what kind? What is the nature of the agreement? Why are McCain, Graham, and Warner now satisfied? Details remain scarce.Update: The text of the "compromise&
MORE
DotCommonwealer and Notre Dame historian John McGreevy has generously offered to answer reader questions on his latest article here on Monday, September 25. So get reading, and keep your eyes peeled for John's Q&A post. N.B.: Only registered users of the Commonweal Web site are able to post
MORE
President Bush: "The bottom line is simple: if Congress passes a law that does not clarify the rules, if they do not do that, the [interrogation] program is not going forward."The question David Gregory asked in response, which the president ignored, was, "And it will not endanger U.
MORE
Sojourners editor Jim Wallis has launched, in collaboration with Beliefnet, a new group blog, God's Politics, named after his most book, which recently came out in paperback. Among their writers are sometime Commonweal contributor Amy Sullivan and Sr. Helen Prejean. First up, a weeklong exchange
MORE
Click here for the live stream of his Catholic University speech (ends at 4:30 p.m. Eastern), much maligned by Cardinal Newman Society president Patrick Reilly at National Review Online (shocker) . 
MORE
Catholic University sociologist Dean Hoge has just released his new study of recently ordained priests--the first since 1990--and the findings are telling.
Since 1990, the average age of priests ordained five to nine years has increased from 34.1 years to 42.6 for diocesan priests, and from
MORE
The New Republic's new blog, Open University, which is written by approximately seven thousand academics, has taken note of Paul Baumann's Washington Monthly review of Damon Linker's The Theocons, which I mentioned earlier this week.
Columbia University historian Casey N. Blake recommends the
MORE
Senator Rick Santorum (R-PA) has had it with the politicization of 9/11 and the "war on terror."
We're at war
against an enemy that I happen to believe is the most dangerous enemy
ever to confront this country. We play petty politics constantly here
on the floor of the Senate, even
MORE
Matt Lauer asks President Bush about his interrogation policy (hat tip, Andrew Sullivan
MORE
Is Damon Linker's The Theocons: Secular America Under Seige the slam-dunk some made it out to be? Not quite. Commonweal editor Paul Baumann explains in the most recent issue of the Washington Monthly
MORE
Where to go for the latest poll-data crunching as the midterm elections approach: electoral-vote.com
MORE
Several people have commented on what's really behind President Bush's decision to grant 14 "war on terror" prisoners POW status, and what it means for U.S. policy on torture. Here's a roundup:
The Plank (and here, previously linked to)
Balkinization (several posts there worth reading
MORE
The National Catholic Reporter profiles sometime contributor to Commonweal, and my friend, Bill McGarvey--musician, editor, young Catholic. Be sure to check out the free--and legal!--song downloads
MORE
Jonathan Karl at ABC News reports:
ABC News has learned that President Bush will
announce that high-value detainees now being held at secret CIA prisons
will be transferred to the Department of Defense and granted
protections under the 1949 Geneva Conventions. It will be the first
time the
MORE
As reported by the Washington Times on August 26 (and the WaPost on August 27), Georgetown's Protestant chaplaincy has ordered six evangelical Protestant groups not affiliated with the university to cease their ministry activities and presence on campus. (They aren't going without a fight.)
The
MORE
First Things blogger R. R. Reno, associate professor of theology at Creighton University (PhD Yale), has compiled his own rankings of the best theology programs in the country. His list in part:
5. The Catholic University of America, Princeton Theological Seminary, and Trinity Evangelical
MORE
Thursday's NewsHour included an energetic exchange between Dr. Robert Lanza, leader of the research team behind the controversial new procedure, and Richard Doerflinger, of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. A snippet:
RAY SUAREZ: Well, Richard Doerflinger, Dr. Lanza's group
has maintained
MORE
CJR Daily, Columbia Journalism Review's excellent blog, points to some criticisms of Malcolm Gladwell's New Yorker piece on pensions, mentioned by John yesterday. To refresh your memory, we turn to Paul McLeary's helpful summary:
Gladwell notes in his story that General Motors currently finds
MORE
The Plank points out the breathless descriptions of a Power Line contributor who recently met with President George W. Bush:
I had the opportunity this afternoon to be part of a relatively small
group who heard President Bush talk, extemporaneously, for around forty
minutes. It was an absolutely
MORE
From the 2006 Official Catholic Directory, page A-13
MORE
The Chicago Sun-Times published a very strange story about a twenty-six-year-old's charge that he was sexually abused by one priest in the presence of his pastor.
[John] Doe said the priests invited him for beers on Saturday night, Aug. 5.
"They kept telling me, 'Here, have another beer
MORE
The Chicago Tribune reports: "Elvira Arellano, who became a national spokeswoman for families facing
deportation, had been ordered to report to the Department of Homeland
Security by 9 a.m. Tuesday." She went to church instead. And says she isn't leaving
MORE
Joseph Bottum, editor of First Things, rightfully takes issue with some statements that appeared in the comments boxes of our threads on Charlotte Allen's critique of Commonweal. After quoting some of the more outlandish comments--left by readers of the blog, not by its contributors--Bottum writes
MORE
"If we just pick up like Ned Lamont wants us to do, get out by a date
certain, it will be taken as a tremendous victory by the same people
who wanted to blow up these planes in this plot hatched in England. It
will strengthen them and they will strike again."
--Joe Lieberman
MORE
The Diocese of Springfield, Illinois, has released a brief report (warning: PDF) from the Special Panel on Clergy Misconduct, convened by Bishop George Lucas to review the results of an investigation into allegations against priests in the diocese. (The investigation was limited to charges
MORE
Here's a sure-fire test, as offered by Stephen H. Webb, professor of religion and philosophy at Wabash College, courtesy of the new First Things blog:
You know you are a liberal if you think that the poor need money more than they need moral discipline
MORE
Another former priest and seminarian with the Legionaries of Christ has come forward with allegations against Fr. Marcial Maciel, the suspended founder of the Legionaries. Brian Mershon has the story, and the letter alleging the abuse. Mershon also notes that Jim Fair, U.S. spokesman for the
MORE
They have lists, those e-mail spammers, and after finding this link in my morning mail, I fear they may have me pegged. (Google shortcut for "Christian lending network" right here
MORE
Ur-Diogenes is back from vacation. Today he posts on a dustup regarding the happy subject of divorced Catholics and Communion. Fr. Alberto Bonandi, Ur-Diogenes summarizes, "has proposed that divorced and remarried Catholics can be admitted to Communion even if they are not 'living as brother
MORE
A journalist, that is. Columbia Journalism School dean Nicholas Lemann has a few choice words for self-aggrandizing bloggers. This ought to send them into a fugue state.One of the more amusing examples of bloggish journalism Lemann offers is an "interview" with New York Times tech
MORE
Hackers are just too smart--not that they'd need to be, when voting machines like this are being built. 
MORE
The Denver Catholic Register, newspaper of the Archdiocese of Denver, led by Archbishop Charles Chaput, published a George Weigel column aimed squarely at Cardinal Theodore McCarrick, archbishop emeritus of Washington, D.C. (The Register distributes Weigel's column to more than sixty U.S. Catholic
MORE
The Colbert Report Web site has broken the interview into two parts here. Honestly, I was hoping for something more on par with what he did with Peggy Noonan, but Donohue was obviously a very good sport. He even brandished a ruler to remind Colbert of their shared Catholic upbringing.Update: here's
MORE
Cardinal Francis George of Chicago will undergo surgery tomorrow for cancer of the bladder. If there's good news in this, it's that doctors believe the cancer hasn't spread to other parts of his body. 
MORE
Anticipating the ritual flaying of the electoral college two-plus years in advance of the presidental election, a Stanford computer-science professor has an idea to revamp the oft-maligned system:
[John] Koza's scheme calls for an interstate compact that would require states to
throw all of
MORE
Mirror of Justice contributor Thomas Berg has an excellent post on what Catholic social teaching may have to say about growing economic inequality. 1. "Great disparity seems likely to make it harder for people to practice
the value of solidarity, that is, 'see[ing] the "other"--
MORE
For those of you who haven't seen George Will's latest slam dunk, here are some of the more exciting bits from his evisceration of the Bill Kristol's absurd call for war with Iran--now. From Will's column (the quotes are from Kristol):
"We might consider countering this act of Iranian
MORE
Those who find U.S. treatment of prisoners in the "war on terror" morally repugnant and strategically daft had their spirits lifted on Tuesday, when the White House announced that terrorist suspects would enjoy the protections of the Geneva Conventions, bringing their policy in line with
MORE
As Tim Reidy pointed out a few weeks ago, I'm a big fan of Sufjan (pronounced SOOF-YAHN) Stevens. (See my review of his album Seven Swans.) The overtly religious themes of that record made it an obvious subject for a Commonweal review.Less obvious Commonweal fodder, though, was his follow-up album
MORE
The July 1 Tablet of London--their Independence Day issue, natch--has a great piece by David Gibson on Tom Monaghan's Ave Maria Town. The crux of it:
But the paradox of Monaghan's plan to build a bastion of orthodoxy is
that his impulse is in reality more American than it is Catholic. Since
MORE
Very good news (AP). Here's the WaPost story.As is now becoming clear, the Court's ruling that Common Article 3 of the Geneva Conventions applies to the detainee Hamdan has major implications for the mistreatment of prisoners at Gitmo and elsewhere. Common Article 3 requires that prisoners of war
MORE
Anne Lamott had a provocative op-ed in Monday's L.A. Times on her participation in an assisted suicide. It certainly gets the wheels turning, and I have some thoughts about this powerful piece. I hope I can put them together later, but in the meantime, have a look. (Hat tip: Amy Welborn
MORE
What's the point of "social networking" sites? I mean really. 
MORE
Several people in the comboxes to Tim's post on Roe below expressed their appreciation for the link to Mark Sargent's paper, "The Importance and Coherence of a Prolife Progressivism." So I thought I should post it here (warning: PDF) for those who weren't following the Roe thread
MORE
How the U.S. government explains its opposition to legal review of its domestic surveillance program.UpdateMore on this from Wired News
MORE
Catholic World News's pseudonymous scribe Diogenes has kept his eagle eye on the liturgical-translation debates for some time now. Little escapes his gaze--not even what he perceives as the grammatical mistakes of those who dare to speak on the subject.Exhibit A: Diogenes (in this case ur-Diogenes
MORE
The National Catholic Reporter's June 16 editorial, "Spin without End in Abuse Scandal," takes issue with the Catholic League's ad on the June 7 New York Times op-ed page. NCR writes:
The clergy sex abuse crisis -- some would have us believe -- is largely about priests taking advantage
MORE
The bishops are meeting later this week to vote on the new translation of the Order of Mass. Many thanks to Rocco Palmo of Whispers in the Loggia, who bumped two articles we ran on the liturgical translation debates last year: John Wilkins's "Lost in Translation" and Kevin Eckstrom's &
MORE
The Chicago Tribune profiles archdiocesan chancellor Jimmy Lago.You can read the independent audits commissioned by the archdiocese by clicking here
MORE
Psst. The last issue of Commonweal's regular publishing schedule before our summer slowdown (one issue in July and one in August) just went live. Be sure to check out William Pfaff's article, "Clash of Cultures," and the many other must-reads over on the home page. Then come back here and
MORE
Here's a sneak preview of our June 16 editorial. A sample:
Ostensibly designed to draw attention to the church’s Jewish origins,
and to embrace the two faiths’ shared love for God, Benedict’s remarks
may have the opposite effect. It seems unlikely that many Jews will
take consolation
MORE
I'll try to comment on these later, but be sure to read Commonweal contributor Charles R. Morris on "Freakoutonomics" and Opus Dei numerary Paul Fortunato on "Opus Dei's Box-Office Triumph." Comments are open
MORE
Remember when Homeland Security officials promised a new grant-steering system would be put in place to ensure those areas most likely to be targeted by terrorists would receive the lion's share of anti-terrorism funding? Well, that didn't work out so well:
The net effect was that the grant to New
MORE
The latest issue of Commonweal just went up online. Apropos of the must-read thread on Gnosticism below, here's a snippet from Jack Miles's piece on Gnosticism and the Gospel of Judas--now the lead story on our home page.
The recently published Gospel of Judas, writes biblical scholar
MORE
New York Review of Books critics say no. In their review of The Gospel of Judas from Codex Tchacos (National Geographic), Eduard Iricinschi, Lance Jenott, and Philippa Townsend--all Princeton doctoral candidates studying religions of late antiquity--argue:
Scholars have commonly approached such
MORE
Catholic World News published a leaked letter from Cardinal Arinze to USCCB President William Skylstad, the content of which ur-Diogenes summarized as "sorry, not buying it." Arinze, head of the Congregation for Divine Worship, was following up on a meeting in which, it's surmised,
MORE
This morning, James Martin, SJ, appeared on CNN to discuss the abiding relevance of Gaudiem et—wait, no. It was to talk about The Da Vinci Code. There's some great stuff in the interview. Here's my rough transcription:
Martin: As a moviegoer I found it really tedious and really long, and as a
MORE
Did you know that the late novelist Muriel Spark had just completed a novel before she died? The editors of Commonweal have the scoop. 
MORE
Here it is, in toto, from the Vatican Information Service:
COMMUNIQUE CONCERNING FOUNDER OF LEGIONARIES OF CHRIST VATICAN CITY, MAY 19, 2006 (VIS) - With reference to recent news concerning the person of Fr. Marcial Maciel Degollado, founder of the Legionaries of Christ, the Holy See Press
MORE
We haven't yet set down a formal terms-of-service agreement for users of dotCommonweal, so let me try to sketch what's expected of those who comment on our posts.
1. No cursing or lewdness of any kind. If you don't think the vocabulary you're using would appear in Commonweal magazine, then try
MORE
John Allen reports:
Capping a decade-long on-again, off-again investigation of accusations of sexual abuse, the Vatican has asked Fr. Marcial Maciel Degollado, the founder of the Legionaries of Christ, to observe a series of restrictions on his ministry. In effect, Vatican sources told NCR this
MORE
Ladies and gentlemen, please direct your attention to this article in New York magazine (May 22), called:
On the Rabbi's KneeDo the Orthodox Jews have a Catholic-priest problem?Can you guess what the problem is? That's right. The sexual abuse of children. It's bad enough that this headline appears
MORE
It's become difficult to muster surprise at the bad behavior of the NSA these days, but the first question that occured to me after learning the government is assembling a database of millions of Americans' phone calls was: how long before Seymour Hersh's sources are identified? Even as I
MORE
Has the mysterious ur-Diogenes awakened from his slumber? As I noted in a previous post, Philip Lawler, the editor of Catholic World News, which hosts the subtle and charitable musings of the pseudonymous blogger Diogenes, informed me that "more than one contributor" writes under the name
MORE
Or at least "more than one." That's how Catholic World News (CWN) editor Philip F. Lawler described the identity of CWN's Off the Record scribe "Diogenes."
After several dotCommonweal readers chimed in with theories about the true identity of Diogenes, I sent Lawler a note
MORE
The next chapter in the immigration saga
MORE
That settles it. The flap at BC over honoring Condi Rice as commencement speaker has now entered the immortal realm of the Rorschach Test. Jonah Goldberg has issued a column on the controversy. His opening salvo:
How is academic freedom like Catholicism? Well, if you are a left-wing academic, the
MORE
Now that dotCommonweal has been humming along for couple months, we’ve had time to get our bearings in the wider blogosphere—Catholic and otherwise. There’s a lot going on out there. You’ve seen links to Amy Welborn’s blog, Rocco Palmo’s, Andrew Sullivan’s, Josh Marshall’s, Mirror
MORE
Together at last. A minor dustup followed the announcement (free registration required) that this year's Boston College commencement speaker would be Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice. This entails bestowing the customary honorary degree, something several B.C. professors object to for her role
MORE
The United States spends an average of $5,200 in health-care per person. So why do we rank twenty-fifth in life expectancy, as a surprising new study shows?
Americans had higher rates of diabetes, heart disease, strokes, lung disease and cancer — findings that held true no matter what income or
MORE
Dan Froomkin dishes up everything you wanted to know about Stephen Colbert's reception at the White House Correspondent Dinner. And then some:
Once upon a time, I imagine, there was great value in throwing a party where journalists and politicians could mingle and shmooze and celebrate the
MORE
As you may have noticed, the main site is borderline nonresponsive. We're experiencing--how to put this kindly--server issues. So if you're having trouble logging in, give it a few hours. In the meantime, here are direct links to some of the latest articles.
Are Illegal Immigrants Pioneers? (by
MORE
The L.A. Times reports that Medicare is in frighteningly bad shape. Again.
The huge Medicare fund for inpatient hospital care will not be able to cover the full amount of billings beginning in 2018, two years earlier than estimated last year. The Medicare fund has been in dire straits before
MORE
President Bush seemed relatively amused for the first fifteen minutes of Stephen Colbert's routine at Saturday night's White House Correspondent Dinner. Or at least he looked like he was trying to appear amused. Which couldn't have been easy, considering that Colbert, in full Fox News
MORE
Lee Siegel's post on the film United 93 over at TNR.com is sort of amazing. He calls out his "posturing scrivening peers" for their bogus emoting over the heroics of Flight 93 passengers. (Whether a writer who uses terms like "scrivening peers" can legitimately level the
MORE
"Given enough time, some disputes do get clarified," Fr. Richard John Neuhaus writes in the May issue of First Things (regrettably, the "Public Square" is not available online). He is referring, of course, to the discussion of Tom Reese's May 2005 departure from America magazine
MORE
The Opus Dei charm offensive has worked wonders for the organization. If David Van Biema's cover story in Time has a thesis statement, it's this: "Opus Dei--not as bad as you thought." This, it seems, is the line taken by many recent investigations of the group, such as John Allen's
MORE
Rocco Palmo points out this BBC story, which reports that Cardinal Carlo Maria Martini, one-time papabile, told L'Espresso that "in couples where one had HIV/AIDS, which could pass to the partner, the use of condoms was 'a lesser evil.'" For more on the subject, see the cover story in the
MORE
The Los Angeles Times tracks some troubling omissions from Cardinal Mahony's 2004 "Report to the People of God."
MORE
There's an interesting exchange over at Mirror of Justice that was prompted by a post from Eduardo Moises Penalver (apologies for not knowing how to add appropriate diacritical marks) regarding the credibility of Catholic scholarship vis-a-vis magisterial authority. Here's a snippet of the
MORE
I'm sure that somewhere buried deep in the dotCommonweal bylaws is a rule barring what I'm about to do, but I'm going to do it anyway. Which is to post on baseball. (Click the play button in the center of the image to make the magic happen.)
What you're witnessing is a selection of home
MORE
As I exited the controlled climate of the L.A. Religious Education
Congress exhibit hall to enter the crisp Anaheim air, I looked up.
After two days of intermittent rain and overcast skies, the clouds were
gone--welcome relief. Palm tree tops against blue sky. California. As
my gaze returned to
MORE
Here's a snippet from Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams's wide-ranging, and even topical, Easter sermon:
Beyond all the history of confusion and betrayal that surrounds a lot of the Church’s history, beyond the power games that we still play in the churches, this one rocklike conviction
MORE
Commonweal just launched a speakers program. The inaugural event took place last weekend at St. John's Student Parish at Michigan State University, where Luke Timothy Johnson spoke on "The Da Vinci Code, the Culture Wars and the New Gnosticism." With impressive swiftness, the techies at
MORE
President Bush answers a grad student's question about the controlling legal authority over private military contractors in Iraq (click the play button in the center of the image): It's astonishing that at this late date, the president seems (or wants to seem) that he's never entertained the
MORE
In a surprising move, the Cardinal Newman Society has responded with great dismay to Notre Dame president John Jenkins's decision not to put the kibosh on Vagina Monologues performances. As with most of CNS's output, the statement is a touch overheated:
Fr. Jenkins has now given
MORE
John Jenkins, CSJ, speaks:
Thanks to the efforts of some
faculty members, this year's performance of The Vagina Monologues
was brought into dialogue with Catholic tradition through panels that followed
each performance. Panelists presented the Catholic teaching on human sexuality,
and students
MORE
Is there anything worse than "liveblogging"? Well, here I go, anyway--from the L.A. Religious Education Congress (that hotbed of liberal loopiness). Just got out of a talk by Timothy Radcliffe, OP, former master of the Dominicans, on the important issue of healing divisions within the
MORE
Bishop Fabien Bruskewitz of Lincoln, Nebraska--who has steadfastly refused to cooperate with the National Review Board's annual audits since they began--has a few choice words for the chairwoman of the NRB. As reported in Catholic World News, he released the following statement in response to the
MORE
The third annual national audit results will be released tomorrow at noon (Eastern) on the USCCB Web site. Two other reports will be issued:
Also to be released as part of the Charter implementation report is the annual survey by the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate (CARA), Georgetown
MORE
Are you planning on joining the cast of thousands at the Los Angeles Religious Education Congress this year (March 30-April 2)? We are. If so, stop by booth 688 and say hello to Commonweal people Paul Baumann, Tom Baker, and me. Free magazines for those who say they heard about the booth on
MORE
As anticipated, the Senate Judiciary Committee approved a more moderate version of HR 4437, the controversial immigration bill that had Cardinal Mahony threatening civil disobedience. The committee adopted an ammendment offered by Senator Dick Durbin (D-IL) that would shelter churches and other
MORE
Last week, Peggy Steinfels posted on John Allen's interview with Peter-Hans Kolvenbach, the superior general of the Society of Jesus, culling from the brief, but fascinating exchange the question, What's a magazine for? In reading Kolvenbach's response to a question about Tom Reese's departure
MORE
Damon Linker reviews Neuhaus's new book, Catholic Matters:
Several Catholic writers have contributed
to fashioning a potent governing philosophy for traditionalist
Christians, but the one who has exercised the greatest influence on the
ideological agenda of the religious right is Richard John
MORE
Amy Welborn asks whether we're really having an honest debate about HR 4437. The National Review, as I noted below, thinks Cardinal Mahony's staunch opposition to the bill is much ado about nothing. It's been suggested that the bill doesn't really say what the cardinal says it does. From my post
MORE
According to the editors of the National Review:
The American Catholic bishops are waging an intense, sophisticated campaign to promote their version of immigration reform, which happens also to be big business's version of immigration reform. The campaign comes complete with brochures, a well-
MORE
Andrew Sullivan posts on a disturbing poll indicating that U.S. Christians generally favor torturing suspected terrorists. Catholics, it turns out, are most hospitible to the idea:
Twenty-one percent of Catholics surveyed said it is “often” justified and 35
MORE
Look at the Right go. Yet another salvo from the National Review shot across the bow of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. Buckley's conclusion is worth quoting in toto:
President Bush endorsed the House bill and asks the Senate to act on
it. He hardly understands himself to be rejecting
MORE
After two days of technical difficulties (maddeningly slow server response), the March 24 issue of Commonweal is finally available. Be sure to check out John J. DiIulio Jr.'s piece, "The Catholic Voter: A Description with Recommendations," Paul Lauritzen's article "Holy Alliance
MORE
A good summary of the findings in the audits released yesterday by the Chicago Archdiocese. (Here's the Chicago Tribune's story.) I haven't had a chance to digest the nearly 100 pages of material, but I invite those who have to evalute the response of Barbara Blaine, president of the Survivors
MORE
Rumors of Deal Hudson's disappearance have been greatly exaggerated. Although the one-time publisher of Crisis left that magazine and his position advising the White House on Catholic matters under a cloud of scandal, he's kept a foot in the game under new auspices. Since January 2005, the Morley
MORE
No, not that FT. The basic-principles variety. You could fill the Grand Canyon with the ink that's been spilled on the subject of the Democrats' post-2004 soul-searching expedition, but every so often something really interesting surfaces in that debate (even the Corner found it intriguing). Just
MORE
"The United States has always been and remains a great defender of human rights and the rule of law," Attorney General Alberto Gonzales told a London think-tank last Tuesday. "I regret that there has been concern or confusion about our commitment to the rule of law."Now why
MORE
Over at the First Things blog, Editor Jody Bottum floats the following theory about the 55 Catholic Democrats' motive for drafting their "Statement of Principles":
But still the question remains: Why the statement now? For someone like Rosa L. DeLauro—or for such signers as Bart Stupak
MORE
(If you've already read this entry, scroll down for new posts.)
Commonweal has never been given to taking up fads. The magazine's concerns regarding the medium of TV, after all, are a matter of public record (see especially our coverage of Edward R. Murrow's broadcasts on Senator Joseph McCarthy
MORE
Was John Paul II responsible for a French nun's sudden recovery from Parkinson's?
"Exactly two months after the death of the pope, from one minute to another, the nun didn't show the symptoms of the illness anymore," Oder told The Associated Press in one of his most extensive
MORE
Wow. The dotCom isn't even a week old and we're already asking whether Commonweal Catholics have a future. It's all so Lenten. For more on the topic du jour, take a look at Mirror of Justice, where Mark's initial post on the subject has generated some interesting responses--including one from
MORE
Take a look at the post below, "A bishop accused." In that post, I quoted one of the more intriguing elements of the AP story about the accusation of abuse against Skylstad, which noted that Stephen Rubino was hired by the woman's legal team to investigate the claim. He's the same lawyer
MORE
The Chicago Tribune reports that Voice of the Faithful has urged Bishop William Skylstad of Spokane and Cardinal Francis George of Chicago to step down temporarily from their positions as president and vice president, respectively, of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops.Earlier this
MORE
Another piece falls into place, reported by Salon. Read the whole article. (And, if you haven't yet, take in Jane Mayer's New Yorker piece on former general counsel to the Navy, Alberto Mora, and his admirable attempts to stem the tide of torture.) Army Reserve Capt. Christopher R. Brinson was in
MORE
Bishop William Skylstad of Spokane, president of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, has been accused by a woman of sexually abusing her over four decades ago, when she was under eighteen and he was in his late twenties. Skylstad denies all charges. Obviously, it's too early to tell
MORE
